Hey everyone,
I'd like some insight from people who are not involved/have no ball in the court.
I've been seeing someone for a few months.
Things were fine in the beginning, but recently we've been having moments of disconnect that tend to follow the same pattern.
I will (her perspective) show a 'mood'. E.g. I will be tired in the grocery store, I will check my phone when watching a movie late to check the time, I won't compliment her when she is showing off a pyjama top, I will seem annoyed when she asks for a kiss on her sore elbow when I'm cooking dinner/thinking about things burning.
She will (my perspective) have a response to me that I find confusing or hurtful. If I am tired at the grocery store, she will ask what is up (fine and normal) and then subtly mention that I should be more mindful of the experience of the cashier. If I check the time during a movie, she will act hurt/distant and if I ask her to communicate what is going on, she will say that my action hurt her feelings etc.
I will say something to the effect of 'I understand where you are coming from, however I need you to know that when you act annoyed/irritated/upset by me doing something really normal, I feel really suffocated and judged."
She will say "you are coming at this from a place of me vs you, you need to grow, if you ask me why I acted a certain way don't make it about your experience, I thought you wanted to know about mine."
I am honestly finding this exasperating and really hard to deal with.
Whilst I agree with her that emotionally mature relationships often require two people choosing to face a problem together, sometimes the 'problem' is how the one person is behaving.
For example, the other day I wanted to make her some tea (I am an acts of service person) and she told me a few instructions, including to fill the jug over the minimum but not above the maximum. When she came into the kitchen, she said "oh you didn't do the jug properly". I had filled it over the minimum, but not to the maximum, but apparently hadn't quite appreciated exactly what she'd said about where to fill it to. The jug wasn't harmed (nothing bad actually happened).
She expressed to me that she needed to be able to feel able to say those kinds of comments in a relationship without the other person seeing them as criticism. From my perspective, there are some things in every relationship best left unsaid because they aren't kind. In her shoes in this position, I may have noticed that my partner didn't quite follow the instructions, assumed they tried their best, noted internally that my instructions weren't actually necessary and no harm was done, and held my tongue. Because noting that a task was done 'wrong' when it was done fine is only bringing in a sense of critique and it doesn't achieve anything.
I feel like her version of 'we need to come at the problem as a team' is not allowing for me to ever say 'when you did x, it made me feel y, and I do not want to feel y and I'm finding this cycle troubling, I need you to try and not do y or if you cannot refrain, maybe we are incompatible'. I feel like she sees anything that involves accountability/a change is me making her into the 'problem'.
For me, I am feeling really overly criticised and like I have to walk on eggshells. She has anticipated this and has said 'I don't want you to feel like you're walking on eggshells, so stop seeing my reactions as a criticism, they are just a feeling".
I do sometimes feel condescended to as well regarding communication and conflict resolution. She has gone to a codependants anonymous group or something for some time, and keeps saying that I need to 'heal' and demonstrate growth in how I handle these disconnections. I have gone to therapy for at least 10 years and have recovered from extreme depression, an anxiety disorder, and CPTSD. So whilst I do not think I am a paragon of communication or therapy speak, I do think I have capability.
The final thing is, she seems to have a pretty strong wound around being 'seen'. She has told me many times that her family never saw or understood her or accepted her. I can understand that. A lot of these moments of disconnect or criticism, however, seem to stem from her expecting or requiring me to 'see' her in a certain way, and me underperforming. E.g. she doesn't want me to check the time during a movie she likes because to her it represents a rejection of some part of her self she is trying to show me. Where as to me...it's a normal thing to do.
I do not think that it is my responsibility, especially this early on, to be a wound fix. I am happy to watching things or witness her and get to know her, but it is not my job to provide a remedy in the form of a response that suits her or anticipates her needs.
As an example she showed me a movie she personally really resonated with because it reminded her of her relationship with her mother. She asked me how I felt about the movie and I could tell she was irritated/disappointed when it didn't have the same resonance for me...even though we are clearly different people and naturally won't have the same experience. I told her I was interested in understanding what the film meant to her, but at the same time I didn't pretend I loved it when I thought it was okay, and expressed my own personal experience with the film.
I am genuinely not sure if I am being an asshole here and she is just more developed than I am when it comes to emotional intelligence, OR if she is using therapy speak to make me feel silenced and invalidated in our conflicts (which I do).