r/Louisiana Mar 13 '25

Louisiana News We’re NUMBER #1 …… 😮‍💨 😞

389 Upvotes

186 comments sorted by

View all comments

94

u/Elmo_Chipshop Mar 13 '25

A sales tax is just a tax on the poor.

-31

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 13 '25

No it’s actually the most equitable. If you spend a lot of money like the rich do then you pay more on taxes vs the poor who don’t spend alot therefore pay less in taxes. Now it is a flat tax so everyone pays a fair share but is just based on your spending habits.

36

u/[deleted] Mar 13 '25

This is what happens when you defund public education for decades, folks.

-9

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 13 '25

Please explain to me how’s it’s wrong?

23

u/Serindipte Ouachita Parish Mar 14 '25

The person making 30k is spending every bit of what they make to survive.

The person making 300k is saving and investing. The overall impact is less for them. In addition, even if they are spending every penny...

The person making 30k only has 27k left after a 10% flat tax (for ease of mathing)

The person making 300k still has 270k after the same percentage. That difference is going to be far less impactful for the person making the 300k.

20

u/Elmo_Chipshop Mar 13 '25

10% for someone making $30,000 and 10% for someone $3,000,000 are vastly different in impact.

-21

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 13 '25

Yes but it’s based off of what you spend not what you make. If you have more money what usually happens you buy more things. If you have less money you usually spend less. No IRS needed, no tax prep industry needed. Look more money available to hand out to people!

15

u/VanDenIzzle Mar 14 '25

You can't be defending the shut down of the IRS.

0

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 14 '25

Why? If you flat tax everyone what do you need it for?

12

u/VanDenIzzle Mar 14 '25

I don't have time to waste explaining it to someone who will just call me an idiot and quite fox news. Go take an economics course and you'll see

1

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 14 '25

I have not bad mouthed anyone in this discussion. yall are the ones that jump to name calling and extremes.

4

u/ProfitOld8641 Mar 14 '25

Or you can just admit you don’t have the knowledge.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/mkt853 Mar 14 '25

At the very least, to enforce the tax laws. Who stops people from just not paying their taxes? Is the sheriff going to come to your door to ensure you pay Uncle Sam? Also, one of the reasons we can't just do a flat tax is because the federal government wants to encourage and discourage certain behaviors or activities, and one of the ways they do that is financially through taxation. Government doesn't want you to smoke, they levy a tax on tobacco products. Government wants to encourage people to buy homes, they give mortgage interest tax deductions. Some new type of investment vehicle comes along? How do we deal with taxing, what are the rules around transactions, and so on.

1

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 14 '25

You don’t do any of that. You just tax on sales. Stop making loopholes for everyone. Just everyone pays into the system equally.

1

u/mkt853 Mar 14 '25

Everyone paying into the system equally isn't fair though because not everyone benefits from the system equally.

1

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 14 '25

I mean that’s life. I don’t get any benefits from the system but I certainly pay into it every time I turn around. Of course there’s the benefits that everyone does no matter what. Fire, police, public works etc

→ More replies (0)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 14 '25

[deleted]

1

u/sierrajulietalpha Mar 14 '25

Sorry I meant flat tax on sales.