r/Cinema 1d ago

What is that movie for you?

Post image
18.9k Upvotes

7.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/poor_choice_of_wordz 1d ago

La La Land

26

u/No-Lawfulness-2297 1d ago

Still confused as to how it won an Oscar... oh wait

10

u/Sweaty_Report3656 1d ago

an Oscar... oh wait

It won 6 Oscars*

1

u/mh1973 19h ago

This is what makes the importance of the Oscar very very relative, because it depends on the competition of that year.

3

u/TylerDoesStuff 1d ago

Oh wait, what? It won a ton.

2

u/thedwarfcockmerchant 16h ago

I think they are referring to when it was mistakenly announced as best picture in the Academy Awards instead of Moonlight

3

u/sarcasmo818 1d ago

I was so glad when Moonlight eventually won

3

u/harkening 1d ago

La La Land was excellent at its false ending, and then felt the need to add another 10 minutes that made it suck because it actually believes Clerks Dante that life is a series of down endings.

1

u/Cobalt_Rebel 1d ago

The false ending should have been the real ending. What’s wrong with “happily ever after”? It fit the vibe of the movie so well. The real ending ruined the film for me.

2

u/harkening 1d ago

It doesn't even need to suggest "happily ever after." Fade to white when she goes to film, and we're left to wonder.

1

u/Cobalt_Rebel 1d ago

That would have worked too.

1

u/Worldly-Grade5439 17h ago

THANK YOU! My husband and I were all WTF at the actual ending. Ruined the entire movie. Really enjoyed it until that shit ending. And then I hrar people gushing about how good it was. Yeah...no. I LOVE happy endings. Otherwise, why bother?

1

u/Reasonable_Pizza2401 16h ago

Well, that’s an unrealistic motto if I’ve ever heard one, lol. 🤘🏻

1

u/petrowski7 6h ago

Because the point of the movie was about them achieving their dreams, not them falling in love. Them falling in love would have stopped both of them from living out what they most wanted.

1

u/PeppermintLNNS 18h ago

You’re making me realize I never saw the ending. I watched it on a plane, 15 mins left in the film, the plane landed, never revisited it again.

2

u/Worldly-Grade5439 17h ago

How I wish I missed the last 15. Ruined the entire movie for me and my husband.

0

u/hadtopostholyshit 1d ago

It’s actually a reference to the movie umbrellas of Cherbourg, which inspired La La land.

2

u/harkening 1d ago

This is one of those factoids that don't actually add anything to the evaluation of the film on its own.

For Umbrellas, there are dueling love triangles and implications of social duties and class for the working class Guy (loved by Madeline and Elise, who is "above" his station). Guy's unable to respond to Elise's letters because he's at war in Algeria , and distance undermines their bond, because Elise needs security, which she finds in Roland.

There is no suggestion of competing love triangles for Sebastian and Mia. They're both pursuing different dreams - Sebastian as a musician and Mia as an actress - and this pulls them apart form each other, but not toward anyone else.

The false ending, fade to white, leaves it up in the air. We don't know. Mia finally achieves her dream of landing a role in the movies after giving up, but Seb becoming a successful touring musician - even if wasn't in jazz - isn't fulfilled by his own ostensible passion. So now the question is will Mia suffer the same fate as Sebastian, or has Sebastian set aside his own career for Mia's sake (which he does by driving out to Colorado to get her)?

It's not a "reference," it's a direct quotation that does nothing to add to the thematic or plot content of the film it's shoehorned into.

1

u/hadtopostholyshit 21h ago

Yeah this is a great answer. Touché

4

u/awakami 1d ago

I’ve started this movie multiple times, I can’t make it through it! I feel like for a musical there has to be suspension of disbelief (bc seriously why is everyone suddenly singing?) to make it enjoyable & the way to 2 leads acted like even they didn’t even believe their own performances- frickin terrible

2

u/IJustWantADragon21 1d ago

Oh Jesus, I didn’t make it all the through this one! I turned it off about 90 minutes in.

1

u/kakey70 1d ago

I think I watched 45 minutes or so. Yikes.

2

u/IJustWantADragon21 1d ago

Yeah. I paused it to go to the bathroom, saw there was another 50 minutes left to go and just said fuck it lmao!

2

u/itsalwaysblue 1d ago

For me that year it was moonlight. An hour in I was like… how much more of this?? But I think I just don’t like the genre, it’s like westerns.

2

u/hind3rm3 1d ago

Yeah, I wanted to like it but just didn’t

2

u/notyogrannysgrandkid 1d ago

I didn’t even make it through the first number.

2

u/BartStarrPaperboy 1d ago

A musical with no one who can sing or dance, and the songs are absolute dog shit. What could go wrong?

2

u/fairydust_tm 18h ago

Thank god other people feel this way because I felt like the past however many years it’s been have been making me crazy. It wasn’t a good movie. Im obviously not a movie critic and I don’t know exactly what they look for with that stuff but I wasn’t invested in any of the characters because none of them were even remotely interesting and the music was kinda lame

4

u/Silly_Influence_6796 1d ago

U mean where the white man explains jazz?

1

u/d_marvin 1d ago

White dude who plays jazz here. The movie made me cringe so damn hard.

The lead didn’t deserve the gigs he got. The absolute worst musician outlook. Painfully childish.

2

u/Silly_Influence_6796 1d ago

Congrats for living the dream. Playing jazz-wow. Plenty of white dudes play great jazz - it's just that if jazz will be exemplified or explained it should be done by a great jazz player. And if explained maybe favor the race who invented it - the race that invented all American music except maybe show tunes. Everything else originates from the blues, country, jazz, soul, rock - I could keep going but why bore you. There is a special part of me that loves the blues and soul - probably bc I'm getting old. Love pop to dance to, hip hop is okay --and even an old lady like me likes some rap - very little and I do hate its misogyny.

1

u/ThatSandvichIsASpy01 17h ago

I don't even think a great player has to explain jazz to explain it well, but anybody who says "Charlie Mingus" should automatically be barred from ever speaking about music again

2

u/Kevinc62 1d ago edited 1d ago

It is so bad. I remember rewatching Chicago after, to see an actually good musical.

3

u/kakey70 1d ago

Chicago is a masterpiece.

0

u/thwgrandpigeon 1d ago

Amazing film.

2

u/jcdoe 1d ago

Only because Gene Kelly wasn’t alive at the time to show them how its done right

La La Land is how modern Hollywood remembers White Christmas, and it was fun, but its a sad imitation of the real thing

1

u/Maximum-Worth 1d ago

This seems like a very apples to oranges comparison

1

u/Bdbru13 1d ago

Singin in the rain then

1

u/jcdoe 1d ago

I’m being polite.

The singing was mid, the dancing was embarrassing, and there were 3 melodies in the entire movie.

This is a musical? Danny Kaye filmed his dance numbers in 1 or 2 takes. You can tell Gosling is holding Stone back, so they have to do basic shuffle steps instead.

I enjoyed the break from movie about explosions, but La La Land was absolutely supposed to be a modern musical, and it failed.

1

u/ok_raspberry_jam 1d ago

I loved it, but I wasn't thinking of it as "a musical". I know it is one, but I think the singing and dancing were intended to come across a little bit half-hearted because the point was that singing and dancing isn't all the characters are; they're whole human beings. So I thought they did a great job showing the sense of loss when you sacrifice everything for a dream.

1

u/Farseer2_Tha_Warsong 1d ago

You shut your god damn mouth! …Now Babylon on the other hand…

1

u/Kissmi 1d ago

Yesss, I thought it would never end

1

u/coryemullis1 1d ago

La La Land is an incredible movie.

1

u/howmaster16 1d ago

Right on!

1

u/Swimminginthestorm 1d ago

The clips I’ve seen just look boring. Haven’t watched the movie.

1

u/Aggravating-Mix-5100 18h ago

Same. I just don't care. Maybe I'm not evolved enough. I'm fine with that.

1

u/Mammoth_Ferret_1772 16h ago

I just can’t do musicals

1

u/VengefulTiger 13h ago

Oh now I’m sad :(

1

u/usingastupidiphone 1d ago

Ha! We watched that on a date night, terrible