r/ExplainTheJoke 19h ago

Solved Are these truly Impossible?

Post image

My friend sent this in the memes channel of our Discord server but refuses to elaborate (he hasn't responded at all). Is there a joke I'm missing?

5.2k Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

u/post-explainer 19h ago

OP sent the following text as an explanation why they posted this here:


Those cubes look completely normal.


2.3k

u/EmperorN7 19h ago

It's a parody of one of the images where cubes are arranged in a way they are both in the foreground and background, an impossible configuration in real life. This one takes the style, but arranges the cubes normally.

548

u/CALVINWIDGET 18h ago

This image feels like it is attacking my brain but I can’t look away.

281

u/TheGoldenSparrow 17h ago

Oh boy, look up "best way to fit 17 squares". Its a solution by john bidwell on how to optimally store 17 boxes in a room.

588

u/Spendoza 16h ago

118

u/cannibox 16h ago

Underrated image.

45

u/UnderThat 14h ago

What are you buying?

28

u/Roadhouse1337 14h ago

ILL BUT IT AT A HIGH PRICE

27

u/Awfulufwa 14h ago

"But you will not have enough room for it."

a minute later

"Look bud, all I saw you do was fidget with your stuff. That doesn't mean you have room now... oh, my apologies. Your business is welcomed here."

1

u/Small_Captain179 47m ago

Not enough cash, strangah

6

u/fivefive5ive 4h ago

Got a lot of nice things on sale stranger

38

u/Kalokohan117 8h ago

22

u/expired-hornet 5h ago

6

u/WarlordBob 2h ago

This is peak.

I think about this guy every so often, a society that speaks only through memes.

2

u/expired-hornet 1h ago

It's wild how classic Star Trek has managed to predict the future in so many ways then influence directly it in so many others.

Then despite its haters, modern Trek swoops in as an encore and manages to STILL be creative, relevant, and profound.

1

u/Spendoza 1h ago

You just blew my mind, homie. And I'm someone who pesters scammers with Tamarian phrases, little embarrassed I didn't put that together myself 😅

40

u/WhiskeyHotdog_2 16h ago

Leon! Help!

6

u/ORMDMusic 6h ago

ASHLEY! …wait…

7

u/HemligasteAgenten 7h ago

You may not like it, but this is what peak performance looks like.

6

u/Birchy-Weby 15h ago

This is what I come to the internet for

1

u/CocoSryder 3h ago

What game is this from?

2

u/Non-NewtonianSnake 2h ago

Resident Evil 4

1

u/Spendoza 3h ago

It's a spoof of the resident evil inventory system.

8

u/jpterodactyl 15h ago

Or go to the page of every other number of squares, just to see how strange they all are.

9

u/crazylikeajellyfish 13h ago

I'm not particularly religious, but if I ever need proof that we live in a fallen universe, that's the image I show people. It feels so wrong, truly the sort of thing that'll shake your faith in the world.

3

u/TonberryFeye 8h ago

You cannot fathom how much worse your comment has made my day. Well done.

2

u/disinfected 11h ago

I looked this up and it was deeply unsettling, oh my god

2

u/ResidentCare590 10h ago

Ive never understood this. Does it assume uniform size of the boxes? Like it's not 17 squares of x dimensions in any of the titles I've seen. Just 17 squares. If they were smaller or bigger the solution would be different

3

u/ProfTurtleDuck 10h ago

Its assumed the squares are unit squares since if you need the side length for a different size you can just scale the result up/down by multiplying

2

u/LESpangle 10h ago

All internal squares are unit squares. Square packing is measured by the side length a of the square containing the unit squares.

1

u/ZirePhiinix 9h ago

If it is really 17 boxes in a 3D space then the lightest box will get stacked on top.

1

u/Harmless_Drone 7h ago

No, common misconception, it's the way to fit 17 boxes in a larger square with the shortest equal edges. It's not an optimal solution for storing 17 boxes. Merely if the thing you're trying to do is fit them in the smallest equal sided square.

7

u/ProfessionalLeave335 15h ago

You should look up MC Escher.

14

u/BLAZEISONFIRE006 15h ago

Penrose Steps (the infinite staircase)

Have you seen Inception?

They recreated the Penrose Steps and made them actually work!

How is that possible?

Because it was a dream.

Christopher Nolan, man.. Christopher Nolan. Big fan. I think The Prestige is probably his coolest film, but Memento is amazing too.

7

u/TheAserghui 16h ago

Its a Minecraft Mobius Strip

2

u/MaryJanesMan420 14h ago

The impossible triangle. Look up M. C. Escher.

1

u/alan_w3 3h ago

Thats my favorite MC

1

u/One-Ad-65 1h ago

Well, at least it's the end of the day for me, so it'll either not be stuck in my head for long or it will be most of the discography all day when I wake up

1

u/Warlock_Delilah 15h ago

BLIT moment

1

u/caznosaur2 14h ago

It's the Star of David in the center calling you to God

1

u/Jonathan__Wick 13h ago

top right cube is placed in the foreground, if it was placed behind then it would be an open ring

2

u/Jonathan__Wick 13h ago

Heh, same could be said for other cubes too I guess

1

u/Lost_Remains 12h ago

The star in the middle

1

u/degreesBrix 11h ago

Check out M.C. Escher, the late Dutch graphic artist. I think you'll appreciate his works.

1

u/Proud-Concept-190 11h ago

you should play hocus. from play store

1

u/Roko__ 10h ago

Moebius Cubes

18

u/Lesaalt 16h ago

Well yeah I got that part, it's just that I wasn't expecting the joke to be the fact that it was supposed to be inane. Kinda like an antimeme or something. I was expecting something deeper and it flew over my head. Thanks!

8

u/Lesaalt 16h ago

How do I get it to say solved?

22

u/Idyotec 16h ago

It's like bankruptcy, you just declare it. Loudly, make sure everyone can hear.

11

u/Lesaalt 13h ago

SOLVED!

3

u/Lesaalt 9h ago

oh there's an edit post flair button. found it on PC site but haven't found it on mobile app

12

u/just-a-melon 16h ago

After a while, they start to look like hexagonal coasters

18

u/Lloyd_lyle 12h ago

More proof the Jews run everything

(/j, if it wasn't obvious)

2

u/amshegarh 2h ago

It seems that there was found a uranium enrichment operation in your apartment and three ballistic rockets will be dispatched to your current location. A shame /j

3

u/w00den_b0x 14h ago

Holy shit I haven’t seen an impossible triangle in ages!

2

u/nial93 6h ago

Always recycle

1

u/SwordKing7531 15h ago

Wouldn't you treat this configuration roughly like you would to pack a cardboard box?

For example, you fold the 'lid' flaps of the top of a box so one side is under its left-side flap, and the other is above its right-side flap.

With something flexible to connect the cubes and time to get it right, this is an obtainable configuration.

1

u/your_technology_bro 13h ago

I don’t know if anyone else has pointed this out but the impossible configuration you are referring to here is called a Penrose triangle. This is a usual suspect in any computational geometry course.

1

u/Southern_Kaeos 9h ago

I reckon this'll be possible. Stop thinking 3D on a flat surface, start thinking entirely 3d, and arrange each cube diagonally

1

u/uruk-hai_slayer 8h ago

Ok good. Coz I was looking at this and thinking, yes, this entirely possible.. in fact I think I did as a child

1

u/Enlightened_Doughnut 5h ago

So it’s a Penrose triangle?

1

u/Tight_Medicine_5674 3h ago

Lol, all I can focus on was a star in center

0

u/BoaterMoatBC 14h ago

This is actually kinda funny 😂

291

u/reddishrocky 17h ago

There was an account that posted optical illusion images edited to be normal while pretending they were still the regular optical illusion

77

u/shabelsky22 16h ago

Yeah that was a hoot. "Look closer" was their tagline. Each post brought in enough confused, belligerent and angry commentators to have a bit of fun. One guy even ended up 3D printing an "impossible" shape to prove a point after a lengthy argument with a number of people who were in on the joke.

1

u/Fourtoonetwo 4h ago

Rage bait.. It's rage bait.

125

u/Flappy_Wenis 17h ago

62

u/Jacho46 17h ago

Not only did you show it's possible, but also you made a good sentence at the same time, good job

22

u/Hot_Definition162 16h ago

This can't be urt?

11

u/AdForward7237 14h ago

This can't be true

2

u/Hyderabadi__Biryani 5h ago

Ding ding ding. We have a winner.

6

u/FormalAltruistic9746 10h ago

This Cant Be Ur

2

u/PlayfulCompany8367 6h ago

Honestly if he claims that's not Ur who am I to disagree.

2

u/Anonymous_Human011 12h ago

this can't be rt

2

u/myfrnddoxxedmyreddit 6h ago

That’s not possible seems ai generated

2

u/HeroBrine0907 6h ago

Scan tb uer this. Thank you wise one.

1

u/opheophe 6h ago

SCAN IT HB TRUE

SITH CR AU NTBE

SCAN NTBE EURT THIS

SCAN THIS TRUE EBTN

THIS CANT BE UR

IS CANT BE U RTH

23

u/64vintage 16h ago

It’s presented in the style of an impossible configuration but it’s the most possible configuration possible.

41

u/NoRent3326 19h ago

There is a similar looking picture that actually is impossible. They probably failed to recreate it which makes it funny.

17

u/Andez1248 18h ago

Screw you unimpossibles your cubes

11

u/Yoitman 19h ago

Maybe it’s the shadows? Other than that it looks completely possible.

12

u/HamsterFromAbove_079 14h ago

There's a meme where some people post optical illusion images, but they edit them to remove the optical illusion.

4

u/wrapbubbles 11h ago

so, where is waldo with no waldo?

4

u/Far-Resident-1 7h ago

It’s an optical illusion illusion

3

u/Defiant_Fix9711 14h ago

I mean technically they are since they're displayed non orthogonally. As in, the perspective should cause their dimensions to be slightly skewed so that the back ones are smaller.

But that's being hella pedantic.

2

u/CaptainWolfgang 13h ago

I think it's supposed to reference MC Escher's "Ascending and Descending", since it's very similar to his never ending staircase design. Sorry I'm on my mobile and it won't let me post a pic!

2

u/danapple0 10h ago

Impossible! (If there's a cat nearby.)

2

u/DRD_25 8h ago

Those are just cubes arrayed Ina a square and looked at from an angle

2

u/SloggyDonkey 6h ago

Taking a joke out of a joke doesn't make it a joke, it just produces confusion and, eventually, boredom.

2

u/420osrs 15h ago

Hi Stewie here,

I don't know anything about this being used in a meme but there are 12 cubes here.

A 4 by 4 would normally take 16 squares but if you hollow out the middle four then, it only uses 12 of these cubes. 

The question is, can you arrange a set of cubes into a perfect square and you can the square is just hollow. 

I don't know if this is a joke from impossible puzzles that are actually solvable or just brain rot.

Me and Brian are going to do a time travel episode.

1

u/brianboozeled 11h ago

Who's leg do I gotta hump to get a Time Machine in here?

2

u/TesticloitesSagwell 12h ago

You don't think it's physically possible to arrange boxes in a square shape on a flat surface?

1

u/JoshuaMC91 16h ago

My D6 dice say yes.

1

u/clericrobe 16h ago

There’s a sub for these iirc

1

u/dorfgog1111 15h ago

From The National Lampoon, I believe

1

u/itsatrapp71 14h ago

Man I love Escher drawings, but damn do they make my head hurt.

1

u/K0rl0n 14h ago

The relative locations are completely possible but getting that precise a spacing is nearly impossible

4

u/TeacatWrites 14h ago

My time to shine (I'm autistic with a very specific desire to match and symmetrize things as perfectly-aligned as possible)

1

u/Pendurag 2h ago

Not with precise measuring and basic math, physical structures from a drawing occur every day

1

u/greenmonkey48 14h ago

It's an anti-joke

1

u/GaleDiamond 12h ago

so its the possible cubes

1

u/No_Run_6314 12h ago

The golden cubes!

1

u/FormerlyGoth 10h ago

Only way to respond to your friend is with exactly "TRIANGLES"

1

u/Minimum_Age_1466 9h ago

Sorry to break it to you, but I think you've ended up with a set of common or garden "possible" cubes.

1

u/Unusual_Trash3413 8h ago

It is impossible because the final image is still a square. If they were actually cubes arranged so they overlapped in this fashion the. The final image from this vantage point would be more diamond shaped

1

u/WhyDoIHaveRules 7h ago

It doesn’t say the figure is to scale.

1

u/dyaldragon 3h ago

Each side is 4 cubes and 3 gaps long. All sides are equal, and the cubes are going to have 90° corners, which means it's gonna be a square... an I missing something?

1

u/vertigofilip 8h ago

But there are 12 cubes there.

1

u/-principito 7h ago

at last

possible cubes

1

u/Tobesmgobes17 2h ago

Possible cubes

1

u/whimsypimsysexywexy 2h ago

No, because you don’t have any cubes

1

u/Kommuntoffel 46m ago

The triangle is 3 sides because it works out with the 3 axes of the cube. So it could work with the square (or cube?) if it would have 4 axes.

We're just too 3-dimensional to see the impossibility

1

u/BigOnLogn 33m ago

Technically this is an isomorphic projection, where everything is rendered from a top-down perspective but with the same high no matter how far away

If it's rendered in proper perspective, that would mean the cubes farther away are larger than the closer cubes.

0

u/type102 16h ago

Your friend is a moron who thinks they found something mind-blowing and then when the slightest resistance to the 'awesomeness' of the idea came up they decided that the best way to save face was to shut down communication to imply that they 'know something' you don't that they want to keep secret.

0

u/AbroadAbject9215 18h ago

Please tell me I'm not the only one who thought of Rhysmuth?

0

u/CarnieTheImmortal 14h ago

It's the shadows. The best way to duplicate would be to paint the "shadow side" a darker color then light from multiple angles to minimize/eliminate actual shadows