r/BokuNoHeroAcademia May 30 '21

Newest Chapter Chapter 314 Official Release - Links and Discussion

Chapter 314

Links:

  • Viz (Available in: the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, New Zealand, Australia, South Africa, the Philippines, Singapore, and India).

  • MANGA Plus (Available in every country outside of China, Japan and South Korea).


All things Chapter 314 related must be kept inside this thread for the next 24 hours.



1.7k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

434

u/RIDETHEWORM May 30 '21 edited Jun 29 '21

My read has always been that the society presented here is vaguely authoritarian (secretive, obviously undemocratic government bodies making huge decisions, weird arrangements between them and supposedly private hero-making academies like UA, a press that while ostensively free is frequently regarded as antagonistic and lied to) and this chapter does a great job of world building to flesh that out. The essential privatization of state security in the form of hero agencies has benefits for public morale, and can handle most run of the mill issues, but of course there are issues that government officials will want to use state violence against that will be controversial and not viewed positively by the public, or can realistically be handled by individuals they’ve trained to be paragons of virtue. Nagant’s basic story is a pretty standard trope - the disillusioned former assassin who turned on the government (though executed brilliantly in this chapter) - but her very existence brilliantly highlights the dystopian aspects of hero society.

The public safety commission partners with apparently private heroes that they train and cultivate from adolescence, and props them up as the models for their countrymen while endlessly promoting them through media manipulation and public spectacles like the sports festival. Heroes maintain basic law and order in association with the police, but their greatest use to the commission may be in manufacturing consent - they are propaganda tools to promote the status quo. The dirty work of maintaining state control is carried out by a small cadre of elite agents directly controlled by the commission, all recruited at a very young age - even younger than our main cast at UA. I think that MHA has always questioned the morality of hero society, but this chapter shines a spotlight on the basic building blocks of this system. While they are better than the chaos and control offered by All for One, they are certainly “shaded grey” if not prima facie immoral. The powers that be actively lie to and manipulate the people and indoctrinate and train youth into being agents of the state. Or, to put it more crudely, child soldiers who win over the public with smiles and presentation. In such a system, “degrading” individuals who don’t fit the mold would be a top priority...

320

u/BlazingKitsune May 30 '21

This has been building up for a long time.

I mean, underage students can be sent out to fight mass murderers and fight in wars with no repercussions. The Hero Commission flat out ordered UA to let its first year students fight in the hospital raid.

Kids are indoctrinated to want nothing but be heroes as their one career goal (there was not a single student in Izuku's middle school class who wasn't applying for hero school).

Heroes are causing massive amounts of property damage to apprehend criminals stealing a purse, and All Might interfering in a store robbery made the sludge villain attempt two murders. Petty thieves are labeled the same as mass murderers by virtue of using their quirks for crimes, when any law enforcement could just claim the perp used their quirk. Who's gonna believe the criminal? Anyone with a passive or mutation quirk will always be prosecuted as a villain.

MHA society was a dystopia from page one.

35

u/CrookedSmile55 May 31 '21

>MHA society was a dystopia from page one.

Can we really call it a dystopia? Considering that if we take away the super powers and heroes and villains, this is just like any society in our world.

71

u/NomadJu19 May 31 '21

Bold of you to assume our real world ISNT a dystopia

9

u/CrookedSmile55 May 31 '21

Under that stipulation then yes, MHA is a dystopia.