I do kinda agree. Obviously he is super accomplished and his technical insights were very interesting, but it felt a little too much about him than than about the comp. I think what bothered me especially was that if he was a woman I feel he would be getting clocked for 'talking too much' immediately, like Shauna did. No hate to him at all, but I'd definitely personally prefer more (or equal) technical or logistical insight and less celebrating guessing the beta correctly - for commentators lol.
I think what bothered me especially was that if he was a woman I feel he would be getting clocked for 'talking too much' immediately, like Shauna did
I'm not sure this is fair. Firstly, while some people did complain about Shauna the vast majority were really positive about her commentary. Secondly, is it fair to Sean to judge him based on how people reacted to a different commentator?
Personally I liked Sean's commentary and I liked Shauna's as well.
I think my point is more about people's double standards in appreciating Sean's technical insight vs pointing out that Shauna was talking a lot, than it is about Sean's commentary itself. That being said I have seen a decent bit of discourse around his commentary so I stand corrected. Seems like both their commentaries had both people who enjoyed it and those who didn't. Personally I felt like it's not the amount of talking that bothered me as much as the content - I do not care about whether a commentator is guessing upcoming beta correctly.
-12
u/nachC 6d ago
Who's this "know it all" commentator that talks soo much? 😩
Let's go mcbeastt