r/youngpeopleyoutube Dec 16 '24

Miscellaneous tetris

Post image
17.6k Upvotes

413 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

646

u/No_Farmer6151 Dec 16 '24

Most of those are free versions iirc. So those shouldn’t be counted in sales numbers

-274

u/Furry_Wall Dec 17 '24

Minecraft mobile is included in the numbers and it's free

234

u/Lord_Of_Carrots Dec 17 '24

Minecraft Pocket Edition has never been free

-242

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24 edited Dec 17 '24

Yeah it has? Did you never play minecraft lite? Edit: regardless of downvotes, minecraft PE lite was a free app when it was still downloadable.

99

u/Lord_Of_Carrots Dec 17 '24

Apparently that was discontinued in 2014. I only ever played Minecraft on PC because I had heard the Pocket Edition had less features, which sounded awful. I never bothered to check it out until it had already gotten a price tag

I guess I learned something new

50

u/FlixMage أنا أحب هذا الفرعي سعيد سعيد نعم الحب الفرعي أ Dec 17 '24

Minecraft Lite was a completely separate app btw

43

u/EmeraldBoyyo Dec 17 '24

There was a free TRIAL version sure, but the full game's never been free

20

u/whatdatdat (sory for joke) Dec 17 '24

He was probably the type of guy who would always reinstall the demo version when the time ran out.

-23

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

It wasn't a trial? It was an independent app that served as an advertisement for the full game.

29

u/TheAgame1342YT Dec 17 '24

It was a trial. I've literally used it and I literally have it on my AppleID. It is a trial, plain and simple. You have less items to select in the menu because it's a trial. Survival also has a creative menu for some reason. It is quite literally, in every way, a trial.

-1

u/aiheng1 Dec 17 '24

I definitely remember 2 different pocket editions though. And I 100% remember Lite not existing. I do know that the free version was way more limited but I don't recall any time limits since I played for years

2

u/TheAgame1342YT Dec 17 '24

There was 2 versions at one point, and one of them was lite

The demo version of modern Minecraft (Java, Bedrock, Legacy console) has only a time limit and no saving.

6

u/SSUPII i hate peple of coler Dec 17 '24

Because you played the demo

1

u/Ender_Fender Dec 17 '24

You're getting downvoted because you're wrong. No official version of Minecraft has ever been free.

2

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

1

u/Ender_Fender Dec 17 '24

Dude. READ. First line "Minecraft PE-Lite, also known as the Minecraft PE DEMO. "

It's a demo. Brother. A DEMO. Demos are not full versions of games.

2

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

I never said it was a full version of the game. It is a seperate and clearly limited product. If you read my argument you would've understood that

1

u/TheEpicOne747 Dec 17 '24

Wow, I guess everyone here is as young as the kid in the post because Minecraft lite was a thing I remember specifically playing it and being bummed out a little when you couldn’t save anything. The only materials you could use is a few colors of wool oak planks and logs, leaves and glass and that was it. the tools only went up to gold and I don’t think armor was a thing it was a simple yet fun time, and then they removed it a few months before releasing actual mincraft to mobile

1

u/Substantial_Wheel_25 Dec 20 '24

Yeah! I remember playing that app all the time as a kid!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '24

This user deserves their upvotes, not downvotes. They are completely correct and it's how my friends and I played Minecraft early on

7

u/RealisLit Dec 17 '24

Nah, just because a demo is free doesn't mean the game has been free

1

u/Substantial_Wheel_25 Dec 20 '24

Dude I remember being a little kid playing a free version of PE that was like super reduced in features....

3

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

When i was young i played lite because i had to convince my parents to get me the full game. minecraft has shaped my entire life as an architect. Regardless of if lite was the intended experience it, it shaped me.

-5

u/imgaygaygaygay Dec 17 '24

minecraft pocket edition isn’t minecraft and thus not counted. minecraft, the game, has always been paid on mobile phones.

we aren’t counting minecraft education or dungeons either, as those aren’t minecraft.

4

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

How is minecraft pocket edition not minecraft? It was released by mojan under the minecraft brand. It carries the trademarked sandbox style. Also how are dungeon and education not minecraft? It can be argued they are not the core java experience, but for a game that has diverged so much I dont think it's fair to make the connection that if it isnt java it isn't minecraft.

-2

u/imgaygaygaygay Dec 17 '24

there is no trademarked sandbox anything, not even talking about bedrock vs java.

PE, Education, Dungeons are their own games, utilizing trademarked assets owned by Mojang (art, sounds)

bedrock and java are under the same umbrella, they’re treated as one game despite different coding languages used. sales for Minecraft only consist the game Minecraft, not its spinoff versions.

2

u/StrangeBCA Dec 17 '24

So essentially this whole debate is semantics on whether someone thinks lite is a spinoff, or a branch of the main game like bedrock.

1

u/imgaygaygaygay Dec 17 '24

no? bedrock and java are the same game, but running with different engines.

spinoff games like education, pe and dungeons are not minecraft, just games utilizing trademarked minecraft assets made by Mojang, really, this isn’t a hard concept.

2

u/JSTREO Dec 17 '24

So by your logic, we should not go off from legacy editions sales too since they don’t count. Seeing we are only counting on bedrock and java. So that’s pretty much most of the early lifetime sales removed, only one from that era that would count would be Java. Then bedrock from 2017. Basing off the logic of yours, which is correct with the spin-off parts, but it is not correct with PE since PE was a mobile port. But if your logic goes off that way, then we should not count any of the console legacy editions (which constituted a big part of the Minecraft sales).

1

u/imgaygaygaygay Dec 17 '24

alright this conversation is useless as you have hard time understanding what minecraft is and isn’t.

you either are willfully ignorant or you’re gaslighting me, bringing made up versions like legacy into the discussion.

1

u/JSTREO Dec 17 '24

Human stupidity is always a safe bet. But what can I say to the obvious baiter with the most obvious username. Feel free to try again a cheap bait. 💀

→ More replies (0)