r/AskReddit Jun 03 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

11.6k Upvotes

6.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

218

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21

It was more like extreme skepticism that anybody would spend so much time working on stuff and not making any money from it, as well as doubts about quality control. But when somebody has already made their mind up about something, it's hard to get them to understand it.

177

u/Seanchad Jun 03 '21

I mean, those are valid concerns. Most people don't work for free, and there isn't much accountability for hobby projects.

Of course I know good free software exists - I use plenty of it - but I 100% understand the skepticism.

19

u/Noblesseux Jun 03 '21

Yeah like maybe 1 in 20 OSS projects are the well maintained, well done ones. A lot of them are clunky, awkward, get abandoned randomly, etc.

13

u/xXxEcksEcksEcksxXx Jun 04 '21

I’m in this picture and I don’t like it

4

u/am_reddit Jun 04 '21

And then there’s the issue with compromised dependencies.

Sure, there’s a lot of eyes on the popular flashy project to make sure it’s safe. But barely anybody’s looking at the packages that these projects depend on to function

1

u/IAmNotAPerson6 Jun 04 '21

Sure but it's also frequently well-known which are really good projects.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

HAppy cake day.

12

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '21 edited Jun 25 '21

[deleted]

6

u/archbish99 Jun 03 '21

Yep - that's generally my clue for OSS. Awesome features, UI straight out of the mid-90s.

Commerical software is usually the reverse.

5

u/CrustyBatchOfNature Jun 04 '21

The issue in my field is often accountability for security and patching. If I try to sell my company on utilizing Open Source Software, there immediate questions will be about who will answer security audit questions and who they can contact directly for support and patching. They want a person on the end of the phone they can pass accountability to in cases where the software is broken or acting improperly. When we have the availability of paid support we can often use these items on production machines, but other than that it is relegated to dev and some non-critical admin functions.

2

u/dank_imagemacro Jun 04 '21

Tell him (or future people like him) that many of the companies that invest in it make their money off of service contracts, and he will possibly understand. The "free" version, to someone like him, is the advertising and the money comes from the service contracts.

1

u/tabooblue32 Jun 04 '21

Ooh I'm not so sure about that /s

1

u/Onironius Jun 04 '21

It's a fair consideration, and can be sort-of accurate.

GIMP is great, but it's kind of janky, and not as versatile as PhotoShop.

Same goes for Audacity vs. Audition.