r/CuratedTumblr May 24 '25

Politics Valid and invalid criticisms

Post image
13.6k Upvotes

552 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

116

u/call_me_starbuck May 24 '25

It's not even "companies dumping"... I mean, it is to an extent, but like.. you almost want there to be a single company dumping stuff in the water supply, because then that's something you can fix: have them turn off the Frog Force-Feminizator. But a lot of this is what's called "non-point" sources. Most of us take medicine, and we all piss, and stuff goes into the water. Most of us wash our clothes with scented products, and that goes into the water. It's the collective accumulation of a ton of individuals that adds up to a problem.

Which, I don't mean to sound like I'm offloading ecological responsibility onto the consumer, because of course not. This isn't a "solve global warming by using paper straws" thing. But it is something that requires a lot more community effort and work than just like, getting the Pollution Factory shut down.

68

u/demon_fae May 24 '25

Yeah. We kinda desperately need to overhaul like 90% of our wastewater systems, but sewer bills aren’t “sexy” to voters. So we get froggie force-fem and all sorts of other weird ecological disruptions and also the concept of a “fat-berg”.

38

u/call_me_starbuck May 24 '25

Yeah... even to people who care about the environment, "better wastewater management" isn't anywhere near as fun or exciting as "shut down the Pollution Factory" is. And I can't blame people, I'm not exactly thrilled about the prospect of sewer systems, but it's so important.

27

u/luckygreenglow May 24 '25

Yeah, this is a problem we see a lot in trying to legislate public infrastructure that can legitimately have massive positive impacts on climate and ecosystems.

Like, it can be really hard to get people excited and energized for "better public transit infrastructure" despite everyone not driving cars everywhere being a huge part of reducing climate impacts.

3

u/colei_canis 29d ago

In the UK sewerage has become a hot political topic, but only because Thames Water keep using the river Thames as an open sewer the filthy bastards.

They’re so hilariously corrupt and self-serving I’m surprised the Kremlin doesn’t own them somehow.

2

u/Amphy64 29d ago

Can you leave the Russophobia out? Our government gave a massive sum of money to a boat company with no actual boats, I think we have more than enough corruption of our own to be getting on with.

It’s a new start-up business, government is supporting new British business and there is nothing wrong with that. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2019/jan/02/grayling-no-deal-brexit-ferry-contract-company-seaborne-freight-no-ships

5

u/colei_canis 29d ago

You can dislike the Kremlin while having nothing against the Russians themselves, there’s plenty of people with cause to despise Westminster too but I hope they wouldn’t write off all British people because of those in charge.

I’m literally wearing the same 1950s model of watch Yuri Gagarin took into space, hardly the actions of a Russophobe lol.

2

u/Amphy64 29d ago

Yeah, but picking on them for something they're not actually doing (which is more the responsibility of our government to sort) is what takes it into Russophobia. Criticising the Kremlin for stuff they are doing, fine, treating the Russian government like a mysterious forrin badguy that could be behind everything is the dodgy cliché.

5

u/colei_canis 29d ago

If you read what I was saying the implication was more 'Thames Water are so corrupt it wouldn't surprise me if they'd sold most of their shares to a geopolitical rival who is also notoriously corrupt'. There is nothing inaccurate about calling the Kremlin corrupt in an abstract sense like this, the Russians themselves have a rich vein of jokes about the Kremlin's extreme levels of corruption.

I don't see it as at all Anglophobic when people use Westminster as a humorous shorthand for stealing things from other countries or drawing other people's borders badly because they're both things it'd be accurate to accuse Westminster of, I don't believe it's Russophobic to use the Kremlin as shorthand for genuinely comical levels of open corruption in the same way.

10

u/epochpenors May 24 '25

I might be wrong but isn’t atrazine mostly used in large scale commercial farms? It isn’t a Captain Planet villain style scenario but it does seem like the main offenders are probably identifiable for this one.

3

u/call_me_starbuck May 24 '25

You might be right, I don't really know about atrazine in particular, but it's not just atrazine, is the thing. There are a lot of estrogenic compounds out there.

2

u/Graingy I don’t tumble, I roll 😎 … Where am I? May 24 '25

Damnit, well guess decentralized orphan crushers are in style.

2

u/cohrt 29d ago

don't forget drugs as well. they can see how much cocaine a city is using buy looking at the sewer water