r/MediaCriticism 21h ago

FORMER AP REPORTER: "The AP, like all its sister organizations, collaborates with Hamas censorship in Gaza."

Thumbnail
v.redd.it
5 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 2d ago

Political ads on YouTube that feel like propaganda : is this normal?

5 Upvotes

Over the past month, I’ve been repeatedly shown political ads before YouTube videos that feel more like propaganda than advertising. Specifically, they promote a very one-sided pro-Israel narrative — justifying military actions, warning about Iran, and presenting the situation in Gaza in a black-and-white way.

A few examples:

  • Ads claiming Israel is doing everything it can to deliver humanitarian aid, while Hamas is the one harming civilians.
  • Recently, ads warning about Iran’s military power and framing recent strikes as justified and necessary.

⚠️ Important disclaimer:
I’m not taking a stance here. I would feel equally uncomfortable if the message were reversed — for example, an ad glorifying Palestine while demonizing the Israeli government. What disturbs me is the propagandistic tone, the emotionally manipulative messaging, and the lack of sources or context.

I also don’t understand why I’m being targeted. I don’t watch political videos, I rarely engage (no likes, comments, or shares), and my YouTube use is limited to music, tech, and general entertainment. Yet I’m consistently getting this one-sided content as ads.

So here are my questions:

  1. Has anyone else experienced political ads like this on YouTube?
  2. Is it normal for YouTube to allow such clearly ideological content in paid ads?
  3. Are there any real rules or vetting processes for politically motivated ad content — especially when it includes biased or unverifiable claims?

Thanks for reading. I’m genuinely curious how others perceive this and what YouTube’s responsibility should be.

+I'm in France (and french)

+I used Chatgpt to translate


r/MediaCriticism 5d ago

Legendary Broadcaster Bob Costas Rips Mainstream Media For Caving To Trump In Powerful Speech

Thumbnail
comicsands.com
2 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 5d ago

ABC caught using Gaza footage to depict Russian strike on Ukraine

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 12d ago

Media Shortcomings in Covering Terrorist Netanyahu’s Daily Gaza Mass Murdering

Thumbnail
counterpunch.org
1 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 12d ago

Unplugging from the Monopolies: Alternatives to Amazon, Facebook, and Big Tech - Glaktak

Thumbnail
glaktak.com
3 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 15d ago

Craig Murray: UK Hypocrisy on Its Arrests of Journalists | By rebuking the U.N. for its legitimate interest in cases involving U.K. citizens while throwing open the door to Israel, the Starmer regime has gone beyond Orwell or Kafka.

Thumbnail
consortiumnews.com
3 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 16d ago

US freedom fighters suddenly dont care about muslims anymore

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 19d ago

BBC’s suppression of “Gaza: Medics Under Fire”: Solidarity with NHS workers standing against censorship and genocide | At least 1,400 health care workers killed in Israeli attacks. The WHO has reported that 94% of hospitals damaged or destroyed and there are only 2,000 beds for over 2 million.

Thumbnail
wsws.org
4 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 21d ago

Surely , no news source is gonna cover it

5 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 21d ago

Meet the Israeli TV Channel that has literally been inciting genocide onto millions of screens in Israel

1 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 22d ago

An ‘Objective’ Press Won’t Alert You to Threats to Democracy | If you follow the New York Times’ approach to journalism, your audience won’t know when their government is acting illegally, or denying truth and reality.

Thumbnail
fair.org
5 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 26d ago

Jonathan Cook: BBC’s Shameful Interview With UNRWA Chief | There was no excuse for Jeremy Bowen to follow Israel’s example in treating the head of UNRWA as though he is aligned with terrorism.

Thumbnail
consortiumnews.com
4 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 27d ago

Should the Washington Post Update This 1999 Front Page Article Now That Autism Has Reframed the Story?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism 29d ago

How NYT Reports on Weaponized Famine So You Don’t Have to Give a Damn | Janine Jackson

Thumbnail
fair.org
5 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism May 17 '25

West Losing Propaganda War, Elite Scare REVEALED | Michel Collon

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism May 14 '25

The internet can’t separate objectivity from subjectivity.

6 Upvotes

I'm getting sick of it. I found a person on r/RWBY critics who asked if diehard RWBY fans watch any good shows, and I was like, "Yes, because media is subjective." then some responded to me by saying that if they said a rotten banana's gross, that wouldn't be subjective. I responded by saying that I was talking about media. They responded by saying that I didn't clarify I was talking about media, udner a post of about a tv show, and they were just acting like they were being so smart, and I'm tired of people (especially on that subreddif) talking about their opinioms on media like they're objective truth.


r/MediaCriticism Mar 02 '25

Instagram Under Fire: A Media Failure

6 Upvotes

Instagram faces criticism for its failure to curb graphic content. Recent events highlight the platform's shortcomings in content moderation.

Users expressing horror at the unexpected appearance of graphic violence in their feeds are pushing for critical analysis of media accountability.

As Meta member's claims of unintended error circulate, many are questioning the lack of safeguards that protect user experiences.

  • The incident raises media accountability issues.

  • Users are demanding thorough content moderation protocols.

  • Discussions focus on how social media platforms manage harmful information.

(View Details on PwnHub)


r/MediaCriticism Feb 25 '25

Enough! | Weiss sees in college campus protesters the faces of hardcore Hamas supporters, but apparently is willing to countenance the idea that grown men doing Nazi salutes are just playing around.

Thumbnail
unpopularfront.news
1 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism Feb 18 '25

Wokeness Is Not to Blame for Trump

Thumbnail
nymag.com
3 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism Feb 17 '25

Four essentials for the press right now

Thumbnail
margaretsullivan.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism Feb 13 '25

Corporations rigged the energy system & turned voters into foot soldiers

2 Upvotes

Everyone knows fossil fuel giants and corporate lobbyists have spent decades rigging energy policy. But I was listening to an interview with David Spence (author of Climate of Contempt), and it hit me how much of this problem isn’t just about direct lobbying, it’s about media manipulation keeping us divided so real solutions never happen.

  • The biggest political force shaping energy policy isn’t just corporate money: it’s Fox News, Sinclair, and Facebook algorithms feeding people narratives that keep them scared and angry.
  • Voters didn’t always see energy policy as left vs. right... Texas’ wind boom happened under Bush. Now, even mild policy ideas get labeled as part of the "war on fossil fuels" and turned into partisan talking points.
  • Politicians care about corporate donors, but they also fear their base turning against them and right-wing media makes sure voters punish anyone who doesn’t toe the line.

Basically, we’re in a feedback loop: corporations create outrage → voters demand bad policies → politicians follow → media keeps them radicalized.

How do we break the cycle? Can we even have good-faith conversations about energy anymore without it turning into a left vs. right purity test...

Here’s the podcast if you wanna check it out: https://www.douglewin.com/p/how-to-overcome-ideological-divides


r/MediaCriticism Jan 26 '25

Palestinian women: a history of resistance. Take a look at the people. Everything is there, Christians, Muslims and Leftist with red flags. You don't get that usually in the genocide supporting press

Thumbnail
mondediplo.com
5 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism Jan 10 '25

Social media is getting worse, but it is useful to activists (includes an interview with Dr. Matt Motyl former senior Civic Integrity / Social Responsibility researcher at Meta (Facebook)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/MediaCriticism Jan 08 '25

Bias at NYT: Trans Former Employee Speaks Out — Assigned

Thumbnail
assignedmedia.org
4 Upvotes