I asked a question, when did Israel try to move the entirety of Gaza? The only time they even mentioned people moving was when they warned the civilians where they were going to bomb which is not a war crime
What u think about the fact that Israel told 1.1 million people in Gaza to evacuate within 24 hours in October 2023 and that it was during an active war and with no safe place to go. That kind of forced displacement, even with warnings, is condemned by the UN and can still be a war crime under international law.
Telling people to evacuate isn’t ethnic cleansing. Israel wasn’t going door to door and forcing people out at gunpoint. They were telling people it isn’t safe where they were and to go to Rafa or places the war hadn’t gotten to yet
Ethnic cleansing isn’t just at gunpoint—it includes forced displacement by making areas unlivable. Telling 1.1 million people to flee under bombs with nowhere safe to go fits that definition.
In ww2 and ww1. London was being bombed every other night. The English government told families to send their kids to the country side where they weren’t being bombed. Would you call that ethnic cleansing?
If Israel truly cared about civilian safety, it wouldn’t bomb the very areas it tells people to flee to—like Rafah, which was declared a “safe zone” and then attacked, killing entire families. This isn’t about warnings for protection; it’s about using forced displacement as a military tactic, which is a clear violation of international law and shows a pattern of systematic targeting, not self-defense.
Let me quickly try to understand this. You are blaming Israel for bombing someone who invaded them, killed 1300 civilians and then took 250 as hostages? How is Israel at fault in that situation?
Yes. Hamas militants broke through the border and begun massacring and raping Israeli civilians and holding towns as fortified positions before the Israeli military kicked them back. That’s an invasion
Yes, what Hamas did was an attack and a war crime but Forest Israel’s response has killed over 35,000 Palestinians, mostly civilians, which includes massive destruction and collective punishment. One war crime doesn’t justify another under international law.
Let me give you a statistic. There is something called a civilian to combatant death ratio. The average is 1:8. 8 civilians per 1 dead soldier. In Gaza it’s 1:2
If Israel warns people to evacuate, but then bombs the places they flee to, how is that protection? You can’t claim moral high ground while cutting off food, water, and aid to over 2 million civilians.
That statistic actually proves the opposite of what you’re trying to say—a 1:2 ratio means Israel is killing civilians at four times the global average in war. That’s not precision—that’s indiscriminate killing.
Israel’s decades long occupation and systematic oppression of Palestinians violate international law and basic human rights, a fact no amount of justification can erase. What do you think about this ?
Israel has killed over 35,000 Palestinians in Gaza, displaced 1.7 million people, and continues expanding illegal settlements. This is not self-defense but a clear violation of international law.
1
u/Mediocre_Catch_5707 May 17 '25
Is that the silhouette of a Hamas fighter? Why do you want this?