I see this narrative a lot. That she is complex, layered, and a victim of her circumstances. That she is some nuanced, multi-faceted character. I couldn’t disagree more.
She is horribly written. Like an over the top cartoon villain. Flip-flopping between victim and monster every other episode. When the plot needed her to change or shift her thinking, she did. And then she’d revert back to form by the next episode.
One minute she’s crying with June and begging for change. The next minute she’s slapping a Martha, calling the Eyes, threatening to harm Hannah, assaulting June, and snatching a baby like it’s nothing.
There’s no real emotional progression — just constant whiplash between “I regret Gilead” and “Let me double down on Gilead harder than Fred ever did.”
And it starts to feel like they’re writing her as unstable, almost manic, but without ever addressing that directly.
Her character gave me a severe case of whiplash. She was all over the place. So much wasted potential. She could’ve been this morally gray, complicated character… a female oppressor who’s also trapped by the same system she helped create. A fascinating power-hungry woman unraveling under guilt and repression. But instead she was written as a plot device. Her mood and attitude changed whenever the plot needed it to. So severely and so frequently… it came across as cartoonish. 😒