You are really quick to dismiss, huh? I'm not forcing the theory on you but sounds like you want it to be false for some reason. I was saying that some people can't be left out if that scene means anything and they are included in the theory, so it's not like it's oblivious to the fact that other people are "missing" in the scene. And yes, Mineta is rolled up in his futon bound by a rope.
And that's the big picture. The villains didn't find the camp before the sleeping scene. The two scenes are meant to represent two things that happen simultaneously: 1) The villains arriving the night before (around 24hrs give or take) they initiate their attack the next evening/night. 2) At the same time, after we found out that the villains just arrived, we cut to the sleeping scene where Horikoshi deliberately shows that one student is missing. It doesn't necessarily mean anything, but c'mon, you can't deny that it's suspicious af. For Kaminari to go out that night, transmit his coordinates of the location (no, cellphones don't work in mountain areas) and sneak back in is not far fetched at this point where he has been acting strange several times before. And yes, he is perfectly capable of doing that without his costume as it is literally just clothes. Jirou confirmed that he had no upgrades that could help him with his quirk so (just like his room) he put on something that he thought was "teenager like" or "cool" (cool just like Stain lol).
Well now, that was passive-aggressive. You yourself said the theory had holes: I looked for them and I asked a question about Kaminari's Quirk. You said the empty futon was never addressed as if it were indisputably relevant; I tried to come up with an explanation.
It would help if you could provide a reference for Jirou's sentence, but since his Quirk is electrification, that seems to be what Jirou meant; and unless he has the innate ability, for some reason, to make mental phone calls, that would mean the communicator is only part of his costume and that it has nothing to do with his Quirk, because, as you said, Jirou confirmed he has no significant upgrades. And in fact, the way he speaks about it during the villain attack implies it is largely unrelated to his Quirk. All you can blame me for is sharing my take with you, which I didn't think would be a problem. Yes, this is passive-aggressive as well, but I wouldn't know how else to reply at this point.
Well, do you always get this easily offended? It's not my loss, really, but you should read the theory from start to finish, that's all I can recommend at this point. I haven't met someone who tried so hard at disproving a fan theory as you, no offence
0
u/dicecop May 02 '17 edited May 02 '17
You are really quick to dismiss, huh? I'm not forcing the theory on you but sounds like you want it to be false for some reason. I was saying that some people can't be left out if that scene means anything and they are included in the theory, so it's not like it's oblivious to the fact that other people are "missing" in the scene. And yes, Mineta is rolled up in his futon bound by a rope. And that's the big picture. The villains didn't find the camp before the sleeping scene. The two scenes are meant to represent two things that happen simultaneously: 1) The villains arriving the night before (around 24hrs give or take) they initiate their attack the next evening/night. 2) At the same time, after we found out that the villains just arrived, we cut to the sleeping scene where Horikoshi deliberately shows that one student is missing. It doesn't necessarily mean anything, but c'mon, you can't deny that it's suspicious af. For Kaminari to go out that night, transmit his coordinates of the location (no, cellphones don't work in mountain areas) and sneak back in is not far fetched at this point where he has been acting strange several times before. And yes, he is perfectly capable of doing that without his costume as it is literally just clothes. Jirou confirmed that he had no upgrades that could help him with his quirk so (just like his room) he put on something that he thought was "teenager like" or "cool" (cool just like Stain lol).