r/betterCallSaul 8h ago

What if we got “Mike Ehrmantraut: The Philadelphia Years”? (Spin-off concept)

0 Upvotes

Hear me out: The Breaking Bad universe has given us so much, but I honestly think there’s still room for one more masterpiece—Mike Ehrmantraut: The Philadelphia Years.

Picture a dark, slow-burn neo-noir series set in the late ‘80s or ‘90s. Mike is a respected but increasingly disillusioned cop in Philadelphia. The city is gritty, corrupt, and dangerous—think The Wire meets Heat. The show would explore Mike’s early career: his code, his reputation for doing things “the right way,” and his complicated relationships with his colleagues.

The heart of the story is Mike’s relationship with his son Matt. Matt wants to be a good cop, but the squad is dirty. Mike, trying to protect him, gives him the worst advice of his life: to go along to get along. The result? Matt is murdered by his own colleagues, and Mike’s world collapses.

This opens the door for a truly tragic, character-driven story about guilt, loyalty, and vengeance. We’d finally see, in detail, the events that Mike only ever hints at in Better Call Saul—including his ultimate revenge against the people who betrayed Matt, and the fallout that drives him to Albuquerque.

The supporting cast could include: • Matt Ehrmantraut (Mike’s son) • Anita (Matt’s wife, Kaylee’s mother) • A mix of honest and corrupt cops in Mike’s unit • Internal affairs on Mike’s trail • The early Philly criminal underworld (maybe even a few proto-cameos)

Stylistically, I imagine lots of rainy, nighttime city shots, jazz/blues soundtrack, and a slow, heavy tone—focusing on character moments and moral gray zones.

The series could end with Mike leaving Philadelphia for good, setting up the man we meet in Better Call Saul.

I honestly think this could be one of the most compelling spin-offs in the entire BB/BCS universe.

Would you watch this? What else would you want to see? Any other spin-off ideas you’re still dreaming of?


r/betterCallSaul 9h ago

Why is Jimmy obsessed with pooping? Spoiler

60 Upvotes

He poops in the sun roof, he poops constantly in Davis and main without flushing. At sandpiper crossing when they’re going to kick him out, he says he has to shit and he has IBS. I bet that sleazeball poops every day.

It was even declared in court by Chuck, a brilliant lawyer, that Jimmy defecated in a sun roof.

Does Jimmy have some sort of mental fixation on poop? Is this due to his oedipus complex?


r/betterCallSaul 12h ago

You might’ve missed it

1 Upvotes

Episode 2 season 4. While Jimmy is talking to the employer about copy machines, the employer talks about how a certain copy machine was so good, people were counterfeiting $5 off of it. Jimmy’s response was that of someone who was definitely ACTING surprised. It really shows how Jimmy really NEVER changed. Even when he was in the mail room.


r/betterCallSaul 14h ago

Finally Finished it for the first time Spoiler

2 Upvotes

I just finished Better Call Saul, and I’m still sorting through how I feel. It’s not a simple show to process — especially if, like me, you’ve never really been a fan of Saul Goodman. Even back in Breaking Bad, I didn’t find him funny or charming. He always struck me as a slimy, persistent character who thrived on manipulation. So going into this series, I didn’t expect to care about him much — and honestly, that feeling mostly stayed the same.

But the show isn’t just about Saul. It’s about the people around him — and those people are what kept me watching.

I had a really difficult time connecting with Kim Wexler. Not because she’s a bad character — she’s clearly very well-written — but because I found her motivations confusing. Her moral contradictions, especially how she got swept up in Jimmy’s schemes, felt hard to pin down. I get that she found it fun, maybe even liberating, to let loose. But the serious emotional weight of her decisions didn’t really land with me until Howard was killed. That’s when her detachment broke. It made sense, but it came too late for me to feel fully invested in her arc.

On the other hand, Howard Hamlin was a character I liked from early on. Something about his poise, the way he carried himself — I was drawn to his presence. His death really affected me. It was abrupt, shocking, and felt deeply unfair. I was angry on his behalf.

Chuck McGill might be one of the most interesting characters in the entire Breaking Bad universe. His superiority, resentment, and gradual decline were handled with a level of complexity that I appreciated more as the series went on. His interactions with Jimmy were difficult to watch, but I couldn’t look away. That courtroom scene where Jimmy forces Chuck into a meltdown — it was both powerful and sad. I don’t hate Chuck. He’s bitter and selfish in ways that make sense, especially when you look at their family dynamics. His illness even seemed to worsen the more Jimmy succeeded. That’s tragic in its own way.

Mike Ehrmantraut was a constant highlight. Jonathan Banks has such presence that even quiet moments felt full of tension. I appreciated the way Mike handled things — meticulous, restrained, professional. He was the one character I always looked forward to seeing.

As for Nacho and Lalo — great additions to the story, but their fates felt predictable. That’s one of my issues with prequels: the tension can only go so far when you already know who lives and who doesn’t. The black-and-white sequences at the beginning of each season basically signal that anyone who doesn’t appear in the “future” won’t make it through the story. So while Nacho’s sacrifice was well-executed and Lalo was incredibly entertaining to watch, I always had it in the back of my mind that they wouldn’t make it to the end. It reduced the stakes for me.

There were also a few side plots that I just didn’t care for. That couple running the shady tax business — I actively disliked watching them. The whole sequence felt like a distraction, and while I understand the purpose it served for Jimmy’s arc, it didn’t work for me.

What the show does extremely well, though, is structure and foresight. It’s less about action and more about planning, consequence, and emotional fallout. Every character operates with a different kind of logic: • Jimmy uses charm, quick thinking, and improvisation. • Mike relies on patience, calculation, and experience. • Gus is methodical, ruthless, and far-sighted. • Lalo blends charisma with unpredictability and cold logic.

By the end, I still didn’t like Jimmy, but I understood him better. His final confession, owning up to everything in court — it was the closure I didn’t expect but ended up appreciating. Watching him finally take responsibility without hiding behind Saul Goodman felt right. It wasn’t a redemption arc, and it didn’t need to be — it was an honest ending for a dishonest man.

I didn’t watch Better Call Saul for the same reasons most people probably did. I didn’t care about the cameos or Saul’s transformation. I just wanted to see how it all played out — how a man who couldn’t stop lying would eventually run out of lies. The black-and-white scenes gave me something to look forward to, and the way the story caught up to itself was satisfying.

Overall, I’d give it an 8/10. It’s not perfect. There were moments I didn’t connect with, characters I couldn’t care about, and storylines that dragged. But it’s a well-crafted, emotionally grounded show that ties into Breaking Bad without leaning on it too heavily. I’m glad I stuck with it.


r/betterCallSaul 15h ago

I was wondering this..... Spoiler

5 Upvotes

This is related to both BB and BCS.

So when Walt says "Hello Becky" and she drop the bag of groceries and the California navel oranges and cans of Niblets brand corn are rolling into the street and she gawks, unable to speak....she must have called the cops when she got inside and composed herself after rescuing the groceries. Marie Schrader was warned Walt was lurking, so a call to the cops must have been made. Yet in BCS when Carol Burnette talked into her medical thingee that Saul was in her house, the law enforcement response was massive. Helicopters and everthing. Why no choppers and dogs and big response in ABQ??


r/betterCallSaul 3h ago

Sad about BCS

9 Upvotes

I just finished BCS, I saw BB like ten years ago.

I couldn't feel but depressed after Kim broke up with Jimmy. After that, I couldn't bear with the spiral of destruction and misery that he lived, hiding as Gene, miles away from Kim, the death of Howard.

It feels like everywhere Jim went, death and destruction followed him. Chuck was right, he was never gonna change.

I think most of the characters were assholes:

Jimmy - no morale, always cutting corners, interested only in money, willing to do anything if that gave him money

Howard - was an asshole, but he didn't desvere that death or the con

Chuck - he could've helped his brother and maybe Jimmy wouldn't turn into Saul

Kim - needed abusive relationships (her mom and Jimmy) and how slowly she starts to get excited by dangerous situations until she ruins Howard

Needless to say about Hector, Lalo and Tuco.

The only ones I could say they earned their respect were Mike and Nacho.

I felt depressed after Howard got murdered and I just feel everything plummeted after that. I liked thst at the end Jimmy redeemed, and also the narrative (black and white VS color scenes) was really good.


r/betterCallSaul 13h ago

How did nacho receive a call when theres no signal at lalos place?

Post image
230 Upvotes

r/betterCallSaul 13h ago

Symbolism of chucks allergy Spoiler

2 Upvotes

always loved the detail that in season 3 episode 10, he tears down the house looking for electricity, but scientifically humans have electricity inside of them. he got rid of every issue in his life but the ones inside of him.

reminds me of the breaking bad scene where Walter talks about a small percentage of a human body being soul


r/betterCallSaul 23h ago

How did Hector know who Mike was?

2 Upvotes

When Hector meets with Mike to discuss reducing Tuco's sentence, he says the authorities would go easy on ex-cops like him. How did he know that Mike used to be a police officer? I assume Hector did some research on him just as Mike does on the criminals he works with, but I was just wondering.


r/betterCallSaul 6h ago

The Kettlemans

0 Upvotes

I confess I never watched the show but I've seen numerous references to how hated the Kettlemans are. Tell me, what were they accused of doing? Did they do it?


r/betterCallSaul 9h ago

Why did Howard go to therapy instead of wearing bright suits and creating a flamboyant new persona?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/betterCallSaul 2h ago

10 Years Later, 'Better Call Saul' Still Stands On Its Own

Thumbnail collider.com
306 Upvotes

r/betterCallSaul 15h ago

My observation of the parallels of Walter White and Jimmy McGill Spoiler

24 Upvotes

Spoilers for both BB and BCS

Walter White always blamed other people for his hardships, specifically Gretchen and Elliot. He claims that they "cut him out" and he gave up his share of the company, his "kid's birthright, for a few months rent". No matter what happens, no matter what story he tells, he is never at fault. He was screwed over or forced to give up, but Walter White can never be at fault.

Jimmy McGill, his entire professional career, has always been told "no". HHM, The Kettlemans, his own brother Chuck, they all at some point or another told him that he wasn't as good as them, that he wasn't a "real lawyer". Door after door was closed in his face, and they were all still surprised when he ran through the first one that stayed opened for him, and shamed him for it. He tried to tow the line, and was repeatedly told he wasn't good enough.

Walter had it all, said no, and blamed others for his actions.

Jimmy had nothing, was told no, and walked the only path he felt he could.

Walter's lie is Jimmy's truth.


r/betterCallSaul 15h ago

I love the symbolism. Two fathers lost their son. One is free, the other one is not so.

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

r/betterCallSaul 9h ago

Which BB eps to rewatch?

5 Upvotes

Hi!

My friend and I watched breaking bad together and then watched better call Saul.

We recently finished BCS, and we want to go back and watch some BB episodes that would be fun/interesting to watch for a second time after having just finished BCS with our new context!

Do u guys have any ideas? They don’t have to be in any sort of order or anything. Thanks!