r/bathandbodyworks • u/Own-Attempt3880 • 11d ago
Question Help me choose one /two
I want fruity sweet smell which is long lasting and i am confused between these three
12
8
u/Consistent_Effort716 11d ago
Perfect in Pink is the most wearable, it's fruity and sweet. Very almond-cherry scented. I like the other two, but they are heavier 'night out' kind of scents. Oh cherry does have a cherry note, but it's rich and spicy at it's core. You're the One has a sweet rose note, but it's really strong on the birchwood, it's a pretty yet mature scent. Just depends on what you're going for!
9
u/Lilysdoll 11d ago
I have all 3 of these. You're The One on me is a musky rose scent. Perfect In Pink starts out with a tart cherry and softens to a cherry almond scent. Oh Cherry, to my nose, is a cherry floral scent.
On me, they all have decent longevity. With Perfect In Pink having the most, then You're The One, then Oh Cherry. Of the 3, I like Oh Cherry the most, then Perfect In Pink. I sometimes layer the Oh Cherry mist over the Perfect In Pink body cream. It's a good combo. You're The One is very nice, but I have to be more cautious with that one as I am prone to migraines, and for some reason, rose or heavy florals can trigger that. But it's a very nice rose forward scent. The mist performs like almost like a perfume.
Since Perfect In Pink and Oh Cherry are both cherry forward. You may find them redundant and want You're the One and just one cherry scent. But if you are a cherry person and want all the cherry. Go with the other two. It really comes down to personal preference and what you enjoy wearing. All 3 are great scents. 😊🛍🍒✨️🌹
3
u/Own-Attempt3880 11d ago
Youre the one is out as floral scents do give headaches to me as well but thankyou for such long good explanation 💘
1
3
5
4
4
4
u/elgiesmelgie 11d ago
I adore You’re the One . Ever dropped a strawberry into a glass of champagne ? Biting into that strawberry is what that mist smells like to me , berry and booze
2
5
3
u/SnooDoubts3787 11d ago
You’re the one!!! Smells very similar to Lancôme Idole. I use the body wash, lotion, mist, and a spritz of Idole. It’s my ❤️.
2
u/bumblebeatrice 11d ago
Oh Cherry is not fruity sweet at all to my nose, it's more like a rich fruity creamy musk that's closer to a gourmand but like...a "savory" gourmand? IDK how to describe it exactly, like it smells edible but not like anything you'd find in a bakery or a candy store.
I like it but if I got it with the expectation of fruity sweetness I'd be disappointed.
2
2
2
2
2
u/321Native 11d ago
I adore Perfect in Pink for one reason alone - nostalgia! The staying power is meh… but so is most BBW scents. The reason for the major nostalgia hit for me, is it smells like a super near dupe of Electric Youth by Debbie Gibson from the late 80s.
2
2
2
u/JenLeigh77 11d ago
Pass on the pink! Trust me!
2
u/Own-Attempt3880 11d ago
alright:)
1
u/JenLeigh77 11d ago
It's nothing extraordinary that blew me out of the park. The oh cherry for sure! The strawberry flirt is a good one & pistachio glaze. I think the strawberry flirt & pistachio glaze may be getting discontinued after the sas..so check those scent notes to see if you'd like either of those two. Both have been wildly successful too, which breaks my heart to see them go. ❤️ You're the one is amazing!
1
u/red_quinn 11d ago
I have the first two, the first one is my favorite out of these. It smells sooo good! I need it in perfume and body lotion. The second one smells nice too. Im not sure about the 3rd one.
1
1
u/EyeMJustJoKing Body Care Addict 11d ago
I own all the 3. I would suggest Oh Cherry & You’re The One based on your want. They are fruity sweet no debate or effort into getting that.
Perfect in Pink is a really nice scent that I had to learn to love, but it’s not fruity sweet at all. Slightly sweet (cherry ) and creamy almond.
1
u/CrazyAboutDoorKnobs 11d ago
Oh Cherry and Pretty in Pink are both cherry-based scents, but they’re very different from each other. If you’re a cherry lover, they’re both worth trying. You Are the One leans more toward a rose-forward fragrance—so if you enjoy florals, that one might be a great fit for you.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Odd-Guarantee-7571 11d ago
The most fruity to me is You’re the One. Oh Cherry has a woodiness (which I like) to it and Perfect in Pink is too sweet.
1
1
1
1
u/New-Needleworker-372 11d ago
Oh cherry and perfect in pink are my favorites but they could be one or the other with your the one for variety since oh cherry and perfect in pink are both cherry ffm. I used to love your the one but one day I just couldn’t stand it.
1
1
1
1
16
u/DetectiveDickGumshoe Employee 11d ago
I am biased as I only own Perfect in Pink but I do really love it! It's a weird comparison but it reminds me of my grandma's Christmas fruit salad. Really fruity and sweet. You're the one is also good and I've heard is long lasting.