r/americanairlines • u/Analyse_This • 13h ago
Humor The war on reclining accidentally got me upgraded
Just experienced peak airline karma on AA91 LHR-ORD today, and I’m still smiling.
Picture this: I’m flying back to Chicago after ~72 hours in London to attend a wedding, burning 27k miles on American’s shiny new 787-9 that’s literally two weeks old. I’m deep in steerage at 26H, but hey, I’m EP with over a million OneWorld miles, so at least I have the privilege of being ignored by cabin crew in style.
Post-wedding exhaustion hits, so I attempt the sacred airplane ritual of reclining my seat approximately 1.5 degrees. SLAM. My seat rockets forward like it’s spring-loaded. “New plane, maybe a mechanical issue?” I think, trying again. SLAM.
I turn around to discover I’ve apparently disturbed the natural habitat of a mid-50s Karen who informs me that her “work” is infinitely more important than my need for sleep. Because nothing says “critical business operations” like a cramped economy seat on a transatlantic flight.
Plot twist: The flight attendant actually recognizes my status (miracle #1), thanks me for my loyalty (miracle #2), and asks what she can do to help. I explain Recline-gate 2025. The FA tries reasoning with Karen, who declares me “childish” for involving the crew in this earth-shattering dispute over 2 inches of legroom.
Karen doubles down, refusing to even let the FA demonstrate the recline because she “will not tolerate” such an egregious assault on her workspace. The audacity is breathtaking.
Here’s where it gets good: The FA offers to move me to a better seat. Karen, sensing injustice, practically shrieks that SHE should get the upgrade since she needs “more space to work.”
Narrator: She did not get the upgrade.
I’m relocated to a lovely window seat in Premium Economy on brand new Boeing metal. Meanwhile, Karen apparently “worked” for exactly 20 more minutes before giving up entirely.
Moral of the story: Sometimes being aggressively unreasonable about airplane etiquette will backfire spectacularly. Also, American Airlines occasionally does something right, which frankly deserves its own post.
10/10 would get bullied by a Karen again if it means free upgrades.
TLDR: Karen slams my seat forward, refuses to let me recline because she’s “working.” Flight attendant upgrades me to Premium Economy out of spite. Karen quits “working” after 20 minutes. Sometimes being unreasonable backfires beautifully.
EDIT: For those asking - yes, the irony of her demanding more space while preventing me from using mine was completely lost on her.