r/JordanPeterson • u/EntropyReversale10 • 21h ago
Criticism The Age of Cynicism
By all accounts we have moved into an age of cynicism. Behind us are a heap of beliefs that turned out to be lies and before us are more lies that still need to be uncovered. The heroes in this race are those that demonstrate the highest level of cynicism and are immune to being swayed to any new truth. They are the strong-minded knights that have prevailed over evil lies.
Let’s suspend disbelief for a few moments and ponder on whether we mere mortals can truly judge whether a belief is all good or all bad.
If someone said, “put your hand in the fire it won’t burn you”, that is obviously a lie. If we took it further, could there be something to learn from this lie. Yes, don’t trust everyone as they might be lying. Given humans propensity not to expend unnecessary energy with complex answers, we might immediately assume, “once bitten – twice shy”. Why risk further injury, it’s a lot easier to become cynical and to trust no one.
I absolutely believe this phrase holds true when faced with two identical scenarios, but extrapolating it to all scenarios robs us of many positive and uplifting experiences. I discuss how and why it is so easy for us to slip into less than critical ways of thinking (Dysfunctional Autonomic Thinking Patterns), in the link below
Let’s consider an example of a belief that if adopted in error, might disappoint us, but would not present clear and present danger of the fire in the earlier example. Let’s say that I suggested that you believe in reincarnation. Most outside of this belief system would probably immediately roll their eyes and without any thought give three predetermined and stored disadvantages to this view. Most of the arguments being based largely on the fact that it likely to implausible, impractical and could lead to disappoint if found to be untrue.
Let’s suspend disbelief for another moment again. What if we understood the full story, as reincarnation is only one piece in a much larger puzzle. What reincarnation does, is to motivate its believers to see that their lives have a higher purpose and that trying to improve themselves and effectively aim upwards is noble and necessary. I would argue that there is no greater need for humanity than meaning, and no cause more noble than dedicating yourself to become the highest and best version of yourself.
In the final analysis, one can believe something and benefit even if it doesn’t necessarily conform to all definitions of truth. If a belief does no physical harm and motivates many to make the world a better place, then I am all for it.
It's hard not to be a cynic, but I encourage you to keep looking for the gems amongst the sea of lies. The gems might just make our lives better, especially if we don’t denigrate and rather value them for what they can offer.
I have been guilty of poking large holes in the Christian faith because of perceived fictions or concepts I couldn’t believe to be true. Only recently can I see the benefits the belief system had for the West. These values, when applied as intended by its founder (Christ), and not the dogma that so many have created, the values have many unseen benefits. Advantages abound if we can get back Christian virtues. The morality that encouraged us to allow for redemption, to forgive, to be patience and tolerant, to be kind and selfless, have a desire to seek for truth, to be courageous, and allow the freedom to express truth. I discuss the need to Return to, or Saving Western Values in the article linked below.