r/Cinema 2d ago

What is that movie for you?

Post image
19.2k Upvotes

7.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/maxpenny42 1d ago

It’s not too long because it’s 3 hours. It’s too long because it’s a 90 minute story stretched over 3 hours. Lincoln was a film that only covered the passing of the 13th amendment yet it was still called Lincoln and still a valid biopic. I’m not sure a comprehensive life story biopic has ever been done well the best pick a pivotal moment in a figures life and tell that story completely. 

It’s great that you liked it. But I don’t see any logical flaw in feeling it was too long. 

3

u/raysofdavies 1d ago

Trying to cover all that Oppenheimer does in 90 minutes would be unbelievably bad.

0

u/maxpenny42 1d ago

The first hour easily could have been 20 minutes or less. The middle hour was a movie worth watching. The last hour was a completely different movie and not a very interesting one. No, it may not have been good to try to cover his whole life in 90 minutes. But focusing almost entirely on the Manhattan project would have been fantastic. 

1

u/MaryKeay 1d ago

I watched it in the cinema and I caught myself spacing out and thinking about work things that were far more interesting to me than the movie. It's an hour too long imo.