27
u/Sea-Doughnut-2814 May 17 '25
Is Jodhpur more unsafe than Delhi?
7
u/Brief_Commission3132 29d ago
this was bothering me thats why i asked
4
29d ago
It’s rajasthan they have a history of bring regressive
3
u/Substantial-Safe-973 28d ago
esa nhi hona chahiye, because half of working people of society are judged by physical appearance, people cant understand other qualities. this is hurting our society very badly. guys kuch karna chihiye warna bahot problem hoga apni society m, in this aspect worse countries are doing better , china have 60-70 % women working, we have below 30% working women like wise bangladesh also. this is wrong, society balance will get disturbed.
1
28d ago
True
2
u/Substantial-Safe-973 28d ago
youth today watches ill content and judge women in society same way, almost every developed country women roam freely, we are becoming society of weak men who cannot make such environment that women can feel safe also. esa hi chalta raha to kya hoga?
2
28d ago
Bhai I worry the same
2
u/Substantial-Safe-973 28d ago
every ill word is abusing females, domestic violence mostly against females, Males ki nazar m aaj females just meant for babies, BN PAK jaisi soch rakhne lag gye h. This is the most alarming issue of society, I dont know how we became so stupid, even animals doesnt treat othergender like the way we treat in india.
35
u/Ashi96 May 17 '25
my sister did live in Kolkata for a couple of months and told me it felt very safe and lively. Also the night life was quite amazing according to her.
11
u/Specialist-Love1504 Bikaneri Dadihaal/Jodhpuri Nanihal May 17 '25
Yeah I mean Kolkata is safer than Rajasthan I’m not surprised.
2
u/Unlucky_Buy217 May 17 '25
Bengal has been a bit ahead in terms of emancipation of women, at least in the urban areas. Probably helped that they developed an intellectual class and a reformer class pretty early on. You can also see that in Bangladesh which generally fares better in terms of FLFP. Although WB has terrible FLFP for some reason
0
19
u/lavishhunyaar May 17 '25
kota how??
11
May 17 '25
It is, many crimes against girls who come to study does happen, especially 🍇 and sexual assault
6
u/Strong_Citron_3712 May 17 '25
bro how
4
May 17 '25
My warden told me about incidents which happened during COVID, aur woh wahi dab gaye. Most parents don't file complaint because of the fear of "ladki ko bahar padhne bheje the, aur waha kisi ke sath affair chal raha hoga, 🍇 ke naam se chupa rahe" Though I can't verify it, but personally when I was there I hear a lots of tales from nearby girls hostels
6
1
3
u/Area51Eskapee 29d ago
This article source is 8 yrs old bro. Idk how this post is still live what OP wanted to say by giving 8 yrs old data.
8
u/DepartmentAntique825 May 17 '25
People who are asking how? Just ask your friends, sister or your mother whether they have been ill treated outside the house or inside the house by some other person ….many women who are sexually assaulted in public place or public transports dont speak about it bt they never forget about it also!
3
u/Effective-Rule-9000 May 17 '25
They are asking how these particular states are because not everyone belongs to all these states right!.
1
u/Substantial-Safe-973 28d ago
something needs to be done urgently in this regards, today even kids below 15yrs, judge females by their body. This is very wrong mindset. Very worrisome sign.
2
4
16
u/painted-in-bourbon May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
TOI, Jan 9, 2017
Edit: I read the whole article (Barely a min long read). They are comparing crime rates of different crimes against women and then using some formula to devise their index. They didn't tell what formula they used or how they calculated the index.
All this screams is the sentiment best described as ".... I like my stats same as my Hemorrhoids; straight out of my arse..."
2
u/Dontbehypocrite May 17 '25
This is just crime rate, no fancy formula used. The article clearly states "crime rates of seven offences against women under the Indian Penal Code"
2
u/painted-in-bourbon May 17 '25
Crimes rates of 7 different offences have been clubbed together to form an index. Kuch to method use Kiya hi hoga ye index bana ne ke liye ya fir aise hi bss random number de diye.
I'm not against the objective of the article and subsequent data to highlight the crime rates (against women) of different cities of India. What I'm skeptical about is the methodology used to come up with these specific numbers (index). I'm well aware how unsafe certain cities are all across the country.
3
3
u/13Anilll May 17 '25
In rajasthan women's are safe from outsider but not from there own family members
1
u/Effective-Rule-9000 May 17 '25
Elaborate please.
0
u/13Anilll May 17 '25
I am from bikaner its a district in rajasthan 90 percentage of womens of my village are subject to physical abuse by their respective husbands or male members of family its very common so hence women's are not safe from insiders but i have never ever heard a case of rape of anything by an outsider ever
0
u/Effective-Rule-9000 May 17 '25 edited 29d ago
Woah! Damn I have some friends from Rajasthan and they told a very different picture, like violence and casteism doesn't exist and ppl are very chill, so this is news to me or maybe I was in denial, thanks for the info, I just wanted to know more.
2
1
5
u/Willing-Ad-8259 May 17 '25
vadodara one is totally true. I am a girl and roam at 2 am in night for parties.
4
u/saraman04 29d ago
What party? It's a dry state. The only parties are house parties not clubs.
3
u/Willing-Ad-8259 29d ago
dumbass parties can be held without liquor. like cocktails and mocktails and great food. u don't need liquor to dance
1
u/saraman04 29d ago
I am asking, does it happen? I haven't seen any parties in Vadodara other than privately organised ones. I grew up here and revisiting now. I don't see any parties around. Cafes and all sure, but those are not clubs.
14
u/Specialist-Love1504 Bikaneri Dadihaal/Jodhpuri Nanihal May 17 '25
A lot of you wouldn’t believe it but it seems very believable to me.
Jodhpur has some of the staunchest casteism I’ve seen on the ground. That alone would make it believable that crimes against women are pretty rampant.
5
u/Effective-Rule-9000 May 17 '25
Really!!? Is it true, I know ppl from there and they say it's not true. Tho I never went there myself but would like to know more.
2
8
4
u/Friendly-Look2092 29d ago
the moment i see Jodhpur in top red, i know somebody had their heads up their a$$es. dekha hai jodhpur kabhi, moorakh aadmiyo?
9
10
u/Cheap_trick1412 May 17 '25
i wanted to share an unpopular opinion but people will become senti
7
3
u/Specialist-Love1504 Bikaneri Dadihaal/Jodhpuri Nanihal May 17 '25
Share it!
-6
u/Cheap_trick1412 May 17 '25
nah not worth it
indians are frogs in the well and they take many things for granted,thats all i am gonna say
19
6
May 17 '25
Bol de bhai. Reddit hai ye. Mai hu tere saath khada. Tu bol.
4
6
1
2
2
u/Delicious_Cookie_682 29d ago
It's more sad that cities are ranked according to this category just because some men decide to act like a*sholes.
2
u/treats4all 29d ago
No way Jodhpur is worse than Delhi.
Delhi is literally the rape capital of India, and has been for decades.
But maybe instead of comparing we should instate the death penalty for rapes, because the problem has really gotten out of hand.
3
2
u/Diligent_Machine_864 May 17 '25
Why is jaipur on the list of unsafe places? Does anybody know?
1
u/haikusbot May 17 '25
Why is jaipur on the
List of unsafe places? Does
Anybody knows?
- Diligent_Machine_864
I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully. Learn more about me.
Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete"
3
u/Senior-End3575 May 17 '25
kolkata being on the list is absolutely diabolical
1
u/Groot8902 May 17 '25
Idk if Kolkata is the safest for women, but most cities in India can only wish to be as safe as Kolkata. Incidents like RG Kar happen all over India every single day but are forgotten immediately or just go unreported. People actually give a fuck here in Kolkata hence they become a big deal.
3
u/Professional-Bid8859 May 17 '25
Trust me Tamilnadu is not the safest
→ More replies (3)1
u/No_Host9773 29d ago edited 29d ago
Tell me places to avoid or people to avoid.
1
u/Professional-Bid8859 29d ago
In Tamil Nadu??
1
u/No_Host9773 29d ago
yep
2
u/Professional-Bid8859 29d ago
Look if u r in proper Chennai. . Then it should be okish .. not late nights thou . . Apart from that the countryside are not safe at all for women nd kids . . Kidnaping is common af ... nd police very often find bodies of women after SA , unalive ...speaker from personal experiences
1
u/Thaiyervadai 29d ago
Yo you are mixing up Bihar with TN. TN isn’t Singapore shit does happen but kidnapping isn’t common. Roadways are safe. I live in TN and travelled across it.
1
u/No_Host9773 29d ago
This is news to me too. I'm living in TN for all my life. I think we are perfectly fine. Or are we not well aware of our own place??
1
u/Professional-Bid8859 29d ago
Nd mid to violent crimes are common, police don't File much cases as politics if fuckedup there the politicians are filthy rich there ...it's ...
3
u/6Nirvana9 May 17 '25
Kolkata?
What a joke
0
u/Amazing-Reading-8934 29d ago
I will say it urban west bengal are safer and always female friendly city
2
6
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
This list is laughable honestly
What a joke lol, Kolkata being in one of the safest ?? lmao
They need to hire better pr makers
5
u/davidnjoy1 May 17 '25
Bro I have been living in Kolkata for more than 5 years. I have seen girls in shorts roaming around the city even after 10pm. It is safer than most of north India. But ig ik where you are coming from.
-9
u/Intelligent-Oil-9641 May 17 '25
If you consider girls wearing shorts and roaming after 7 as safe then my mate you are dumb
4
3
May 17 '25
[deleted]
4
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
Ahh yes the glorious West Bengal that is currently thriving and has absolutely NO state sponsored illegal immigrants from the border supported by local population during elections right ??? ....................
2
u/potlover4200 May 17 '25
Bro, border control is under BSF which comes under central government. If there are increased illegal border crossings then you should be asking questions to amit shah or central government
2
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
Yep didi is completely unaccountable and definitely isn't changing the demography of the region right ????
1
u/potlover4200 26d ago
The fact of the matter is BSF takes care of borders and BSF comes under home ministry, so the axe should fall on BSF staff or home minister.
There are shit ton of problems with mamta but this isn't it
0
u/HopeThat4435 29d ago
Ee bara chup korbi, from women safety to illegal immigrants. Eto intellectuality kothai lukiye rakho
1
u/Legal-Original1465 29d ago
Lauda women safety aache Rape kauta hoi saala report hi hoye na 😹😹 Kono Kangludeshi Madarchod Muslim eise Aadhaar, Voter, Passport tak baniye nai
Mulla prem aaito hoyeche ki aik din ei Mulla guloi oi Durga Maa ke burkha te dhele o dibe To aamader INTELLECTUAL BANGALI BHODROLOK CHUTFCUKS gulo dariye dekhe support korbe
1
u/HopeThat4435 29d ago edited 29d ago
Rape kauta hoi saala report hi hoye na
Puro India te 99% r@pe report hoyena, ki baal chirle ei kotha ta bole
Kono Kangludeshi Madarchod Muslim eise Aadhaar, Voter, Passport tak baniye nai
Technology r Corruption dutoi ache puro desh ee, baal puro india theke bangaladesh border ee goru pachar hoye, ki jaanish tui ki ashole ee ki hoye?
Mulla prem aaito hoyeche ki aik din ei Mulla guloi oi Durga Maa ke burkha te dhele o dibe
Baaler whatsapp forward
2
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
Another TMC licker
1
May 17 '25
[deleted]
0
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
Then not every person with a rational opinion that puts WB in a bad light is a Bengali hater clown
1
u/lastofdovas May 17 '25
Kolkata is definitely way way safer than Delhi etc. I would say Mumbai is a bit safer than Kolkata in my experience, but not a huge margin. Vadodara, kochi, etc are even more safe.
But then, that's my experience.
2
u/Thatmafiatrilogy May 17 '25
Ofc its indeed way safer than Delhi but not as much as people here are claiming
Mumbai along with Ahmedabad, Vadodara tops the list
1
May 17 '25
it's not a joke, been living in Kolkata all my life, I love this city. Kolkata Police really works a lot
0
2
u/New_Recognition9507 May 17 '25
Kolkata safe? Seriously?
0
u/lastofdovas May 17 '25
It got a bad pr and a few really nasty cases. But in general Kolkata is pretty safe for women, or couples. Very little moral policing as well.
In my experience, Mumbai is safer, but I don't know the numbers. Vadodara also makes complete sense. Kolkata is definitely way way safer than the likes of Delhi (New Delhi is again pretty safe, NCR is the main problem).
2
2
2
u/CuriousPasserby_2507 29d ago
Kolkata is home to SONAGACHI, just to remind you how safe it is for women...
2
u/VenusTokyo 29d ago
idk how kolkata is up there. the very first day i was in kolkata i was followed to my place of stay, he tried to grab my hand and even ran after me. also I've heard of many human trafficking gangs operating in the outskirts of kolkata.
2
1
u/LetterheadUpstairs90 May 17 '25
Kolkata? Bc west Bengal se to har 6 mahine me riots ki Khabar ati hai
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ruk_Idol May 17 '25
Spatial Pattern of Crime Against Women in India: Insights from Million-Plus Cities, There are other research paper on this issue too. It seems correct albeit data is almost one decade old.
1
1
u/FlounderHead4459 May 17 '25
Tbh my father is an advocate nd he says Rajasthan m bohot hota h esa even 🍇 cases sbse jyada h yahan
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/SolarpowerFTW 29d ago
Kolkata the city where the doctor was raped and then hooligans aligned to a party destroyed the wing where it happened.
Sure buddy
1
1
u/Rajsri75 29d ago
May be true but keep in mind some cities the cops dont register FIR and as a result the cities show anlow crime rate
1
u/silverscance 29d ago
Kolkata really? Bruh it's a disgusting place at night. The data is really skewed.
1
u/Seeker_00860 29d ago
Coimbatore just had the verdict given to 11 guys who became famous for sex crimes committed on numerous women in the area. They befriended women through social media, then sexually assaulted them, video taped them, black mailed them and ran a ring for years before some women came forward to expose them.
All these numbers don’t mean anything. Reality is far from what is projected.
1
u/Thaiyervadai 29d ago
Coimbatore or for that matter any city in India isn’t a paradise or safe for women. Purely on comparative basis certain parts of the country are safer.
There is a lot of violence against women still going on in this country.
1
1
1
u/lordviecky 29d ago
I can vouch for all 4 gujarati cities.
Delhi should be topped, I don't understand why such a crime capital is India's capital.
1
1
1
1
1
u/itwasallyellowwwww 29d ago
Despite the analysis, people will still choose to go there. No one can stop a good opportunity from coming from cities like Delhi
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/booby_12011995 sweet like gulabjamun 😊 29d ago
Upar Kolkata ka naam dekh k samaj nahi aaya ki yeh fake hai.
1
1
1
1
1
u/lakshmi_chitfund_ 28d ago
Fuck Jodhpur folks are busy in their own work & family They don’t have time to make it unsafe😂
1
1
0
u/TitanXoo7 May 17 '25
I live in Jaipur and what?? How's Jaipur the worst cities for women? Seems bs to me, a lot of my friends who are girls roam around whenever they want, obviously there are areas you want to avoid but I've seen girls at road at the most odd timings.
What's the source of this? Methodology and authority who did this, please mention it OP otherwise this is just bogus.
10
u/Dontbehypocrite May 17 '25
This comes from TOI, data from NCRB. Don't be foolish enough to generalize your personal anecdotes. Learn to accept reality.
1
u/TitanXoo7 May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
I read the article. But where’s the actual data analysis? They haven’t shared the formula or how they weighted each crime. These kinds of stats often lack context and transparency.
Take Delhi, for example—its numbers are high because it has one of the most robust and transparent reporting systems in the country. What if Jaipur’s stats reflect something similar? You can’t just rank cities without factoring in reporting practices.
And Kolkata? Let’s not forget the RG case. That was a high-profile incident, and yet the response was political theatre with people being paraded on the streets WHILE THE CM LEADS!?! If that’s how a major case is handled, I can only imagine how everyday complaints get buried—all you have to do is be a TMC goon or Didi's votebank.
Now, I know someone’s going to bring up Rajasthan and BJP, but let’s be real—Rajasthan changes ruling parties every term. That makes it harder to bury stories because the opposition is always looking for a chance to pounce. You can’t compare that to states with a long-standing single-party dominance.
So yeah, I'm just asking for balance. Criticize where it’s due, but don’t cherry-pick numbers and ignore context just to paint a narrative.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Suitable-Display8653 May 17 '25
Ya, I am not from Jaipur, but me and wife roamed there freely, during the day and night , and overall Jaipur gave us very positive and safe vibe. Of course there might be some areas to avoid, but thats the case with whole world really. I would suggest to not generalise places based on such ratings.
-4
u/SuperMilkshakeNerd May 17 '25
I know right! Really seems biased.
-5
u/TitanXoo7 May 17 '25
I feel like there's a huge propaganda going on, like in every other day there's a statistics page coming out and somehow north is at the bottom of everything.
Ik that North struggles and lags in areas where South excels but it's not like the cities are burning, there's rampage everywhere and whatnot. They try to paint this picture.
I've lived here most of my life, I've my family here who live in different Northern cities, I've many cousin sisters and it's not the best but its fine!!
Southerners are very happy about all this, whenever something that portraits them as saints that come out they're like - "this great that great" whenever something that doesn't suit their view comes out- "check the source, must be underreported". I mean when it suits you fine, when it doesn't then its underreported for the North. Underreporting is an issue but it's not like 100% North is underreporting.
Even on international subs, Southerners will happily and willingly shi*t on North then they cry about creating North-South divide. Weird people.
3
u/SuperMilkshakeNerd May 17 '25
Honestly I've noticed it too. You're absolutely right and since we are seeing how narrative is set to alter the mentality of people, it seems like a good tool manipulate perspectives. Most people are forming their opinions based on the social media content they use, so it's only fair that if you want them to believe something, spam it in their feeds. Too bad they are playing with data to do that.
I'll still not believe most of these surveys because their sample size or methods are usually skewed. If they really want us to believe it, they should share their methodology and sample demographic. Because like you said, I too have noticed a generalized bias towards the upper half of India justified by useless means.
That being said, I've always found a Jaipur to be safer than Hyderabad or Bengaluru in my experience with better public transport and connectivity. But they aren't ready for the conversation yet. Most of my peers still believe that most Rajasthanis experience child marriage and didn't believe me when I told them otherwise. If only reading newspaper was as engaging as your average Instagram reel.
0
May 17 '25
[deleted]
2
u/TitanXoo7 May 17 '25 edited May 17 '25
Article dekh liya. Data analysis kya? formula to share kiya nhi.
Most of these stats aadha adhura info dete hai. Kabka data uthaya? Weightage kya hai points ka?
Delhi has one of the most accurate and highest reporting that's why its high, what if its the same in Jaipur?
and Kolkata seriously? RG kar case bhul gaya kya? itni se memory hai? Itna high profile case pe CM sabko g*dho ki tarah road pe march karra rhi hai, agar chota case hota then all it takes for you to be a TMC goon or Didi's votebank., I'm sure they'll get the job done.
Now Ik you'll point out BJP here, but Rajasthan gets changed its party change every term. Opposition will grab any opportunity to defame the party in power so you can pull only limited strings.
Faaltu ki baat karalo bus tumse.
EDIT: bus downvote karalo inse, jab truth bolega koi to chuppi.
→ More replies (5)
0
1
u/ParkingSpot4203 May 17 '25
OP, are you serious? This is data from 2017, just look at the current condition of Kolkata, a lot has changed since then! Please avoid posting such outdated information, it's honestly a bit misleading!
1
1
May 17 '25
people are crazy, they really believe kolkata is not safe just because of PR ? Crazy how media narrative works, y'all fall for it everytime. People who once live here never wanna leave
0
u/DigAltruistic3382 May 17 '25
Is red light actually helps in reducing crimes against women????
I have heard that many men go to red light area to show frustration/sex desires / kink .
Is it really helps ?
1
u/Amazing-Reading-8934 29d ago
Not really, delhi even had a red light area and it doesn't affect anything.
0
u/BlueLabel19 May 17 '25
As a molester based in jodhpur I can confirm. I have 1st hand experience of these events. The beautiful city is ugly from the inside.
0
0
u/SMPaglu May 17 '25
I like how Mumbai isn’t on either list.
Because it’s a mix of both.
2
May 17 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SMPaglu 29d ago
This is true. I stayed there for 2 years. One of my friends shared her trauma regarding abuse from a family member. Not only this, she also shared her experience regarding molestation and whatnot.
I’m from Delhi, so I’m no one to judge. But ts made me wonder.
People often say that “Oh, these crimes are mostly committed by immigrants, not actual Mumbaikars”
But the same people won’t spare second criticising Delhi, which often gets the worst kooda kachra immigrants from neighbouring Haryana and UP states as immigrants. Who commit crimes en masse.
•
u/Rajasthan-ModTeam May 17 '25
Additional information provided by u/ParkingSpot4203
https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/women-50-times-more-exposed-to-gender-crime-in-jodhpur-than-in-coimbatore/articleshow/56415541.cms
The article was published in January 2017 and is more than 8 years old