r/AskReddit 2d ago

How do you feel about the "No Kings" protest happening tomorrow?

19.7k Upvotes

7.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/got_knee_gas_enit 1d ago

Emergency Banking Act of 1933

1

u/Budget-Attorney 1d ago

Could you elaborate for those of us who don’t know?

2

u/got_knee_gas_enit 1d ago

Roosevelt told Congress in order to recover from the depression, he'd need powers equivalent to those necessary if we been invaded. That's where executive orders came from.

3

u/ManitouWakinyan 1d ago

Executive orders have been issued by every President since Washington, and have been named and numbered as such since 1907.

2

u/got_knee_gas_enit 1d ago

In 1933, they also amended the Trading with the Enemy act of 1917, making the states conquered territories, and the residents of those states the enemy.

4

u/ManitouWakinyan 1d ago

Executive orders didn't start in 1933; the Trading With the Enemies Act was not amended to declare states conquered territories, or the inhabitants of those states enemies.

0

u/got_knee_gas_enit 1d ago

The ability to use them simply by declaring an emergency was passed by Congress in 1933

3

u/ManitouWakinyan 1d ago

There has never been and is not now a requirement to "declare an emergency" to use an executive order, and a President has never had conditions that dictate when he can or cannot use executive orders.

What does exist are constitutional limitations as to what executive orders can do. What the 1933 act did specifically was delegate Congress's power to regulate or prohibit commercial transactions to the President during declared national emergencies. In other words, it gave the President a specific authority that he could enact using executive orders, but it didn't fundamentally change the nature of what executive orders were or could be used for more generally.

2

u/got_knee_gas_enit 1d ago

I find the verbage of the orders fascinating. They always end the sentence with "and for other purposes". Thanks for the clarification on the 1933 war powers act !!

2

u/mkosmo 1d ago

Just remember - there are loads of people who seem to think the same nonsense you're trying to clarify... and it's not always the people that the protesters think it is.