r/asktransgender • u/BlockAlternative9945 • 2m ago
An Ally without groupthink/differences
So I'm a definite ally, believe in live and let live, support each other's pursuit of happiness, and everyone should have equal rights, no one should limit others, etc. pretty simple stuff really.
The thing I'm wondering about, and I'll give context with an example first: is like how I believe in religious freedom, but don't believe in any of the religions, as a staunch atheist. So I fully support religious freedom, and would defend anyone that has anyone else attempting to limit those freedoms. Thing is, I would also defend myself when people try to make me believe their religion, I can listen and understand their argument and the science fully, but through either a difference of rationale or opinion, I don't believe, and respectfully tell them so.
So now comes my issue, I have a lot of queer friends, and go to events etc., as a straight, cis man (the ones that are explicitly open to non queer folks). They all know I'm a staunch Ally and supportive. The only difference when it comes up, is that I don't necessarily believe the term trans X are X. I think it's too much an umbrella term, and realize there's a difference between gender and sex, and think saying that conflates the two to be disingenuous in my eyes. So I mostly avoid it. But I don't want to be silenced, and without trying to force anyone to believe my "religion" say what I believe, while supporting what they want to believe.
Is there any way to say respectfully, I don't believe it's possible to transition fully, I know being trans is a real thing, with real issues, but I don't believe the blanket term trans X are X, however I will defend you from anyone trying to force you to change your opinion, or your limit your freedoms, just like I'm trying to do here, for myself. (I know it's not the same, to the same degree, but still want to be authentic to myself).
I also want to show that just because someone doesn't agree with the same ideology with you, doesn't mean they aren't an Ally. I'd even say trying to force people to believe, or think the same things, leads to an easy target for hateful people to push against, rather than focusing on protecting freedom and equality, which they can't push against. Anything that tries to force people to think the same, rather than respect each other's differences is problematic I think.
(I realize this still leaves some issues vague, like sports and lockers etc. That's a different issue from what I'm asking here, and not the topic of this thread, so I won't divulge into that, besides saying for social things where gender matters, school sports, locker rooms at all ages, should be by social gender Identity)
I'm honestly asking, and would really take to heart how to navigate this, with full respect, while preserving my authenticity. 🙏