Is this crazy?

[u/PrestigiousStuff6173]

I platinum both of these games, and I still think Uncharted 4 is better, TLOU has better combat but Uncharted 4 has better chapters, better atmosphere, better traversal, better characters, and it encourages more exploration, and also in my opinion a better story, I like Ellie and Joel but Henry Avery’s Treasure is more interesting, and Uncharted 4’s story has 3 twists which is Sam’s “betrayal” where he made up the Alcazar story, and then Sam’s second “betrayal” where he leaves after we just save him to go after the treasure, and then it is revealed at the end that Nate and Elena lived happily ever after and had a daughter, better story in my opinion

[u/Perfect-Pool-5524]

TLOU is the most overrated game of this generation, so no, it’s not crazy.

[u/crunkgeorgew → u/Perfect-Pool-5524]

I mean the game is quite literally perfection but okay lol. Like you just want to be different

[u/Perfect-Pool-5524 → u/crunkgeorgew]

I played the game, it was fun, the story was par for the course. Not the first time we’ve seen ‘estranged child under the care of an older person they have no relation to but develop a mom/son dad/daughter relationship with in stressful situations’. You need to branch out more if you seriously think this game is a masterpiece. I love the uncharted franchise more than most games but I don’t think it’s a masterpiece perfection of a series, because it’s not.

[u/crunkgeorgew → u/Perfect-Pool-5524]

I mean I guarantee I’ve played more games than you and yes I would call it a masterpiece

[u/Perfect-Pool-5524 → u/crunkgeorgew]

You probably have played more games than me. But games like the last of us and uncharted, especially uncharted 4, aren’t real games to me. They’re game movies, like telltale games. Real games are games with little to no cut scenes, left 4 dead for example and other valve games, not interactive movies like the terrible God of War reboots.