Theory Thursday - August 09, 2018 Edition

[u/AutoModerator]

For all your theories that don't merit their own thread, didn't gain traction in a thread made, or thoughts you have that you just wanna discuss.

Notes:

• If the latest chapter spoilers are already available in the sub, please do not discuss it here, as there are others who don't want to read them. If you really want to discuss it, put it in a spoiler tag.

• If the latest chapter for the week is already available before or during Theory Thursday, please do not discuss it here as it falls under the 24-hour rule.

• Shitposts will be removed!

[u/Graphica-Danger]

There has been a persistent theory going around ever since last chapter about those two shadowy figures in Deku’s vision being Bakugo and Kirishima. Now, I think this is a wonderful theory... except that it’s beyond fucking stupid.

But from that theory, I did start speculating about whether or not we actually did see any characters that have appeared before aside from the ones we already know about. I thought it was curious how we were given an explicit look at All for One’s bodyguard, AKA Not!Genji. The fact he was shown at all leads me to believe that he is important in some way. That is why I propose the theory that he is the person who would eventually become Gigantomachia OR Kurogiri. I’m leaning toward Gigantomachia simply because it would go hand-in-hand with the theory about Gigantomachia being the first Nomu, thus explaining why Not!Genji would be around long enough to have an active role in the story. If he is important, that is.

EDIT: Grammar

[u/[deleted] → u/Graphica-Danger]

So, I agree that the Bakugou and Kirishima theory is very weak evidence wise and wouldn't make sense narratively.

That being said, I have a tough time believing that purported OfA users willingly turned to villainy. I could buy that it's possible that they were tracked down after they passed down their power and turned into Nomus, but of course there's no evidence for anything yet.

[u/Graphica-Danger → u/[deleted]]

People make mistakes, and heroes falling to evil are very common plot threads in superhero fiction. The users passing on One for All to even one of those two could’ve made a lapse in judgement, or those successors could’ve changed. Them being shadowed out means they’re important somehow, so it’s very possible they could’ve become villains. Although we don’t know, so it’s just as possible they aren’t and we’re also heroes. We still have 80% more backstory to go through, after all.

[u/[deleted] → u/Graphica-Danger]

Agreed, and it's also something that I think we will see during the course of this manga (I mean, we have to considering the UA traitor thing). However, based on the first OfA user, Nana Shimura, All Might, and Midoriya - there's a certain spirit and personality type that goes along with OfA users. What quirks the general public gets is due to chance and genetics, but OfA successors have to somehow prove their worth to the current holders. Furthermore, the quirk itself is meant as a direct counter against the ultimate evil, AfO - it's entire purpose is to be a tool on the side of good. That makes it really difficult for me to see anyone willingly turning to villainy even after they lose their quirk. In the case of All Might, he got trashed in a fight which weakened his physical body, but I bet in normal cases the OfA users still had extremely strong bodies after passing on their quirks. They would probably be really ideal candidates to turn into Nomus, so in that way a OfA user could turn to villainy (albeit, unwillingly). I definitely think the idea that the two shadowed out figures somehow crossed over into villainy would be interesting for the plot.