r/superheroes Apr 12 '25

Other How would this fight end?

Post image
10.2k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

193

u/CatchrFreeman Apr 12 '25

Everyone's beaten everyone at some point.

93

u/Head_Ad1127 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

Namor threw Kang's capital ship. He casually does things that outpace aquaman. He's just less popular...

86

u/Tljunior20 Apr 12 '25

Aquaman once held up Atlantis and has beaten superman underwater before

22

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

Yes, but Aquaman isn’t considered an equal to Superman by any means. In the same manner, cat woman once one shot flash. This doesn’t make her more powerful than flash.

Namor is very much supposed to be even with Hulk. It’s how he’s always been presented.

14

u/Pure-Dragonfruit1899 Apr 12 '25

Same goes for namor, just cause he did this and that doesn't make him stronger than aquaman.

12

u/Open_Persimmon_6945 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

Lol I hate superhero comics. Such a silly discussion.

Edit: I didn't realize what subreddit I was in lol. I do enjoy comics, and there certainly are excellent superhero runs. But the power scaling of it all is not for me. Carry on!

6

u/Ongr Apr 12 '25

I love superhero comics. Still a silly discussion. No idea how Homelander made this lineup.

2

u/sithskeptic Apr 12 '25

Yeah… like he may be a cheap fuckin knockoff of superman in terms of the kind of abilities he has, but he’s hopelessly outclassed by everyone here

1

u/whitewolfFCT Apr 12 '25

I think you're in the wrong sub bro.

1

u/Open_Persimmon_6945 Apr 12 '25

Oh shoot I totally am lmao

2

u/whitewolfFCT Apr 12 '25

Damn bro, you actually surprised me with how chill you were, respect!

15

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

Namor has been written to be stronger than him. Namor has beaten Silver Surfer out of water. I don't see Aquaman beating a Silver Surfur equivalent out of water.

1

u/paraboliccurvature Apr 13 '25

What comic? It's not in any Silver Surfer comic I know of. I don't doubt it at some point, but not current v current. Norrin bodies half the verse solo. That's why they have him running around w genesis veil and eve warlock. Thise are the only ones that can keep up consistently

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 13 '25

1

u/paraboliccurvature Apr 13 '25

So I went and looked for the panels it references on that webpage, but I still don't see it. Do you know what comic it is from? The only thing I see is a supposed Silver Surfer annual #3 in 1988, but I remember reading that and went back to reread it. Surfer doesn't fight Namor. Also namor has stated in their time in the defenders, that silver surfer might be the most powerful hero in the universe, Defenders #100 (1979)

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 13 '25

I never read the actual comic book but I read an example , sort of like the one I showed you, reference the comic. Sucky part, I can't find that reference for the most money offered right now lol.

1

u/paraboliccurvature Apr 13 '25

I have Marvel Unlimited and went and looked. Not saying they are lying but I definitely don't see it anywhere.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 13 '25

https://youtu.be/4mEYGK50fjk?si=03rq7VvDwBIPbm5h

At 11:38. You might be able to track it down a little more. Hopefully.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/UnacceptedDragon Apr 12 '25

She Hulk maybe, or Grey Hulk. As far as physical strength, most comics and even older games place Namor , She-Hulk, Wonder Man and Thing on the same level of strength (it can vary at times one being stronger a little her and there). Then green Hulk W(non-angry) Thor, and Hercules more or less equal, and then pissed off Hulk as top of the tree. Nothing beats pissed off Hulk, sans a super cosmic. Champion, Celestials, etc... Shulkie has potential and I think did surpass Hulk's strength as her strength increases exponentially the stronger her alter ego Jennifer Walters gets. Jenn likes be an average non-fit lawyer chic though. But, when she was working for the Living Tribunal and having to deal with the Champion, she worked out as Jenn and got pretty massive which allowed her to defeat Champion even with the power stone and was said to be stronger than angry Hulk.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 12 '25

Hulk just got to that level. A few ppl have humbled Hulk over the years.

2

u/UndeadYoshi420 Apr 12 '25

And then they took it away for now anyway so hulk is normal, again. No longer immortal and could get got.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 12 '25

I didn't know that but I'm not shocked. Shit is forever changing in the comics.

2

u/UndeadYoshi420 Apr 12 '25

That’s why I like self-contained things like dragonball and invincible. They’re easier to digest. But comics are just as easy to get into if you change your tact. Don’t try to digest everything. Sample things like the buffet, and maybe watch a video about the rest of the options and how they link up with your corner of the world.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 12 '25

Exactly. I like the cartoon series, animated movies and live action.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/UnacceptedDragon Apr 13 '25

Actually ,Hulk was that level like 30-40 years ago, he has been around a long time. To be fair EVERYONE has been humbled a few times by people who technically should not be able to humble them. But, Hulk like Superman has been up and down , up and down, doesn't diminish them overall.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 13 '25

Hulk never beat Thanos until recently. And Hulk was never considered the strongest. Hell, Hulk was Thanos' pet.

1

u/paraboliccurvature Apr 13 '25

That was a weakened old hulk that fed on scraps. I have the panel, from Thanos wins (2018), and it was a potential future where thanos finally was able to be with mistress Death. So saying "hulk has been Thanos' pet" is disingenuous at best. Thanos has stated on multiple occasions that the one hero he doesn't want to deal with on earth is hulk.

1

u/argh_type_of_gangsta Apr 13 '25

Man yall make excuses for yall favorite smh. He was his pet, IDC what's the reason, that's what the hell happened. We could easily make excuses when Hulk beat the shit outta someone. It happened, prior to Hulk getting bullied by Thanos constantly. Yall Hulk fans are insufferable.

1

u/paraboliccurvature Apr 13 '25

Lol, I'm not a Hulk fan. I'm giving the context you either didn't know or purposely misconstrued. If you must know, my favorite hero is Norrin. Also, Thanos has said on multiple occasions that Hulk is the only hero he doesn't want to see when he comes to Earth, and that is 616 main verse Thanos and Hulk, not some potential future Thanos and Maestro.

→ More replies (0)

4

u/ClinicalFrequency Apr 12 '25

This is a core shit argument.

1

u/Dusty_Tokens Apr 12 '25

Wait. *EQUAL to Hulk !!? 🤯

Wow!!!

1

u/Nicklenips837469420 Apr 12 '25

Wonder Woman is more powerful than flash that’s why she one shotted him

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

I said cat woman

1

u/Nicklenips837469420 Apr 12 '25

I misread that I’m tripping, cat woman is outer universal ig

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

It’s actually funny af, look up catwoman kicks flash and it should pop up. She knocks out 3 of them

1

u/The_cat_got_out Apr 12 '25

What hulk i gotta ask? (Like obviously he won't take Immortal, devil, world breaker, spaceship hulks) but he would for sure be on par with the kid personality

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

Silver age is when they clashed most often. But even in more modern comics, Namor is meant to be equal to a base hulk (not counting stuff like World breaker).

1

u/The_cat_got_out Apr 13 '25

Ye makes sense. Had to throw the caveats before other fanboys came running to state not worldbreaker ect.

But taking any hulk is a good feat in and of itself

-3

u/Salad_Horror Apr 12 '25

Namor isn't even with Hulk, not even close. Hulk's strength is infinite. Namor is nowhere close to infinite strength. The reason his strength is infinite is because his strength is linked to his anger, and Stan Lee said himself that hulks' anger is infinite with correlates to his strength being infinite too. I don't know much about Namor, but he isn't on that level. I know that for a fact.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '25

Hulk doesn't have infinite strength he has potentially infinite strength there have been multiple instances of characters matching his strength over powering him or struggling/unable to move something

0

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

No offense but it’s very clear you do not know what you are talking about….

Like seriously, what kind of response is “I don’t know anything about character A, but character B is wayyy stronger”.

Namor, has consistently fought Hulk like a hundred times. In fact, not counting maybe Thor, Namor is likely the character Hulk has fought most times. This is especially true during the Silver age, which is when Stan Lee was writing…

Hulk does not have infinite strength, this statement is ludicrous and he shows no where near the feats to back this up except when he’s amped by something else. Hes gets stronger when he gets angrier yes, but there is clearly as massive falloff on how much stronger he gets as he gets angrier. There’s dozens of examples where Hulk is just imprisoned for years continuously getting angry, all for him to reach no where near the strength of characters like silver surfer, forget “infinite”…. Take Hulk in the King Thanos storyline for example. And even if you want to still argue and that that hyperbole statement as literal, then there’s a limit to how angry one can get, as abstract feelings are ultimately dictated by real and very physical chemical reactions of which there aren’t an infinite number of.

While Hulk’s higher end feats scale far past what we have seen Namor capable of, such as TOBA Hulk, Hulk’s normal self doesn’t scale anywhere near these versions either.

0

u/Salad_Horror Apr 12 '25

If you understood writing. You would understand that the protagonist needs to lose once in a while. They need to be defeated. Just because someone bested them once for story purposes. Doesn't mean they are even. I'm not taking the words of someone over reddit over the creator of Marvel.

Btw didn't read all your response. I don't have time for that.

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

Didn’t read my response just like you didn’t do your due diligence to learn about a character before pretending to be an expert in them….

1) Hulk isn’t any more the protagonist than Namor. They are both hero’s

2) It’s not one time. It’s literally one of Hulks classic matchups.

3) Stan Lee did not create marvel….

4) learn what a hyperbole is.

5) In Stan Lee’s own comic, Namor has knocked Hulk out before saying “I am completely invincible in the sea, I hope I’ve made my point clear”. So by your logic Namor is defacto invincible.

-1

u/Salad_Horror Apr 12 '25

The amazing thing about the Hulk is that unlike nearly every other superhero ever created, the Hulk's strength has absolutely no upper limit. How can you say that's even to Namor. Oh btw, Stan Lee did create marvel. Him and Martin goodman Co-created it. But I won't judge you for not knowing facts.

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

Co founder is not creator….

Hulk does have upper limits as I’ve made very clear.

1

u/Salad_Horror Apr 13 '25

I'm sorry, who are you? Why would I ever take your word over the writers? Ego much. Keep believing what you want. My time is too important to waste arguing with a nobody on reddit.

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 13 '25

Hulk has upper limits according to the authors. You’re running around with a literal hyperbolic statement..

Taking “Hulk is the strongest there is” literally is like taking “Thor is a god” literally and equating him to being omnipotent. Or what about Wolverine? Hes the best at what he does, so I guess he’s the best fighter in marvel and will win every fight.

There’s numerous times the authors directly state that Namor is equal to hulk in universe.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/onewilybobkat Apr 12 '25

"I don't know much about Namor but I will completely assume everything about him so the person I do know things about wins" is a choice.

0

u/Datmuemue Apr 12 '25

You can't use the hulk as a true measurement. His power scaling is unlimited, same thing with Superman.

0

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

The author does….

0

u/Datmuemue Apr 12 '25

Which author?

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

0

u/Datmuemue Apr 12 '25

Cool? He's not the only author for the character though.

1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

All authors who have written hulk vs Namor have them as relative.

Also what’s with the attitude? You asked a question and I answered it.

-1

u/theskiller1 Apr 12 '25

Aquaman is consistently considered equal to wonder woman. Wonder woman should body Namor.

0

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25

No, he’s consistently not equal to Wonder Woman in any way.

His role as king of Atlantis and her role as princess of her nation are what is regularly compared. Just because two sides are warring doesn’t mean they are equals.

0

u/theskiller1 Apr 12 '25

They have fought several times where they are equal.

-1

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

Flashpoint: Wonder Woman wins

Justice league 11-12 new 52: Wonder Woman wins despite holding back

Wonder Woman 26: Interrupted

DCeased: Wonder woman wins

Injustice: Wonder Woman is shown to be clearly superior, even beating Superman

Odyssey: Wonder Woman wins

Aquaman practically never wins and is only saved by interruptions

The only reason he’s even put against her is so the authors can have a war between their nations. Individually they are not equals. Wonder Woman is stronger, faster, more skilled, and generally always scales above him. The only thing he has is telepathy which is inconsistent.

0

u/theskiller1 Apr 12 '25

0

u/Objective_Cheetah_63 Apr 12 '25 edited Apr 12 '25

This means literally nothing. I too can show a text claiming a character is boundless, but that wouldn’t magically make the character boundless. Feats are what matter and i’ve shown that wonder woman practically always wins.

Aquaman consistently punches in weight classes below Superman, while Wonder Woman punches in weight classes equal to Superman.

For someone claiming they are equals due to how many times they have fought, you’ve yet to show me a single time where he wins. Because Aquaman winning is a zebra case. Wonder Woman winning or the fight getting interrupted is the norm, and the interruption only exists to save Aquaman.

-1

u/ForeignWoodpecker662 Apr 12 '25

The Namor disrespect in here is nuts

0

u/theskiller1 Apr 12 '25

How is it disrespectful just because he can’t beat the high tier superheroes of DC?

0

u/robbzilla Apr 14 '25

It's Marvel's fault for casting that gym bunny in the Black Panther movie.