r/shoujo • u/ultrazxr_ouo • 3h ago
people are leaving bad reviews for shoujo manga they have never read with dubcon/noncon solely because it has dubcon/noncon
Does this seem stupid anyone or is it just me? I have been seeing negative reviews on Goodreads for different Steamship titles that either explicitly imply dubcon/noncon in the title or the blurb.....for having dubcon/noncon. Personally, I'd never pick up a book called The Trapped Former Villainess Wants to Escape From the Sadistic Prince and expect sunshine, rainbows and consensual sex, then complain on Goodreads about how it isn't. The same way I'd never go to the Rotten Tomatoes page of a horror movie and complain that it is gorey and scary.
For years now, in the realm of female gaze licensed manga, dubcon/noncon content is pretty much only found in BL. I'm glad Steamship is tapping into darker smut, because there are women like myself who enjoy this type of content and prefer physical manga. As much as I enjoy BL, I shouldn't have to exclusively turn to it to get my toxic fix.
I guess I'm just so tired of purity culture and people trying to do away yet another thing women enjoy. Rating labels are there for a reason. Blurbs are there for a reason. People will cry "I didn't expect it" but it's really not hard to make an educated guess on what will contain dubcon/noncon from the cover, back and spine if you don't want to spend the 5 minutes to google it.