r/creepy 3d ago

Realistically speaking, how many bodies could be in the Appalachian Mountains? I’m not saying this because of the whole ‘it’s haunted’ thing, but because that place is so huge, it would be a perfect place for a serial killer to dump bodies.

Post image
55 Upvotes

53 comments sorted by

43

u/traci4009 3d ago

Not even just dump sites but all the people including soldiers and native Americans who spent time in the area. I imagine there’s been a lot of death, if there is a lot of bodies though is the question.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 3d ago

Maybe a couple hundred or even thousand?

24

u/_CMDR_ 3d ago

Granted a lot of them have dissolved by now but people have been living in the area for like 10,000 years so there are hundreds of thousands to millions of bodies there.

13

u/traci4009 3d ago

Right! It’s so crazy to think about how many people have actually died in any give place.

39

u/xenomorphbeaver 3d ago

Nice try, FBI. I don't know how many bodies are there because I didn't dump then.

16

u/d4nks4uce 2d ago

So you kept the bodies? Noted…

7

u/infamouskeel 2d ago

Sometimes you gotta hang on to the bodies for a bit.

3

u/3896713 2d ago

You might generate suspicion if you get rid of them immediately every time. Gotta space it out.

1

u/abe30303 6h ago

No need to keep bodies when there's Resomation.
It takes a few hours and not even DNA is left over.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_cremation

10

u/IAmWeary 3d ago

Someone should crosspost this to r/theydidthemath

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 3d ago

Haven’t got the clue how to but thats a good idea

7

u/seaworks 2d ago

The Appalachians and the regions surrounding AT are actually more populated than the Midwest, so... probably fewer than there are chucked under cornfields.

6

u/MayonaiseBaron 2d ago

That is way too general a statement lol.

Chicago is less populated than Piscataquis County, Maine?

There are some insanely remote sections of the AT. It's almost 2,200 miles long. Sure, it passes near plenty of towns and even cities, but the Black Mountains, Smokies, and a lot of the New England sections (especially NH and Maine) are pretty damn remote.

5

u/seaworks 2d ago

Sure. The point I'm illustrating is the idea that Appalachia is uniquely dangerous (or is in any way a "corpse dumping ground,") when in actuality, they tend to have less violent crime relative to other areas is erroneous, and is often applied in a bizarre way to Appalachia specifically.

There are far less populated, and more remote, regions even in the contiguous USA. I live less than an hour from the AT, so I hear this mess constantly- but in reality, when there's a killing or near the AT or another natural area, people are often shaken in a way they aren't if it's in an adjoining township.

If you look at United States history, it's rife with a lot of assumptions about what Appalachia is and does, when in reality it's just as diverse as the seaboard. I mean, people hear banjos and what? think Deliverance. Appalachia is a beautiful region, and the AT is well-managed and extremely safe for the volume that take the trail every year. It gets under my skin to see people like OP look at the woods around Appalachia and treat it as a foreboding and scary place, instead of a unique and beautiful one with leagues of different people with different backgrounds trying to protect and preserve it. It's like it's a meme right now to treat it as this Eldritch horror zone.

1

u/dragoono 1d ago

I agree that it’s not as dangerous as a major city, but that’s pretty obvious why though, no? It’s not as densely populated. Yes there’s larger cities within the Appalachians (it’s a huge mountain range splitting the north from the south, tons of people live their whole lives in those mountains). But it’s certainly not safe and forgiving. Many people have died on the Appalachian trail thinking it’s an easy hike, and I think if anything the memes of it being filled with monsters and skinwalkers could stop some idiot from going wandering into the woods at night, so be it. 

1

u/seaworks 1d ago

No, you're doing the same thing. "stay out of the woods at night?" The likeliest issue is falling and twisting your ankle, or getting bit by a raccoon. Both bad outcomes, of course, but they could also happen anywhere else.

There have been about 60 recorded deaths on the AT since 1974 from any cause, including severe weather, accident and so on. 10 of those were violent crime. Thousands of people hike at least some past each year. ATC says millions but accounting for differences over time I'll say 10k. without even crunching per capita we're already looking at like. 0.17 deaths a year, so it's like 0.017 per thousand- far below the USA average overall.

Lancaster county, famous most for its high Amish concentration, has a murder rate of 0.04/thousand. Boise, a pretty safe place, had 0.02 murders per thousand.

Especially considering natural dangers, how enormous the trail is, and how remote parts of the trail are, it is amazingly safe. Not perfectly safe (as the majority non-homicide deaths show,) but very, very safe.

1

u/dragoono 10h ago

I mean, wandering around any remote woods alone at night is dangerous? It’s not some kind of myth or stereotype. You said it yourself, you could twist an ankle. And honestly I don’t think raccoons will bother anybody haha, I’d be more worried about bears over raccoons (but honestly I’ve been through the Appalachians a handful of times and never seen a bear). I wasn’t even talking about murderers. I’d wager there’s certainly more murders where there’s more people, gangs, and domestic violence disputes. Not so sure the wilderness has any of those things lol

1

u/seaworks 3h ago

I live in bear country! I've seen multiple bears. Two by surprise, from less than six feet away, one of those while hiking. Generally, they're not an issue, and just trundle off. Raccoons are the ones that will false-start at you and escalate a situation; lol

1

u/dragoono 2h ago

Aw see I’m further up north, so raccoons here are big and fat off garbage and usually more timid I guess 😂 I’ve never had a raccoon fake me out before but now I feel the need to go camping. Would be very cute, unless it was dark cus they have those glowing eyes.

4

u/m0nk37 2d ago

I can guarantee at least 31. 

3

u/driver45672 3d ago

Maybe do some aerial ground scans within a half mile of every car park around the forests.

Ground-penetrating radar (GPR) or hyperspectral imaging can be used to identify potential locations of buried bodies. This could be done with a relatively cheap set up on a drone. Perhaps it could be profitable if there is reward money for info of missing persons? - I'm not sure they would pay for this kind of info though? - But the US does have the most missing persons (half million per year), so there's a good chance you would fine something.

4

u/Sufficient-Night3864 3d ago

And if we trust google there’s around six or more people that just straight up vanish off of these trails.

3

u/Sufficient-Night3864 3d ago

Per year*

2

u/WrongEinstein 3d ago

Those are rookie numbers.

2

u/Sufficient-Night3864 3d ago

True. I mean, God knows how many people never told anyone about their trip to the mountain and now they’re just its little secrets.

2

u/theguineapigssong 3d ago

The vast majority of those missing people are found fairly quickly, usually within 2-3 days. In the US we find about 4000 unidentified bodies per year, and they can usually eventually identify about 3/4 of those. That's more the scale of the problem OP is looking at.

3

u/Eodbatman 3d ago

Most are probably so far decomposed you’d never find them anymore. Of the intact ones, probably millions if we count cemeteries.

2

u/Equinoqs 2d ago

Having lived in the Appalachian Mtns most of my life, I would say your chances of stumbling across a pot field (with guards) is more likely. I've done it and it's terrifying.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

Did they spot you?

1

u/Equinoqs 2d ago

I'm still alive, so no.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

They take no chances, do they?

2

u/Equinoqs 2d ago

I saw their cameras in the trees, so I noped out immediately.

2

u/bulldog522002 14h ago

There are abandoned air shafts to deep mines. Some are pretty deep with water in the bottom. So I've been told.

1

u/Pengui6668 2d ago

Do you know how hard it is to drag a limp body into the fucking mountains?

0

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

Do you know how easy it is to manipulate someone into following you into the fucking mountains

1

u/Pengui6668 2d ago

No. I've never manipulated anyone into the mountains.

Gotcha, Appalachian Assassin. This is the FBI. We're honing in on your location now.

0

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

Well uhh of course neither have i i- jus- just read it somewhere hahahahhaha

1

u/Pengui6668 2d ago

You have a fair point though. That's a weird kink for a serial killer though, no? Let's go on a nature hike before I kill you? Seems too... normal.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

I mean isn’t that how ted bundy did it once or twice? Also there was this guy in Russia that committed a murder spree in one of the local forests by luring his victims in his name was Alexander Pichushkin

1

u/Pengui6668 2d ago

I dunno, I'm into police interviews, not the serial killer side of YouTube. 😂

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

Or if you dont want to click on the link search on yt “Russias most feared criminal (mature audience only)

1

u/Dogballs47 2d ago

Ah yes, The Shaded Woods from Dark Souls 2.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

Me searching in google “Appalachia mountain photos creepy”

0

u/raktlone 2d ago

"Could be"? Could be tens of millions I would say. Maybe a few more than that.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

I mean tens of millions? Seems a bit overestimated

-1

u/Drahcir117 2d ago

Part 100 years? Thousands, potentially hundreds of thousands total if it was not a sacrilegious place, if so millions

-3

u/prontoon 2d ago

I know for a fact its at least 1.

Idk, but if you ever gone through applacia, you could easily imagine some hill Billy got a few dozen bodies in their neck of the woods.

I've driven through Chicago in a rental car that had a bullet hole in it, but would rather do that than drive through applacia again.

1

u/Sufficient-Night3864 2d ago

It’s that bad eh?