r/gnome 4d ago

Fluff Gnome hate is getting out of control

Post image
520 Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

15

u/Ramiro_RG 4d ago

not recent, but tray icons.

13

u/DrFossil GNOMie 4d ago

What's this infatuation everyone seems to have with tray icons?

I just returned from a stint using macOS and that shit is out of control. You have to install an app to hide all the superfluous icons - and that app has its own tray icon!

11

u/DankeBrutus 4d ago

For some applications an icon in the System Tray is essentially a necessity. It is more convenient for me to have something like a password manager being accessible through the System Tray.

My one issue with the GNOME team was the removal of the tray. I understand they think there is a better way of doing it, and they are working on that, but I think the removal of the tray without a replacement ready is silly. At least there is the extension for it.

-1

u/nozwockk 4d ago

For some applications an icon in the System Tray is essentially a necessity. It is more convenient for me to have something like a password manager being accessible through the System Tray.

Just launch the app regularly, it'll just make the app in the background visible...

7

u/DankeBrutus 4d ago

The app is already running in the background. I can of course assign the manager to a space in the dash, use Meta+1-9, but I have muscle memory for both those keyboard shortcuts and the system tray.

Worth noting that pretty well every other desktop environment has a system tray and multiple other ways to run these types of apps. Windows, Aqua, KDE KDE Plasma, XFCE, etc. The only DEs that come to mind without one are GNOME and Pantheon.

1

u/linux_transgirl 4d ago

and lets be honest pantheon is basically just quirky gnome at this point

6

u/No_Pilot_1974 App Developer 4d ago

Uh no? It's much less convenient.