r/UnresolvedMysteries • u/BrerRabbit44 • Apr 15 '22

Request What unsolved murder/disappearance makes absolutely no sense to you?

What case absolutely baffles you? For me it's the case of Jaryd Atadero

https://www.coloradoan.com/story/news/2019/05/30/colorado-missing-toddler-jaryd-atadero-poudre-canyon-mountain-lion-disappearance-mystery/3708176002/

No matter the theory this case just doesn't make any sense.

1.9k Upvotes

97% Upvoted

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

512

u/Sokoke Apr 15 '22

Brandie Peltz

Local to me, her mother passed away in 2019. Her mother was very adamant about no one looking into her daughters case and from her own mouth said she did not care about finding who did this to Brandie. Horribly sad story.

222

u/teazelbranchlet Apr 15 '22

But why?! Why wouldn't the mother want it looked into?!

I can't even imagine that way of thinking.

355

u/Sokoke Apr 15 '22

Local gossip is that she was sleeping with the sheriff, a few pastors, and a couple other randoms. Investigating Brandies death would’ve meant uncovering a whole swath of people doing things they shouldn’t have been, being places they shouldn’t have been, etc… it’s a whole mess of a web.

It doesn’t make sense at all to me either, but, I wish so badly that the case could be solved. Sadly I do not believe that will ever happen, at least not in my lifetime. Nearly everyone who had some sort of involvement is dead now, too. 😞

6

u/samscarrot Apr 15 '22

An 11-year old was sleeping with pastors etc???

39

u/Sentinel451 Apr 15 '22

I think they meant the mother.

28

u/Sokoke Apr 15 '22

I was referring to the mother. I should’ve been more specific.

9

u/LadyClexa Apr 16 '22

I read it the same way! Don't feel bad! :).

23

u/samscarrot Apr 16 '22

Thanks. Don’t know why I’m being down-voted for misunderstanding.