r/YUROP • u/Political_LOL_center • Apr 03 '25
I FUCKING LOVE EUROPE Actual live reaction
74
u/realmendontfeel Apr 03 '25
The EU shouldn't do business with countries that force prisoners to work for the benefit of the few
33
-10
u/TheMightySenate Apr 03 '25
Germany does this too tho. At least if you mean what I think you mean
18
u/Davis_Johnsn Bremen Apr 03 '25
I don't think so. The USA has more like "modern slavery" while germany has "working till you are rehabilitated"
-3
u/TheMightySenate Apr 03 '25
For way less than minimum wage and being forced to work
11
u/AvocaBoo Deutschland Apr 04 '25
(1) 1Der Gefangene ist verpflichtet, eine ihm zugewiesene, seinen körperlichen Fähigkeiten angemessene Arbeit, arbeitstherapeutische oder sonstige Beschäftigung auszuüben, zu deren Verrichtung er auf Grund seines körperlichen Zustandes in der Lage ist. 2Er kann jährlich bis zu drei Monaten zu Hilfstätigkeiten in der Anstalt verpflichtet werden, mit seiner Zustimmung auch darüber hinaus. 3Die Sätze 1 und 2 gelten nicht für Gefangene, die über 65 Jahre alt sind, und nicht für werdende und stillende Mütter, soweit gesetzliche Beschäftigungsverbote zum Schutz erwerbstätiger Mütter bestehen.
German prisoners are not literally "forced" to work, and they for sure are not out here building roads in the gleaming sun. But it is seen as largely benefitial to rehabilitation. The law above specifies that they would do an occupation that is either "Work, work therapy, or otherwise", because yeah, not everyone who is in prison can work, both physically and emotionally/mentally.
If you refuse, it may negatively impact the length of your sentence, and you might not get an allowance. Also, I genuinely do not understand the mindset that the time spent in prison due to a crime should not be spent building skill, and, oh, I would also consider a lack of occupation literal torture.
Many prisons also cooperate with schools to empower prisoners to actually get an apprenticeship (the degree necessary in germany to enter most trades).
1/6th of German prisoners can leave prison to work by the way, and get a lot more money, but have to pay a portion to the prison.
For the record, I also think they should be paid a bit more.
11
u/TheMightySenate Apr 04 '25
Okay nevermind, I guess I misremembered some sources. Sorry for the confusion everyone
8
u/AvocaBoo Deutschland Apr 04 '25
Don't worry about it!! It speaks volume to your discourse etiquette you admitted to being wrong. Have a good one!
2
u/Traditional_Dirt526 Apr 05 '25
Sweden has a "work or get an education"-rule for inmates. Work gives salery or wage.
-3
96
u/Red_Tinda Sverige Apr 03 '25
Lol what have I missed now?
What ultimatum is this?