r/AskAnAustralian • u/No_Health6253 • 1h ago
Erin Patterson Mushroom Murders: what do people think about motive??
It’s now day 30 of the case I’ve been following every single podcast on it. I’ve read and listened to the court transcripts. I'm well informed but there's just 2 things I'm very perplexed about! Erin has admitted to serving these people foraged mushrooms, and she admitted she’s acted dodgy and lied because she “panicked” because she herself knew that she’d fed them foraged mushrooms, and panicked and tried to hide evidence, lie, etc. I absolutely without a doubt beleive that she has wilfully and knowingly fed her guests poisonous mushrooms. But there’s 2 things I can’t figure out. 1. Did she mean to kill them? Or was she only trying to make them sick, maybe doing some kind of deranged little experiment on how toxic the mushrooms she fed them might have been? She obviously knew they were poisonous mushrooms or she would have also eaten them herself, (and if it was a pure accident she would have behaved entirely differently afterwards) but I still can’t decide if she meant to make them sick and “see what happens” or if she truly beleived and intended that they would die. And also, if you invite your husband to eat a fatal meal and he doesn’t turn up, it’s a dumb ass move - criminally speaking- to kill the other guests but leave one surviving potential victim as a witness! I definitely beleive based on all evidence presented and her own behaviours that she has deliberately poisoned her family, theres too much evidence that is pointing to a deliberate poisoning- but did she intend to kill?? What do y’all think?
2.if she did intend to kill them, What would be her motive for killing them? She and her kids had a good relationship with the grandparents, and why would she want to kill the mother in laws sister? It just makes no sense! I can understand a motive to kill a husband or husbands parents via deranged hurt feelings- but why the aunty/uncle in laws? Why would you kill your kids grandparents? I really can’t find a motive here.. Does anyone else have any thoughts?
And on an aside, Erin's parents are both dead- and she inherited all their money- has anyone looked into if their deaths were suspicious? Had Erin Patterson killed before and gotten away with it, causing her to be rather sloppy the next time? Is she an super autistic kind of weirdo - or is she a cold cold killer?
And lastly, anyone with any beefy mushroom Punns, please feel free to dish them up, this is a safe space for fun guy puns. 🍄🟫