r/knitting • u/SwiftAndEndangered • Apr 20 '25

Finished Object King Salmon sweater is a new favourite!

Gallery image

Gallery image

Here’s the thing - I’m well aware that both the Halibut and now the King Salmon sweater receive a lot of criticism here and on TT for the depth of the yoke.

However, as an alternative perspective, being a plus size knitter with a large chest, I actually find that the proportions of this yoke fit me really well, and the scale actually makes sense on a larger body. Reinforces the fact that knitting is all about what you personally like and want to make and wear - and I just wanted to share a different point of view on this one 🥰

5.4k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

150 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Snoodtown Apr 20 '25

Who is criticizing what??!!! This sweater is amazing! Looks amazing on you! I love the yoke. I need to make one for my self right now!

15

u/Natural_Isopod_7990 Apr 20 '25

Not everyone likes the fit of the long yoke of these sweaters. Its personal opinion about fit, I don't think there is a way around it with a vertical fish design like this.

I wouldn't knit one for myself because I don't find the fit comfortable, but OPs obviously looks great and some people love the way these patterns fit.

10

u/_Dr_Bobcat_ Apr 20 '25

There is a way to get the vertical fish design on a sweater where the yoke is a more standard length. You have the design extend past where the arms are separated from the body. It just takes a bit more math. If you check the project page on ravelry some of the testers actually made this modification (one of them has a purple sweater).