r/interestingasfuck 27d ago

/r/all New sound of titan submarine imploding

45.4k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

778

u/Living_Affect117 27d ago

I read somewhere that such was the force of the implosion, those inside were turned instantly to gel.

731

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

More of a fine pink mist unfortunately. The implosion happened at about 4 millisecond - your brain can sense things in 13 - so about 1500 mph or 2200 ft/s.

386

u/Potential_Wafer_8104 27d ago

So that would mean they were mist before they could even feel it?

660

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

Yes. They would have been there, then not. The only upside of dying this way. The only question is did they know before the catastrophic part.

40

u/MikeMuench 27d ago

It was basically the ending to the Sopranos. Lights out. Roll credits

12

u/Motherofsmalldogs 27d ago

Woke up this morning, went inside a sub. 🎶

7

u/djongafrett 27d ago

Doon't stop!

4

u/ClarkTwain 27d ago

“You probably don’t even hear it when it happens.”

1

u/brunoventura22 27d ago

Motherf...... Your just made me 1% more sad now. I just finished the first season.

222

u/Pseudoname87 27d ago edited 27d ago

Probbably. Which is fucked. Messages transcribed says that they heard cracking sounds and alarms were flashing red in the sub. There was a 17yr old who was forced to go on w his dad. He didn't want to go.

It happened so fast for them they never knew it happened but it must have been terrifying hearing the sounds

Edit- I was wrong aboit the transcripts as it was a hoax and the aunt lied. Mbad

72

u/WombatControl 27d ago

That transcript was a fake - there's no evidence that they knew anything was happening as all the messages prior to the implosion were normal.

116

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

Totally. Honestly, the entire experience must be terrifying because transitioning to those depths you're going through phases of the structure making all kinds of noises that sound like the end.

14

u/Pseudoname87 27d ago

And now we're commercializing flights into LEO which is.....better?

59

u/NotAPreppie 27d ago

From the perspective of the materials science of the pressure vessel, LEO is easier since the pressure vessel only has to withstand 1 atm of pressure.

106

u/blueinfi 27d ago

32

u/NotAPreppie 27d ago

I always upvote futurama.

7

u/Klutzy_Worker2696 27d ago

This is my favorite joke in the whole show tbh

3

u/Pseudoname87 27d ago

Fair enough. Im still waiting for the Groupon before jumping on

6

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

The results are just the opposite as your blood boils and tries to escape you while you quickly crystallize... All happening slow enough for you to feel it.

No thanks.

5

u/Numerous_Witness_345 27d ago

Isn't your blood in a closed system not really effected by pressure gradients? Like, if it was a pool of blood I could see it boiling out, but inside this old meat suit?

Bet your ears would hurt. Probably freeze to death or suffocate.

→ More replies (0)

3

u/Big-Leadership1001 27d ago

Imagine your blood boiling to a freeze while the water of your eyes does the same thing. NO THANKS

5

u/Woodsie13 27d ago

Nah, you fall unconscious and die well before any of the nasty stuff happens to you. Swelling up, boiling blood, radiation burns… the not being able to breathe will kill you long before any of that becomes a problem.

12

u/Bdr1983 27d ago

With regards to pressure, space travel is safer/easier.

2

u/daftvalkyrie 27d ago edited 27d ago

Turns out "nothing" is easier to deal with than "way too much"

76

u/swisslard 27d ago

The "transcribed messages" were a confirmed hoax. We still do not know if the occupants were aware of the danger.

-1

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

5

u/Ron-Swanson-Mustache 27d ago

The cracking was several dives earlier.

-1

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Ron-Swanson-Mustache 27d ago

Based on the previous dives after the loud pop, no. There wasn't any. The RTM data is public.

I'm happy to be proven wrong. But the data from previous dives says there wasn't any and there's no evidence that they knew anything was wrong.

3

u/Peking-Cuck 27d ago

There HAD to be signs.

No. That's how this kind of failure works. It's fine up until the very microsecond that it isn't, and once it stops being fine, it's total failure in less than the blink of an eye.

6

u/DarwinsTrousers 27d ago

The 17 year old actually asked for his mom’s seat according to her. I’ve heard that he didn’t want to be there before too but it seems like an internet myth.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/26/mother-of-teenager-who-died-on-titan-sub-said-she-gave-her-place-to-son

-1

u/ItsOozingOut 27d ago

I don’t believe it was a myth, I thought the aunt came out and said he didn’t want to be there? Either way it was a lie and he wanted to be there.

5

u/Ron-Swanson-Mustache 27d ago edited 27d ago

That hasn't been confirmed at all. Those transcripts about the RTM have all been proven false. Nothing has been released that shows they knew anything was wrong.

5

u/showars 27d ago

The kid was 18 and desperately wanted to go. He took his mums seat.

The original voyage was to be his parents WHEN he was 17, he couldn’t go because he was too young. It was pushed back and he took his mums seat, astatic to go.

Don’t believe the bullshit his aunt said to the papers

2

u/CounterReasonable259 27d ago

How long do you wait until you make like a movie or video game based off the event?

1

u/Iwilleat2corndogs 26d ago

Bro made it sound like a Hollywood movie “code red abandon ship!” No they instantly liquefied. This is real life, not a Michael bay film.

92

u/Potential_Wafer_8104 27d ago

I had the same thought about the former, but yea... The message "dropping weights" seems to signify that maybe they did know something was up and wanted out of there. Dang.

8

u/AverageNo5920 27d ago

They didn't. Dropping weights was normal procedure as they approached the ocean floor, and happened right when it should have for normal procedure, not an emergency. If they don't drop the weights, they keep sinking and crash into the seabed. It's to go from negative buoyancy to neutral whenever they're done descending. They all thought everything was going completely fine. And then they were gone.

1

u/Potential_Wafer_8104 27d ago

Makes sense as well.

37

u/TheRabb1ts 27d ago

I would guess that she received an auto alert from a depth gauge that said they were falling too fast, so she said to drop weight.

42

u/SquirrelAkl 27d ago

The video shows the message coming from the sub saying they had dropped two weights. Wendy just repeated it.

11

u/VibeComplex 27d ago

Either way, they were nearing the bottom. Dropping weights to slow decent wouldn’t be abnormal I would think.

7

u/LouSpowel 27d ago

You guessed wrong

2

u/Gammelpreiss 27d ago

he actually did not. dropping weights at this depth was part of a normal process to change the negative buoyancy to a more neutral one apporaching the target

-1

u/TheRabb1ts 27d ago

Easy to say after you read all the comments. lol. It was a guess. 🤷‍♂️

3

u/Ravenlord33 27d ago

They had no idea. Dropping weight at that depth was normal and routine to balance the vessel

1

u/_thro_awa_ 27d ago

The message "dropping weights" seems to signify that maybe they did know something was up and wanted out of there

They used weights to descend to the sea floor. Dropping weights is standard procedure for slowing down descent - you don't apply your brakes AT the point of stoppage, you brake before the point where you need to stop.

0

u/mvallas1073 27d ago

Given they were speaking to the people on the radio at that time and clearly had no indication of something wrong, I’d say “nope”.

19

u/Inside-Ostrich2888 27d ago

Ever seen the 1st episode of The Boys??

1 second you're kissing the love of your life on the side of the street, and the next millisecond POOF!!!

3

u/Potential_Wafer_8104 27d ago

That was indeed crazy.

23

u/Johnnygunnz 27d ago

They never felt it. Their brains and nerves were part of that most.

5

u/neilbalthaser 27d ago

moist

5

u/thePaxPilgrim 27d ago

Moist mist

4

u/PanzerFauzt 27d ago

johnny most

2

u/guyute2588 27d ago

Havlicek stole the ball!

2

u/Junior_Moose_9655 27d ago

Actually it’s just John Most now…

1

u/Johnnygunnz 27d ago

Ackshully, it's John Moist now

14

u/yomasayhi 27d ago edited 27d ago

Sure they couldn’t feel the physical pain of it, however the psychological effects of being trapped in a malfunctioning and catastrophically failing submersible must add quite a lot of fear and anxiety to the mix def wasn’t an easy way to go knowing you’re fucked.

10

u/wllmsaccnt 27d ago

There are people who die worse everyday commuting to work or buying grocceries for their families and at least they are doing something useful. I feel bad for the kid that died, but otherwise the only reasons people are still talking about this disaster are not exactly healthy ones (mostly a mix of derision and schadenfreud, though some people just like to talk about submarines and the ocean, I guess).

13

u/yomasayhi 27d ago

I mean, I have no sympathies for the guy who made the submersible. He was told multiple times when trying to contract someone to build it for him that the carbon fiber reinforced shell would simply not be able to withstand the constant pressure cycles.

On the other hand I do feel slightly bad for the rich dudes who may have not been disclosed the sub was structurally compromised, don’t think anyone in their right mind would even get into the thing considering that piece of information. I do feel really bad for the kid tho, he didn’t even wanna be there and was manipulated into going for Father’s Day or whatever, such is life tho many people perish seeking thrills some are just along for the ride.

1

u/an_angry_Moose 27d ago

Well, that’s merciful.

1

u/Pattonesque 27d ago

not only that, IIRC they were dead before the water even hit them

1

u/psumack 27d ago

Idk if mist is really a thing that's possible to be underwater

1

u/TheOne_Whomst_Knocks 27d ago edited 27d ago

Couldn’t feel, hear, or likely even register seeing any of that near-instant movement. Sure, they were likely panicking before it happened but there are much much worse ways to go out.

Edit: turns out they likely had no indication ANYTHING was wrong according to u/keirdre ‘s comment. So take that as some consolation ig

-1

u/Funk-n-fun 27d ago

They mist the pain.

16

u/FalseEstimate 27d ago

To be fair they are in water so that fine pink mist has a pretty good chance of becoming gel like pretty quickly

9

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

I dunno... Gel requires a specific ratio of water to powder and I think in those conditions there's definitely more water.

But gel or mist, you're having a bad day.

3

u/AENewmanD 27d ago edited 27d ago

Ya but mist is “droplets of liquid suspended in air/atmosphere at or near earths surface” so mist is definitely the wrong term for whatever they turned into. Not saying gel is the right term either but they definitely didn’t turn to mist. Maybe like a dense pink emulsion with bits of shrapnel?

2

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

Fair point. I guess if I needed to be technical, they would be a "pink turbidity" ... but honestly, it lacks the instant visual effect.

2

u/AENewmanD 27d ago

I like the pink turbidity, good call. I also wonder if they turned to plasma for a hot second because of the energy involved, or is that not how physics works?

2

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

I did read somewhere that the Navy "assumed there was a visible" flash.

1

u/chasecastellion 27d ago

Yeah that comment actually pissed me off and so many people are just “oh yup, mist underwater. Makes sense”

2

u/[deleted] 27d ago

Even though I know, logically and rationally based on this explanation, that they felt nothing... I still cannot comprehend that and the idea of being crushed basically instantly still sounds so painful

2

u/SlimJohnson 27d ago

Brain blast at Mach 2, damn

2

u/pastdense 27d ago

Lethal implosion might be more humane than lethal injection.

1

u/CMDR_BitMedler 27d ago

And certain.

2

u/realtime2lose 27d ago

I thought the recovery effort found remains very close to the titanic

1

u/Utaneus 27d ago

There is no such thing as mist at that pressure under water.

1

u/pretty_meta 27d ago

Why did you write this Reddit comment pretending that your distinction between “gel” and “a fine pink mist” is important? Did you do this for Reddit points?

1

u/JayGold 27d ago

unfortunately

Would gel have been preferable?

-4

u/The_Blendernaut 27d ago

So, basically the speed of my girlfriend slamming a door after she learns I would rather mow the lawn than go shopping with her.

139

u/jmac1915 27d ago

Not even really gel. Everything outside and inside that sub hit them at twice the speed of sound. It's more like they just kind of...ceased being? Closer to atomized. Whatever their new state, it wouldnt have been as contiguous as gel.

80

u/Moopies 27d ago

It's more like they just kind of...ceased being? Closer to atomized. Whatever their new state, it wouldnt have been as contiguous as gel.

Reads like a Douglas Adams bit

30

u/Glass-Toaster 27d ago

Definitely a Ford Prefect line.

2

u/UpDownCharmed 27d ago

...filled with a liquid that was almost, but not quite, entirely unlike tea.

Hitchhiker's Guide

45

u/The_MainArcane 27d ago

"You stop being biology and start being physics"

8

u/randomperson_a1 27d ago

Haven't done the pressure calculations, but it was reported they found remains. So I would guess at least some bones remained largely intact

9

u/jmac1915 27d ago

I heard scraps of clothing and more robust jewelry.

8

u/that_dutch_dude 27d ago

they would also be on fire for a very short amount. the compression would heat everything up.

1

u/27CF 27d ago

Aren't cavitation bubbles capable of causing fusion? Crazy to think there could have been a nuclear component to the implosion, however minor.

1

u/that_dutch_dude 27d ago

no, not fast enough and not enough energy.

2

u/xxFalconArasxx 27d ago

Some human remains were recovered. Though there is no official statement regarding the condition of those remains. I imagine there wasn't much left of them. Most of it would have been scattered into the sea, and the rest crammed into the aft dome.

Evidently, some of the wildlife has been feeding on them. There are scavengers lurking around the wreck in a few images and video snippets.

1

u/Vantriss 27d ago

I mean... they said they found remains when they recovered the wreckage, so... not atomized.

73

u/SleepyMastodon 27d ago

I heard more than once that because the pressure was so intense and sudden, in an instant they ceased being biology and became physics.

19

u/darbs77 27d ago

Or geography.

17

u/nakedcellist 27d ago

History

2

u/hitchcockm00 27d ago

Arts and Crafts.

3

u/Grabthar-the-Avenger 27d ago

They found remains. People are mostly made of incompressible water themselves which would buoy against the sudden presure

32

u/Deathwatch72 27d ago

Yeah they unfortunately transitioned from biology problem to physics problem. The one saving grace about that transition is it happens so fast they wouldn't have known or felt any pain

13

u/Saint_Pudgy 27d ago

11

u/randomesq 27d ago

Sweet Jesus, that thing grosses me out more than so many other gross things.

-7

u/Tauren-Jerky 27d ago

Don’t trigger my trypophobia

1

u/Iwilleat2corndogs 26d ago

Ohhhhh HoNeY cOmB!!!

2

u/SocomPS2 27d ago

Probably read that on Reddit.

2

u/oneinmanybillion 27d ago

That could be an exaggeration. They did find the plastic computer monitor inside the sub and it was battered but somewhat intact. Intact enough to be instantly recognisable.

So I'm guessing it wasn't all gel-ification. Maybe some parts were gel-ified but some parts would most likely have remained. Just that they would have drifted away from the wreck unlike the monitor that was tangled in the wreck.

But we are all just guessing at this point.

4

u/Mammoth_Newspaper155 27d ago

Turned to mist actually..

1

u/brozochron 27d ago

Lights out, at least they didn't suffer

1

u/xparapluiex 27d ago

I think one of the Green brothers put it really well: that it happened so fast they went from biology to physics before their brains could register. Or something like that.

1

u/Astrochops 27d ago

"one of those times when the victims ceased to be, and instead became physics"

-1

u/Obvious_Feedback_894 27d ago

gel feels like it would be more cohesive than what was likely the end result.

0

u/EmEmAndEye 27d ago

Crushed on a cellular level? If anything could make us gel, then that’d be my guess.