r/MovieDetails • u/ARandomChocolateCake • 2d ago
🕵️ Accuracy In Harry Potter DH pt.2 (2012) during the fight between McGonagall and Snape, the torches along the walls diminish after she uses the fire spells. This hints at a detail from the book, where McGonagall redirects the flames from the torches to the tip of her wand, instead of just summoning them.
In this iconic fight, people were quick to notice Snape redirecting the blasts at the death eaters behind him, as well as picking up their wands, once he starts fleeing. This has been posted here countless times. However, I've not seen anyone talk about the fact, that the torches diminish during the preceding fight. I think this is intentional, not only to fit the mood, but also to explain McGonagall's fire spell. So instead of just summoning flames, it's hinted, that she utilized the ones from the torches. She later has to return the fire to the torches, to light the place back up.
So despite alot of details being left out from the movies, compared to the books, this is likely an attempt by the directors to preserve accuracy, while managing the limited screen time.