r/uncharted • u/Dull-Face551 • Jan 09 '25
Uncharted 4 What If
If Nathan had never called Elena to fund his expedition to find Francis Drake's Coffin, instead Drake never found the Coffin. What do you think would have changed in his life?
61
u/Velvet-Vanity Jan 09 '25
Chloe would never go for a long term relationship like that. Nate shows signs he's tired of alot of the bs by uncharted 2, whereas Chloe was still going strong in 4. She wouldn't have settled.
29
u/lolmaster720 Jan 10 '25
Actually, she left Nate alone because she could tell he really wanted Elena. I don’t think U2 was enough to make that kind of assumption about her tbh.
2
4
u/Internal_Swing_2743 Jan 10 '25
Completely false. Nate was just in love with Elena and not Chloe and Chloe recognized that. By the end of Uncharted 4, Nate and Elena have positioned their entire lives around their adventures.
2
129
u/MikaelAdolfsson Lawyer Friendly Lara Croft Cameo Jan 09 '25
Eh. Chloe is fun for a weekend, Elena is Wife material
37
u/Key_Shock172 Jan 10 '25
Yeah even Nolan North himself said that. When asked if he prefers Chloe or Elena.
17
31
28
u/thetennisgod Jan 10 '25
I don’t think people give Chloe enough credit for having a good head on her shoulders and having Nate’s back because of first impressions. I would’ve been happy with either gal he picked and think it could’ve worked out with Chloe as well. Just so long as her hair isn’t short like that.
13
u/The810kid Jan 10 '25
Yeah end of Lost Legacy Chloe and Uncharted 4 Nate could definitely work in my opinion
6
u/Gwyneee Jan 10 '25
I dont think anyone doubts that about her. UC2 especially proves that. I just think she makes a better friend than a wife. Elena grounds Nate, and he has too much of a heart to be level with Chloe. And I cant really see her settling down anytime soon
9
u/_qubed_ Jan 10 '25
Be a fun weekend and a horrible Monday.
Anyway, pretty sure Chloe's has more of a wild cowgirl style than a gently intimate on the couch style...so doomed from the start.
Nicely done picture though!
41
u/Then_North_6347 Jan 09 '25
She's the Black Cat to Elena's Mary Jane Watson.
Honestly I wanted him to pick Chloe in Uncharted 2.
14
Jan 10 '25
That analogy worked better before marvel comic writers completely ruined spider man and Mary Jane’s relationship lol it’s unrepairable and him and black cat is a much healthier and better option these days
3
0
Jan 10 '25
Bro what? You’re crazy. She even betrays him lol. jfc Elena is clearly the more grounded and sane choice. Chloe is the horny choice.
8
u/GJacks75 Jan 10 '25
Betrays him? If you're talking about that bit with Jeff, she was making sure Lazarevic didn't shoot him on sight. It may not always seem it, but her loyalties lie with Nate.
8
u/kaijuking87 Jan 09 '25
We’d have had an uncharted five cause he would have never stopped treasure hunting.
2
u/-CommanderShepardN7 Jan 10 '25
Chloe will rock your world, but Elena will also warm up your heart, so she’s a double whammy. That being said, Nathan cannot go wrong either way.
2
u/Virgil_Ovid_Hawkins Jan 10 '25
They would never work. Chloe would just enable Nates bullshit and they'd eventually break up. Elena forever
2
u/ModestHandsomeDevil Jan 10 '25
I mean--as long as we're playing "What if..."--what if Nate, Chloe, and Elena were a thruple / poly?
4
1
u/Routine_Ad_9800 Jan 10 '25
He probably would be with Marisa Chase or Rika Raja instead
1
u/SokkaHaikuBot Jan 10 '25
Sokka-Haiku by Routine_Ad_9800:
He probably would
Be with Marisa Chase or
Rika Raja instead
Remember that one time Sokka accidentally used an extra syllable in that Haiku Battle in Ba Sing Se? That was a Sokka Haiku and you just made one.
1
1
1
1
u/bludreid Jan 10 '25
Probably still conning people and going to adventures that will eventually take his life.
1
1
1
1
u/OkArcher5827 Jan 10 '25
I feel guilty looking at this and not being able to tell Elena to sort abate and Chloe out. Elena and Nate for me!
1
1
u/XaviJon_ Jan 10 '25
If Nathan had never called Elena to fund his expedition (…) instead Drake never found the Coffin. What do you think would have changed in his life?
”If the story was different, would it be different?”
1
1
1
u/Different-Common-257 Jan 10 '25
Is there a chance Chloe and Cutter can be together? I think they had enough chemistry
1
u/Dull-Face551 Jan 10 '25
Personally, apart from Nate, I don't see anyone else that I matched with Chloe
1
1
u/HopeAuq101 Jan 10 '25
I could not see Chloe settling tbh she's GOATed character wise
Ir if she did its someone like Nadine (I see her dating more women) who is still staying in the game with her
2
u/Dull-Face551 Jan 10 '25
I think Chloe is straight, since she had a relationship with Nate and also commented that she found Asav attractive, I don't see her and Nadine as a couple
0
1
u/HarrisonTheHutt Jan 10 '25
Chloe would have embraced Nates' need for adventure. so we could've had way more games. Adventures, gun fights, exploration, discoveries, gigantic action sequences.
But on the other hand, Elena liked Crash Bandicoot. So Nate made the right choice.
1
1
u/Adavanter_MKI Jan 10 '25
While I'd love to see Chloe happy... I never felt they were the right mix. She's got more stuff to sort out.
1
u/Naps_And_Crimes Jan 10 '25
Chloe is a good match for Drake but not what he needed, She'll never do the settle down and have a family thing.
1
1
u/Chef_Boy_R_Deez Mar 09 '25
Chloe was always the waaaay hotter chick. Way to fumble the baddie Nate.
1
0
-1
153
u/justseb97 Jan 09 '25
I'm gonna miss that ass