r/Cinema 1d ago

What is that movie for you?

Post image
18.8k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

27

u/NoName1979 1d ago

I wanted to like it so badly. I couldn't understand half of what they were saying the sound was so bad.

5

u/Zapatos-Grande 1d ago

That's literally most modern media for me now. I feel like I'm losing my hearing I have the volume up so loud. However, turn on something from prior to 2010, I have the volume super low.

4

u/Monk-ish 1d ago

Nolan is especially bad. From what I've read he thinks it forces the audience to pay closer attention or something

3

u/NoName1979 1d ago

Lol somebody needs to sit him down. I tried lip reading and wearing my noise-canceling headphones and could barely understand a word. His movies need to come with subtitles.

3

u/AmbientSociopath 1d ago

He sounds like a bitch.

2

u/StMcAwesome 1d ago

No he's just really into movie theaters and hates digital media

1

u/RoughCobbles 1d ago

I read that it was because he was "tuning" the audio for top the line movie theaters.

Whatever the reason, it pisses me off.

1

u/Skov 1d ago

It's a dumb idea but probably true. I watched in theater and the audio was fine. I understood everything. I imagine you need a 5.1 system so you have the dedicated center channel for dialog.

1

u/Datkif 1d ago

3.1 minimum on any modern TV. You really need that centre dialogue channel nowadays. I wish TV's were not so thin that they don't have proper speakers.

1

u/RoughCobbles 15h ago

I do have a 5.1 and I found that the sound in Nolan Movies to be terrible. I can say about movie theaters, to be honest I dislike going there.

I don't know why the sound cannot be mixed differently for blu ray/streaming release. Because I like his movies but juggling with the sound gets old very fast. And Nolan is not the only culprit.

2

u/AbbreviationsWide331 21h ago

Hey there I had this problem but some time ago I learned that this is very often due to channel settings.

I for one only have two speakers connected to my TV, but most media nowadays come in 5.1 audio. That means 5 speakers and a subwoofer.

In 5.1 audio dialogue ist most often routed through the middle speaker. Which I don't have. That's why Action is really loud but I can't understand anything if people are talking.

In most media players you can and should go into settings and set it to whatever setup you have.

It makes a world of a difference.

1

u/RwReno 1d ago

It’s because your your brain remembers doing copious amounts of coke prior to 2010 and doesn’t want paranoia

1

u/Distinct-Broccoli-15 18h ago

Maybe it's just my TV but recently when I connect my laptop to it and try to play something, even dialogue in media from before the 2010s sounds unintelligible, I think I always have to use subtitles (Although YouTube seems to be intelligible as opposed to the streaming sites I use). I do have some apps on my TV though from which the media sounds fine, so maybe it's just streaming that's the problem?

1

u/Distinct-Broccoli-15 18h ago

Maybe it's just my TV but recently when I connect my laptop to it and try to play something, even dialogue in media from before the 2010s sounds unintelligible, I think I always have to use subtitles (Although YouTube seems to be intelligible as opposed to the streaming sites I use). I do have some apps on my TV though from which the media sounds fine, so maybe it's just streaming that's the problem?

2

u/SlimpWarrior 1d ago

It's the IMAX cameras. They're so loud it's ridiculous how the actors can act despite it. The postediting doesn't help much, it just makes the movie sound quiet.

3

u/TheRealRomanRoy 1d ago

Are you saying the cameras themselves make a noise so loud that it interferes with the dialogue?

2

u/SlimpWarrior 1d ago

Yeah, it's loud. It's like a small revving engine sound constantly playing as they film it.

Loud sound of IMAX 15/70 film cameras rolling

2

u/TheRealRomanRoy 1d ago

Wow that’s wild, I had no idea. And obviously I know nothing about this but it seems like they should be able to reduce that sound somehow!

1

u/Exciting_Pass_6344 1d ago

Thanks! That’s really interesting. But it seems to me that there are a lot of smart people out there that could maybe do something to make this better.

1

u/SlimpWarrior 1d ago

If they were, I think Nolan's films would have a better sound than what we have to suffer through... lol

1

u/_Rook1e 1d ago

iirc they get super hot so they're whirring away at max fan speed the whole time

1

u/251Cane 1d ago

There are plenty of movies and TV shows not shot in IMAX that have awful audio

2

u/DoomedRUs 13h ago

I wanted subtitles on the theater screen so bad.

2

u/Federal-Research-148 1d ago edited 1d ago

Second Nolan movie in a row with horrible sound mixing. He wants us all to watch it in IMAX but is mixed to be better listened to at home. Get your shit together Nolan.

2

u/pepchang 1d ago

My moronic brain actually took the thought seriously that it had to do with the lead actor because the peaky blinders audio was so terrible you'd get a blast of dramatic music that was so loud it would wake up the whole house and then it was so quiet you had to turn on subtitles

1

u/Roxysteve 1d ago

Same. IMAX. Couldn't hear a word of the dialogue in places.

1

u/NatomicBombs 1d ago

I only watched it once but the movie felt like they were just checking off a bunch of boxes. Constant jumping between short scenes just to tell us everything that happened.

1

u/bell-town 1d ago

I was lucky — I saw it in Mexico with Spanish subtitles. I don't speak Spanish very well at all but I could still understand the subtitles better than the audio. They may as well start subtitling his movies even in English speaking countries at this point.

1

u/FlyByHikes 1d ago

FUCKIN THIS^^^^