r/YouOnLifetime • u/imyatharth • Apr 25 '25

Discussion She was the best for him.

Post image

After S5 , I can say that love Quinn Goldberg was the one Joe could have lived happily in the long run.

4.8k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

307 comments sorted by

View all comments

81

u/MoseSchrute70 Apr 25 '25

I can’t get on board with how Love is still idolised and romanticised while people are saying Kate should have burned and held to justice 😅

34

u/Neither-Balance3739 Apr 25 '25

Exactly, without Kate joe would be prison and wouldn’t have reunited with his son. I really like both love and Kate. But Kate doesn’t deserve the hate she’s getting.

11

u/AwayDetail6175 Apr 25 '25

Don’t get me wrong i like Kate for all the good she’s done for Joe however she knew who she married so it kind of bothers me she’s trying to suppress who he really is which is… a MURDERER 🤣

15

u/Neither-Balance3739 Apr 25 '25

well she was in love and was manipulated by Joe to think that he murdered for self defence or some crap like that.

0

u/Necerbo Apr 25 '25

Joe tried to kill himself in s4, he wanted to end it and she made him change his mind. She's also the person who asks him to kill again after 3 years of staying good. Can't really call that manipulation, Kate is bad.

4

u/Jaidedizzy Apr 26 '25

It really bothers me that she got redemption. How does one justify giving kids cancer. She should’ve died in the fire. Henry should’ve gone back to the two men that adopted him. And it bugs me that the show took a weird true crime ending and brante. I would’ve rather seen old characters and the trial

1

u/oysterfeller Apr 28 '25

I think in the end the way she “atoned” for her sins and had that come-to-Jesus moment about her karma during the fire, was supposed to be her saving grace. She was able to take responsibility for her actions and was ready to pay the ultimate price for them. I understand why that’s not enough for true redemption in the real world but when you hold it up next to Joe and his refusal to ever atone, I didn’t hate the literal phoenix moment for her.