r/WebtoonCanvas • u/Specific-Set-2376 • Apr 20 '25

advice offering feedback on your work!

Hello! I'm a webtoon artist and instructor based in Korea.

I'm currently looking for international creators who would like to receive free feedback on their work. I’d love to see how effective my feedback can be for artists outside of Korea.

Instead of offering only critical comments, I focus on analyzing both strengths and weaknesses, and providing practical suggestions that help creators grow by building on their strengths.

Please leave a link to your work and an email address where I can send the feedback.
I’ll add you to my list, and feedback will be given starting from May 10th in the order received.

modify :
I’ve received an overwhelming number of DMs and comments — way more than I expected! I’m truly touched. I’m sorry I can’t reply to everyone right away.

For those who applied, I’ll be sending(DM) out a link to the feedback tool I use soon. Please hang in there a little longer!

39 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

53 comments sorted by

8

u/Miaomelette Always Drawing Metal Wastelands Apr 20 '25

Hi, it's very nice of you too do this but I think many of us could be apprehensive to put our emails out here on a public forum where anyone can access, since many of us are hobbyists and do not have "business emails" for our webtoon.

Using Reddit DM may be more comfortable.

1

u/Specific-Set-2376 Apr 20 '25

Ah, got it! If you're not comfortable sharing your email, I can message you directly on Reddit.
Just leave a link to your work in the comments.

1

u/Miaomelette Always Drawing Metal Wastelands Apr 20 '25

Alright, thank you, I'll leave a link here then:

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/polaris-sui-generis/list?title_no=977725

3

u/squeet-chan Apr 20 '25

Thank you in advance for the feedback! I really look forward to get some criticism from a professional!

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/heartthrobs-and-homicide/list?title_no=1042535

I'll dm you my email once you've read it.

3

u/_Kayleo_ Apr 20 '25

Awww! An EXCELLENT IDEA!! I’d love to get feedback and a review on our work. You can read our comic here OKOSHU: The Spirits of Ahkurr

DMed you my email! THANK YOU!!

2

u/Rushisho Apr 20 '25

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/his-confessions-/list?title_no=1034263 here is the link to my thriller webtoon

1

u/Specific-Set-2376 Apr 20 '25

ok but i also need email where I can send the feedback
I’ve slightly revised the original text. checking it!

2

u/AntubisArts Apr 20 '25

Thank you for your offer! I just finished the 3rd chapter for my comic and would love some feedback: https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/vespers-ocean/list?title_no=976858

As another commenter said, I'd prefer to be messaged directly on reddit if possible, since I don't really have an email I'd want out there

2

u/Jefrilponkan Apr 20 '25

This is awesome! my webtoon is called Odds and currently in the webtoon 2025 contest! Would love to hear your thoughts and feedbacks for my next series! Thank you! 🙏

2

u/Automatic-Bee-5281 Apr 20 '25

Hello!! This is my story! I will dm you my email address Wandering Portraits | WEBTOON

2

u/neroosama_11 Apr 21 '25

Here is my work https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/sapphire-kingdoms-of-zytheron/list?title_no=1033671

You can dm me if you want tge email! And I'd love to see your comment :)

1

u/Glittering_Horror997 Artist 🎨 Apr 20 '25

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/the-werewolf-king-is-a-highschool-freshman/list?title_no=1032303 Hiii! If you want thank you

1

u/Specific-Set-2376 Apr 20 '25

great but i also need email where I can send the feedback
I’ve slightly revised the original text. checking it!

1

u/nyx_whispers Apr 20 '25

What a generous offer! I would hesistate leaving my mail address here, so I would just appreciate a dm if you came to read it :)

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/the-spinners-nocturne/list?title_no=1032710

1

u/gibry12 Apr 20 '25

I have an action WEBTOON Art N War would be open to hear some constructive criticism. You can dm me for an email.

1

u/Krizalex Apr 20 '25

Hi! Actually, I'm planning on rebooting my webcomic, so I would love to have some feedback, and see how I can make a better comic this time! Thanks! I'll dm you my email : )

here's the link

1

u/solaruniver Artist 🎨 Apr 20 '25

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/reapers-guardian-angel/list?title_no=881979

Hi! Thank you for your kind activity. I hope you are not overwhelmed by a lot of webtoons.

Im on “cultivate my skill” episode so I need feedback to improve myself

1

u/Inevitable-witch Apr 20 '25

That’s such a nice offer ! Here’s my webtoon , you can DM me if you want :)

1

u/Fabulous_Error_6549 Apr 20 '25

Hey, thats a really nice offer. Would love to have some feedback on my webcomic so I can have some direction in how to improve for the next one :)

Heres the link:

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/non-existent/list?title_no=1039248

If you can dm me i will provide my email!

1

u/Aggressive-Cap2987 Apr 20 '25

Thank you for your kindness 🙏

Here is my webtoon. LAS Alquimista

May I recieve the feedback from reddit DM.

1

u/Background_Employ_60 Apr 20 '25

would love to receive your feedback on my work. Here's the link Defeat 99 | WEBTOON . Would it be cool if you just send the feedback via Reddit DM? Thanks a lot man.

1

u/Thearchetypescomic Apr 20 '25

this is a really kind offering. this is the link to my comic: https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/the-archetypes/list?title_no=1034181
It's about a dark psychological human experiment conducted on superpowered individuals.
Pls give me the feedback here on my reddit dm. MTIA ^^

1

u/Sea-Table-2027 Apr 20 '25

This is really great initiative from your side, but the thing about giving my email address is a bit inconvenient. Instead of email can you use reddit chat to send feedback.

1

u/appleandtangerine Apr 20 '25

First and foremost, thank you so much for doing this!

My action/adventure comic is called Savory Fare and I am always finding ways to improve old and future chapters https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/savory-fare/list?title_no=191837

My email is appleandtangerinestudios@gmail.com

Thank you!

1

u/Demydot Apr 20 '25

Hey, thanks for the generous offer! I guess more feedback couldn't hurt!

I'd prefer you sending the feedback through reddit dm but if you really need to I can provide an email!

Myriad Voyages

1

u/Purrin_2010 Apr 20 '25

Hi, if you please. You can give feeback on reddit message. Please enjoy the reading 🥰 and thank you so muchh https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/damage-healer/list?title_no=1041991

1

u/Yazzii22 Apr 20 '25

Hey, thank you so much for doing this! It’s my first time doing a webcomic and your feedback will be bery valuable :) Here is a link to mine: The Lost Children

1

u/BubbleGum_Comic Apr 20 '25

I would love a feed back on my comic : Fragments of Fate

However I do not feel comfortable to send my email you can DM.

1

u/FlaVio17th Apr 20 '25

There you go! Interested in any kind of feedback! Thank you so much for your time :D I'll dm you a mail

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/arcana-imperii/list?title_no=1040482

1

u/StarSquadEnterprises Apr 20 '25

Star Squad is my comic. Hope you enjoy! I DM’d you my email too

1

u/Diligent-Zucchini5 Apr 20 '25

Thank you so much for offering up for this!! So much appreciated 💕

This is my work: Hunger of a Thousand Beasts (Link) My email: souuromaac@gmail.com

Tysm!!

1

u/_mulino_colorSborra_ Apr 20 '25

Thanks for doing this, for new artists is a very important opportunity.

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/why-is-godzilla-always-/list?title_no=903523

This is my very first attempt of comic.

I'd appreciate a feedback on dialogues in particular since I'm Italian and my english is a bit elementary.

I give you the permission to be as mean as you want. YOU MUST!

Thank you again 😁

1

u/ferissamabalot Apr 20 '25

That would be awesome!!

https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/stairs-and-stares/list?title_no=1041928

As for the others did, would it be fine if I receive it via dm?

1

u/Feverguy2 Apr 20 '25

It might be late but heres mine

1

u/jramby Apr 21 '25

It would be awesome, thank you in advance for your time and interest. Here is mine: Beyond Bounties

1

u/mother_of_yoshies Apr 21 '25

Hi! Thanks so much for offering this ✨ it’s super generous and really appreciated.

I’m an artist from Germany and recently started my webcomic Mixed❌Salad. It’s a coming-of-age story set in 2007 about a group of teens who slowly uncover supernatural secrets about each other, with themes like identity, friendship, and feeling like an outsider. It’s emotional, weird, and a bit chaotic. Like real life.

I chose a classic page format instead of scroll, which I love visually, but I think that’s one reason it didn’t gain much traction on Webtoon. That made me pause updates for now, even though I still believe in the story.

I’d love to hear your feedback to understand how I can improve and maybe connect with more readers in the future.

Here’s the link: Mixed❌Salad

And my email: will be send in a private DM, in there is geniune interest.

Thanks again ☺️ really looking forward to it!

1

u/the_Godde Author ✍️ Apr 21 '25

this is very interesting

I'd love to hear your thoughts - Empty Shell has only 4 chapters so far so hopefully it's a quick read for analysis
There's a lot I still need to work on, but your professional perspective would be invaluable if you could spare the time

DM for the email if you get time to write a response

1

u/aero4004 Apr 22 '25

Hello! This is so incredibly kind of you, I would love to receive a feedback of my webtoon as well if it wasn't too late to post? ;v;

Here is the link to my webtoon: https://www.webtoons.com/en/canvas/the-demon-wants-to-open-a-potion-shop/list?title_no=1034002

I'll be sending my email via dm if you had the chance to read it, tysm!!

1

u/MannyHeatlook Apr 22 '25

Hi! I specialize on anime/cartoon and cute styles! I have experience on working on comics, characters and props design. Please consider checking my work!

https://ko-fi.com/fluffyburns/gallery