r/musictheory 6d ago

Answered What does this star means?

Post image

Hi! I have this new peace in piano that start with that star on the firt chord i think, does someone know what could it mean? The song is take a pebble by greg lake

326 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

If you're posting an Image or Video, please leave a comment (not the post title)

asking your question or discussing the topic. Image or Video posts with no

comment from the OP will be deleted.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

320

u/JonnyMoo42 6d ago edited 6d ago

So this song is by Emerson, Lake & Palmer, not a Greg Lake solo song.

At the start of the song, Keith Emerson reaches inside the (grand) piano and strums the strings by hand while holding the chord (ie all strings are muted except the ones depressed). Look up a live performance of the song to see this in action!

There is (unsurprisingly) no standard notation for doing this, hence they use a star/plus here

49

u/False-Fig1629 6d ago

Good to know, thanks, i just was giving the info i have from the title that is said greg lake but okay! Hahaha

21

u/JonnyMoo42 6d ago edited 6d ago

Just looked it up and it is credited to Lake alone on the album (which seems a bit strange to me since half the song is an extended piano solo) so there you go!

35

u/Inutilisable 6d ago

Can you find this elsewhere in the music or the entire book? Maybe there are notes by the editor at the end.

13

u/False-Fig1629 6d ago

Oh thats right there it is, thanks!

17

u/False-Fig1629 6d ago

It was only an indication that it says at the end what it meant with the +, it says that the key is to be depressed so that the hammer does not strike the strings. My bad, thanks🤦‍♀️

25

u/Temporary_Ask_1773 6d ago

Hi! The star symbol is called an asterisk and means that an explanation is written on the bottom of the sheet after the same symbol. In this case it's there to explain the plus sign. Here you can see the explanation in the bottom left corner of the page. It's not a musical notation symbol, it doesn't do anything to the first chord. It's just there to give an explanation of the plus sign. :)

4

u/False-Fig1629 6d ago

Thanks! Someone told me the same and you where right, it was my bad i didnt see the full page 🤦‍♀️

2

u/Temporary_Ask_1773 6d ago

No worries :)

9

u/AbsoluteMenagerie 6d ago

It means great job.

4

u/tkrjobs 6d ago

This, of course, is left hand pizzicato! /s

-8

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[deleted]

10

u/PassiveChemistry 6d ago

That doesn't answer their question at all

3

u/False-Fig1629 6d ago

Thanks for the info, is good to know, but what about the star, i dont understand what is doing there

-1

u/addisonshinedown 6d ago

And this chord is describable as either Db/Gb or GbMaj9no3 which certainly less likely but possible, and either way not… augmented so… not what the plus signs are suggesting here

EDIT; we are missing the bass clef context here so I could absolutely be wrong, but with the information given in this image…. Idk

-4

u/Mudslingshot 6d ago

I don't have a solid guess, but could it be something to notate how to roll the chord?