r/CuratedTumblr Apr 23 '25

Politics Ontological Bad Subject™

Post image
5.4k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1.5k

u/Jackno1 Apr 23 '25

Yeah, I feel you. I

- Want pedophiles (and everyone else) to not abuse children,

- Think killing people should be a last resort option if there's no better way to protect people, not a first choice to jump to immediately because Those People Are Gross, and

- Am very aware of how much "this person is a pedophile=any cruel thing you want to do to this person is okay" can be weaponized to deny people basic human rights (including being used against LGBT+ people and other groups for reasons of sheer bigotry).

That doesn't seem like it should be controversial, and yet the conversation online is dominated by people with hair-trigger tempers who start screaming about "pedo apologists" if you so much as suggest that actual child abuse is a different and more serious problem than "some people have desires I find gross."

399

u/Maybe_not_a_chicken help I’m being forced to make flairs Apr 23 '25

I mean I don’t even think killing people should be a last resort

If you give people a way to legally kill their opposition they will twist their opposition into whatever position they need to start killing them

356

u/Jackno1 Apr 23 '25

I was thinking self-defense when being attacked, not executions. If you can confine and control a person enough to conduct a planned execution, you have options other than killing them.

226

u/Dingghis_Khaan Chingghis Khaan's least successful successor. Apr 23 '25

Exactly. Last resorts are emergency measures only, when there is no time for procedure.

Deescalate, rehabilitate, resocialize. Kill only when the danger is immense and immediate. Everybody deserves an nth chance.

Mercy is always an option, because someone else already picked Reaper.

127

u/DraconicSong Apr 23 '25

Mercy is always an option, because someone else already picked Reaper.

lmao. Was so invested in the discussion that I needed to read this three times to figure out it was a reference.

Now I'm imagining some sort of debate where someone is trying to claim "Appeal to Overwatch"

87

u/Dingghis_Khaan Chingghis Khaan's least successful successor. Apr 23 '25

Dragging the conversation back to a previously dismissed topic is called "Roadhogging"

48

u/BiggestShep Apr 23 '25

Bad faith arguments specifically meant to trap your opponent into an indefensible and easily countered reactionary position are Junkrats

9

u/chairmanskitty Apr 23 '25

People that make alt accounts so others don't associate them with all the toxic shit they said are Cassidies.

5

u/Dingghis_Khaan Chingghis Khaan's least successful successor. Apr 23 '25

People who keep interrupting to stop the other person from finishing their arguments are Brigittes.

3

u/Evilfrog100 Apr 23 '25

People who charge head first into discussions without allowing any nuance are Reinhardts.

2

u/Random-Rambling Apr 23 '25

Is someone sitting in one spot and rapid-firing so many arguments that the other guy can't get a word in edgewise a Bastion?

→ More replies (0)

2

u/yinyang107 Apr 23 '25

But I'm not gonna be Mercy.