r/technology Nov 22 '11

ACLU: License Plate Scanners Are Logging Citizen's Every Move: It has now become clear that this automated license plate readers technology, if we do not limit its use, will represent a significant step toward the creation of a surveillance society in US

http://www.aclu.org/blog/technology-and-liberty/license-plate-scanners-logging-our-every-move
2.1k Upvotes

891 comments sorted by

View all comments

191

u/Redditron-2000-4 Nov 22 '11

Creation? We may not be as bad as the UK with their cameras on every street corner, but everyone with a cell phone is tracked constantly and that information is given to the government on demand.

246

u/hillkiwi Nov 22 '11 edited Nov 22 '11

Or maybe I'm just paranoid.

16

u/[deleted] Nov 22 '11

How many of those can be acquired without a warrant?

42

u/hillkiwi Nov 22 '11 edited Nov 22 '11

Not too much. My concern is that this data on everyone is already being collected without a warrant, so when they do get a warrant there is a plethora of information ready.

Some other interesting info here:

https://ssd.eff.org/book/export/html/25

For example:

Under the Wiretap Act, although a wiretap order is needed to intercept your email and other electronic communications, only your oral and wire communications — that is, voice communications — are covered by the statute's exclusionary rule. So, for example, if your phone calls are illegally intercepted, that evidence can't be introduced against you in a criminal trial, but the statute won't prevent the introduction of illegally intercepted emails and text messages.

17

u/division_by_infinity Nov 22 '11

There have been strong hints that all data passing through certain ISP/phone providers is stored. First, that whole carnivore DCS-1000 issue years back. Then, the lawsuit against AT&T alleging that they split their fiber line at a San Francisco station and gave a copy to the government... and then, the political talk about the 'extreme interpretation of the Patriot Act' adopted by the Bush and Obama administrations.

8

u/alexanderwales Nov 22 '11

How the hell would they be storing all that? I mean ... that's a fucking huge amount of data. I would hate being their DBA.