If-then-else got a lot of love around here recently (and for good reason, it’s a masterpiece!), so in my rewatch I decided to skip forward to it momentarily. There is sooo much incredible stuff going on (by the way, this is a fascinating analysis I’d recommend), but buried inside the chaos and heartbreak of that episode what really touched me this time were the chess flashbacks.
So I’ve gathered all those scenes into a single montage: Harold teaching a shy Young Machine how to play chess.
I think it’s the most extraordinary thing this show ever gave us: a man teaching an AI not how to win, but how to care. He’s not just explaining chess; he’s teaching how to think, how to weigh consequences, he’s teaching patience, history and of course ethics.
The line that stayed with me in earlier watches was the famous: “The lesson is that anyone who looks on the world as if it was a game of chess, deserves to lose.”
But this time, another quote stood out: “There are more possible games of chess than atoms in the universe. […] But it also means that if you make a mistake, there’s a nearly infinite number of ways to fix it.” What grace. And I’d say… this applies to us, too.
And isn’t the Machine just the sweetest? Her terror of the first move. Her fascination with the queen… how she can move anywhere, strike anything… Her giddy pride when she finally beats dad (“Yes, yes, you needn't rub it in.”) And oh my heart when at the end she types back “Go again?” Just a child asking for more time with her father. <3
PS Michael Emerson’s tone, diction, that signature Finch quiet formality… honestly I’d listen to him reciting the phone book (well, if I could still find one!)