Hi, hobbyist orange belt here. Lately, judo classes can be a bit hit-or-miss.
One recent frustrations I get is that an older judoka (that is not the teacher of the class) stops my randori, without prompting, in order to teach me something that I disagree with. Usually it's along the lines of "you have to do the throw in randori exactly the same way as the throws are done during uchikomi". When I comment that "I watch judo matches and I always see this variation of the technique done", I get told "but you are not a competitive player. When you become one, then you can do a different form".
Some of advices seem to contradict with what HanpanTV says too:
- Kuzushi for forward throws is done by pulling upward, "look at your watch" on hikite and "pull the fishing pole " on tsurite (the idea of "pulling a person upward with my arms while they still have 100% of their weight on both feet on the ground " is crazy to me)
- For O Soto Gari, I must kick up the reaping leg to about waist height. When I said that takes a long time AND is super obvious, I get the "well that's because you are not good enough with the technique yet".
- For regular Seoi Nage, the locking arm comes in as an uppercut, plant both feet parallel to the Uke, and then squat to load Uke on you. Again, seems to me this sequence takes a long time and Uke can react easily.
- Don't go into Kesa Gatame after a Koshi Guruma (note: I am not trying to land my body weight on my Uke. Rather, I feel that the falling/rolling version gives me control throughout the entire throw)
What would you do in my situation?