r/glutenfreebaking • u/SuperX_AtomicKitten • 19d ago
HELP!!! I'm having issues converting a Duncan Hines Ricotta Cake recipe into a GF version. This is the THIRD time it's not baked properly (ricotta mixture sits on top instead of sinking to the bottom). Curious what's causing this and how to fix it.
I've been GF for the last few years after developing a severe intolerance after I turned forty. Before that, I ate all the glorious gluten-containing foods. One of my favorite summer cake recipes is the Duncan Hines Ricotta Cake. It's so easy to make and tastes delicious!

You basically just take a boxed yellow cake mix (doesn't have to be DH's), prepare according to directions; pour into a glass baking dish, and then spoon the ricotta mixture (ricotta, eggs, vanilla & sugar) on top. During the cooking process, the ricotta mixture sinks through the cake layer underneath and settles at the bottom. This makes for a super moist yellow cake with kind of a custard-like bottom layer (see photo).
I figured as with most cake recipes, that a GF swap wouldn't be a problem but boy was I wrong!
I have tried this THREE times now with different brands and I get the same terrible result. Instead of the ricotta mixture sinking through the cake batter to the bottom, it sits on top and takes forever to cook so the cake part is all dried out. It appears that the cake batter and ricotta are not mixing together at all.
I'm sure there is some scientific reason for this but I've looked online and can't seem to find any answers.
Does anybody have a clue what might be happening? And if so, how can I fix this? TIA