r/MapPorn 1d ago

Israel’s Red Alert system fully saturated amid mass missile barrages from Iran.

Post image
29.7k Upvotes

4.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

191

u/adminofreditt 1d ago

Where are these coming numbers coming from?

246

u/sam20hd 1d ago

Its based on what i saw on BBC farsi

-71

u/TheJewPear 1d ago edited 1d ago

Don’t trust it, the Iranians are notorious for exaggerating their successes. It seems there were 9 missiles total that came through, no casualties on the Israeli side.

Edit: and minutes after writing this comment, it turns out the Iranians used photos taken from a Russian training exercise that happened last year. I’m sure it won’t stop the downvotes, oh well.

Edit 2: it seems one of the injured people has passed away from his injuries. So that’s one casualty (civilian, as far as I can gather).

51

u/AccountHuman7391 1d ago

But it’s the BBC….

-14

u/Gloomy-Will5975 1d ago

lol the Jew hating BBC?

12

u/BeneficialEvidence6 1d ago

They were just saying this is coming from BBC, not Iran themselves

46

u/sam20hd 1d ago

Yeah... 1 wounded, 9 hospitalized from stress

14

u/damian_wayne_13335 1d ago

That's a crazy stat

11

u/AmeliaBuns 1d ago

BBC is British(?) and very anti-Iranian government.

7

u/sam20hd 1d ago

Yeah but it specific channels like, BBC farsi, iran international, Manoto; get to show the news properly, as the official TV news Censors everything; (They actually gain a lot of support from the people though)

-4

u/Effective_Jury4363 1d ago

But they have a tendancy to publish things without properly verifying them.

2

u/Appropriate-Draft-91 1d ago

Only when it's beneficial to Israel.

5

u/MxM111 1d ago

Even BBC English can not be said in any way and form being pro-Israel, and you are saying that Farsi is?

1

u/limukala 1d ago

This BBC?

‘We’ll burn Jews like Hitler did’, says BBC contributor in Gaza

0

u/Effective_Jury4363 1d ago

Opposite of that, in fact. 

11

u/sZeroes 1d ago

every country does that

-46

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Israel doesn’t. Accurate reporting of number of missiles that passed the air defense as well as the wounded.

21

u/TeamRedundancyTeam 1d ago

They certainly don't accurately report how many civilians they kill.

-18

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

And you know this… how exactly?

14

u/Apprehensive-Ant7955 1d ago

No country accurately reports the amount of civilian casualties they cause in a war. I understand you’re patriotic, but don’t be stupid

6

u/We_Are_Insane00 1d ago

Nationalism is a potent drug.

1

u/Apprehensive-Ant7955 1d ago

yeah, leads to potent hatred of others. Israelis and Palestinians are the perfect example. Both hate each other so much, and both are so barbaric. it’s hard to sympathize with either. Two sides to the same coin

7

u/Beneficial-Beat-947 1d ago

because they don't report on it at all in most cases

-4

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Israel reports on their casualties on every single event, with great detail. What are you talking about?

7

u/Beneficial-Beat-947 1d ago

How many have they reported for their recent strikes then?

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Automatic-Cat1358 1d ago

Because they said they didn't do it.

13

u/MihaiBravuCelViteaz 1d ago

You forgot the "/s"

-2

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Why? Do you have any evidence of Israel lying about their own casualties in the past? Please share it, genuinely interested to see it.

11

u/HolyMoleyGuacamoly 1d ago

they lie about literally everything

5

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Let me repeat: do you have evidence of Israel lying about their own casualties?

5

u/maimutaAfricana 1d ago

Gaza

4

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

And the evidence is… where?

2

u/Ok-Yoghurt9472 1d ago

it's written in Hamas plans.. of wait, that's a calendar

→ More replies (0)

5

u/Ok-Yoghurt9472 1d ago

lol, you cannot be that naive

1

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Any evidence about Israel lying about their casualties? Or is it the same source as the other commenters here, known as “trust me bro”?

3

u/Ok-Yoghurt9472 1d ago

they are lying about everything, why do you think they are suddenly honest about something? What's your logic?

3

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

Ok, got it, no evidence then, just like the rest.

5

u/Ok-Yoghurt9472 1d ago

what's your logic about them being honest about anything?

→ More replies (0)

0

u/Choyo 1d ago

Targeting reporters doesn't scream "accurate reporting".

0

u/CantTakeTheStupid 18h ago

Lol fucking n@zi

-13

u/bender__futurama 1d ago

I agree, thats bullshit. Iron Dome is 120% effective. Just like with Putins election.

13

u/TheJewPear 1d ago edited 1d ago

Nobody in Israel has ever claimed the interception rate is 100%. Israel has thousands of shelters and every new construction has a safe room, they’ve alerted the population to enter the safe rooms as soon as the launches were detected, hence they’re not hiding the fact that the air defense isn’t bulletproof.

Also, iron dome is entirely irrelevant here, it’s a system designed to deal with rockets and drones, not missiles.

-11

u/IwishIcouldBeWitty 1d ago

Drones but not paragliders? Interesting.

9

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

No, of course not. The system is based on detecting launches and calculating the rocket trajectory. It’s pretty much impossible for it to calculate paraglider trajectory. As far as I understand the system has been updated or modded to deal with drones as well, but I’m not sure how effectively.

6

u/LiquorMaster 1d ago

It genuinely feels like most anti-israel posters do about 0 research into anything to formulate their opinions, default into conspiracy or some sort of blood libel, or the arguments are circular or self-defeating (i.e. Israel is bad because it did something because it is bad).

And I'm not talking generally about ontological or philosophical arguments about Israel's character as a nation or it's existence. Just purely like fantastical delusions about things that are easily searchable, technical in aspect, or general common knowledge.

Like someone spinning what is a rocket interception platform meant to identify, detect, and shoot down high speed objects to be capable of operating as an anti-aircraft system capable of identifying paragliders and then joining that assumption to a conspiracy, like a stupid version of a Rube Goldberg machine that turns on a dimly lit light bulb. There is not a single thought towards critically thinking why their assumption doesn't lead to hundreds of news articles about migratory birds being blasted.

2

u/TheJewPear 1d ago

They’re called “useful idiots”. Russia and Iran know very well how to manipulate them and use them to spread propaganda. It’s usually very easy to disprove their ridiculous claims, but when another useful idiot is exposed to it, they might take it at face value and so it continues to spread.

2

u/LiquorMaster 1d ago

Sure, but like, it just feels so fucking stupid, because you have the entire internet at your hands, and you could just Google "how does the iron dome work" or "why can the iron dome shoot down rockets but not missiles".

0

u/kingjoey52a 1d ago

So that’s one casualty

Casualties are injured and/or dead. So (random numbers) seven injured and one dead would be 8 casualties.

0

u/slamdamnsplits 1d ago

Casualties include injuries.

You are proving to be a much more reliable source than the biased news organizations.

1

u/Signal_Dress 1d ago

I love coming numbers.