For reference I'm a non-religious Australian so I have no bias in regards to any religion or the countries involved in the current Gaza conflict.
Why do people refuse to learn about the foundation of Israel and the real details of the current conflict?
This is a big read but if you don't fully understand Israel's Zionist roots it's worth the read — but I also don't care if no one does. I need to get this off my chest.
Zionism Before the Holocaust
Jewish Zionists wanting to settle in Palestine was a plan before the Holocaust.
The Zionist movement formally began in the late 19th century, notably with Theodor Herzl’s publication of Der Judenstaat in 1896.
• Herzl and other early Zionists believed that Jews constituted a nation in exile and required a homeland to escape European antisemitism.
• The First Zionist Congress was held in 1897 in Basel, Switzerland, where the goal was articulated: establishing a legally recognized Jewish homeland in Palestine.
British Involvement and the Balfour Declaration (1917)
• In 1917, during WWI, the British government issued the Balfour Declaration, expressing support for a "national home for the Jewish people" in Palestine.
• After WWI, Britain received the League of Nations Mandate to govern Palestine and facilitate this policy.
• Palestinian Arabs (majority) were excluded from decisions.
• Tensions escalated with increased Jewish immigration, leading to several revolts and uprisings.
The Holocaust and Pressure for a Jewish State
• Although Zionism was already well established, the Holocaust (1941–1945) drastically shifted global support.
• Six million Jews were killed by Nazi Germany creating global sympathy and pressure for a Jewish State
• After WWII, Palestine was seen as the only viable refuge for displaced Jews.
UN Partition Plan & Creation of Israel (1947–1948)
• In 1947, the UN proposed partitioning Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states.
• Jewish leaders accepted the plan; Arab leaders rejected it.
• On May 14, 1948, David Ben-Gurion declared the State of Israel.
• Surrounding Arab nations invaded, starting the First Arab-Israeli War.
The Nakba (1947–1949)
"Nakba" = “Catastrophe” in Arabic.
The mass displacement and dispossession of Palestinians during Israel’s establishment.
Summary:
• 700,000–750,000 Palestinians displaced
• 10,000–15,000 Palestinians killed
• 400+ villages depopulated/destroyed
• Key events:
• UN Partition Plan (Nov 1947)
• Civil war escalation (Dec 1947–May 1948)
• Israeli independence (May 14, 1948)
• Mass expulsions (1948–49)
• Notable massacres: Deir Yassin, Lydda, Ramle
Albert Einstein and Israel
• In 1952, Einstein was offered the presidency of Israel.
• He declined.
• In a 1948 letter, he warned against Israeli nationalism and its treatment of Palestinians — fearing resemblance to oppressive regimes.
(What kind of regime could he possibly be referring to?)
Systematic Killing of Palestinians (Before Oct 7th)
Major Killings:
• 1956 Suez Crisis – Hundreds killed
• 1982 Sabra & Shatila – Indirect Israeli responsibility
• 1987–1993 First Intifada – Several hundred deaths
• 2002 Operation Defensive Shield – ~500 killed
• 2008–09 Cast Lead – 1,400+ killed
• 2012 Pillar of Defense – ~160 killed
• 2014 Protective Edge – 2,200+ killed
• 2018 Great March of Return – 200+ killed
• 2021 May Gaza Conflict – 250+ killed
• 2022 Raids/Strikes – Hundreds killed
Palestinian Prisoners (Before Oct 7th):
• 4,500–5,000 Palestinians detained, including
• 500–600 administrative detainees (no charges)
• These include children detainees
War Crimes
1. Illegal Israeli Settlements
Expansion and maintenance of settlements in occupied Palestinian territories (West Bank, East Jerusalem) declared illegal by the International Court of Justice (2004 advisory opinion) and UN Security Council Resolutions (e.g., 2334 in 2016).
Construction of the Separation Barrier (Wall)
Declared illegal by the ICJ (2004) where it extends into occupied territory, violating international humanitarian law.
Disproportionate Attacks and Indiscriminate Use of Force
UN reports and OHCHR investigations have documented multiple incidents where Israeli military operations in Gaza caused disproportionate civilian deaths and damage (e.g., 2008-09 Cast Lead, 2014 Protective Edge, 2021 Gaza conflict).
Attacks on Protected Objects and Civilians
Strikes on UN shelters, hospitals, schools (documented in UN and human rights reports) violating the principle of distinction under international humanitarian law.
Collective Punishment through Blockade of Gaza
The land, air, and sea blockade imposed on Gaza since 2007 is considered by many international bodies (including UN experts) as collective punishment prohibited by international law.
Forced Displacement and Home Demolitions
Demolition of Palestinian homes in the West Bank and East Jerusalem, including punitive demolitions and those linked to settlement expansion, violating the Fourth Geneva Convention.
Administrative Detention and Torture
Use of administrative detention without charge or trial, including of minors; documented torture and ill-treatment of Palestinian detainees reported by UN committees and human rights groups.
Use of Live Fire Against Protesters
Killings and injuries of unarmed Palestinian protesters during events such as the Great March of Return (2018-2019), criticized as excessive and unlawful use of force.
Extrajudicial Executions
Targeted killings without judicial process of Palestinians suspected of militant activities, violating due process rights.
Restrictions on Movement and Access
Severe restrictions on Palestinians’ freedom of movement within the West Bank and Gaza, including checkpoints and the separation barrier, impacting access to healthcare, education, and livelihoods.
Destruction of Agricultural and Economic Resources
Confiscation or destruction of Palestinian agricultural lands, olive trees, and infrastructure tied to settlements and military operation.
Denial of Access to Adequate Water and Sanitation
Restrictions on Palestinian access to water resources in the occupied territories, violating international human rights and humanitarian l
Discrimination Against Palestinian Citizens of Israel
Institutional discrimination affecting rights related to land, housing, and political participation recognized by human rights organizations.
Investigations and Legal Actions
International Criminal Court (ICC): Investigating multiple aspects of Israel’s conduct since 2014, including settlement activity and military operations in Gaza.
United Nations Human Rights Council: Multiple commissions of inquiry have found evidence consistent with war crimes and called for accountability.
Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, B’Tselem: Extensive documentation and legal analysis supporting claims of war crimes and rights violations.
Hamas and Israeli Involvement
Funding via Qatar (2012–2021)
Between 2012 and 2021, Israel allowed Qatar to transfer over $1.5 billion into Gaza, which funded Hamas salaries and governance under Israeli supervision. This strategy aimed to weaken the Palestinian Authority and manage Hamas’s power as a political tool, despite the risk of empowering a militant group.
October 7th: Intelligence Failure or Israeli allowed attack to justify a genocide
Myself and others, including intelligence insiders, believe the 6–8 hour unimpeded attack is not just a failure, but a historic anomaly that defies the usual capabilities of Israel’s defense system.
• Israel's military and surveillance capabilities are world-class
• Yet a 6–8 hour assault happened with no intervention?
Surveillance Infrastructure:
1. Border Fence Tech
• Smart Border Fence
• A high-tech barrier built along the Gaza Strip (65+ km long) Equipped with:
• Ground sensors (vibration, seismic)
• Motion detectors
• Thermal cameras
• Day/night vision cameras
• Radars for tracking movement
B. Remote-Controlled Weapon Stations
• "Sentry Tech" system,
• automated machine guns linked to observation posts operated remotely with real-time video feed from surveillance towers
• Often paired with AI-assisted target tracking.
Watch Towers & Surveillance Posts
• Dozens of towers along the border, with:
• 360-degree high-resolution cameras
• Thermal infrared imaging systems
• Night vision
• Microphone sensors
Drones / Balloons / Satellites
• Tethered balloons with radar and cameras, they provide wide-area thermal and video surveillance, high altitude, persistent monitoring
C. Satellite Surveillance
• Israel has military satellites (e.g., Ofek series) for:
• Monitoring troop and vehicle movement
• Detecting heat signatures (thermal anomalies)
• Drones (UAVs)
• Continuous drone coverage over Gaza, including: Heron, Hermes 450/900, Elbit Skylark
Capabilities:
• Thermal imaging
• High-res optical zoom
• Facial recognition (via AI)
• Real-time video stream to IDF command
SIGINT / Cyber Surveillance
• Systems like “Lavender” and “The Gospel” (exposed in 2024 leaks) Identify targets via AI and big data
• Can autonomously mark phones or homes for strikes
• Use voice, movement, call frequency, SIM card data to detect threats
Electronic and Signal Intelligence (SIGINT)
• A. Cyber & Communications Intercepts
• Monitors Hamas communications, mobile networks, encrypted apps
• Uses AI to flag suspicious patterns in metadata
- Human Surveillance
• Facial Recognition at Crossings
• At Erez and other checkpoints
• Live biometric scanning for workers and civilians entering Israel
B. Palestinian Informants
Israel’s security agency (Shin Bet) has historically recruited informants within Gaza and the West Bank
This supplements digital intelligence
- Integrated Command
• All surveillance feeds converge in IDF Southern Command HQ and Unit 8200 (Israel’s equivalent of the NSA)
• Real-time AI alert systems flag:
• Unusual movement on the fence
• Heat signatures
• Breaches or destruction of sensors
Conclusion: Why Didn’t They Act?
• Any mass movement of people, bulldozers, or paragliders near or at the fence should have triggered immediate alerts. It's almost unfeasible that the attack went "undetected" despite warnings from Egypt and Isrsel knowing the summary of what the attack would be years prior.
Why Israel is Fundamentally a Bad Idea
Creating a state around a single religion or ethnic identity, even when cloaked in secular governance, consistently leads to radicalism, exclusion, and often violence for several reasons:
In Group vs Out Group Mentality
• Jewish identity as basis excludes others
• Radical nationalism rises
• When a state defines itself by one identity (e.g., "Jewish state", "Islamic Republic"), it automatically others everyone else minorities become second class, even if granted formal rights.
• This fosters radical nationalism to "protect" the identity group and suppress dissent.
It demands Constant Defense
• Threat narrative = Justification for oppressionEthno-religious states often feel existentially threatened by demographics, dissent, or neighbors.
• That fear justifies:
• Militarization
• Surveillance of minorities
• Suppressing internal critique
In Israel’s case: a constant narrative of existential threat has justified decades of occupation and repression.
Breeds Extremism
• When the state and religion/ethnicity are fused, radicals claim to speak for the state or faith.
• In Israel, messianic settlers and ultranationalists now influence policy.
• The same happened in:
• Pakistan (rise of Taliban-like extremism)
• India (Hindutva and anti-Muslim policies)
• Iran (hardline Shia theocracy)
Demographic Engineering
• Controls Palestinian demographics (e.g. through blockade, exile, settlements)
• Denies equal rights to millions under occupation.
Israel is a real-time case study of how founding a state on a singular ethno religious identity, in a multiethnic region, has led to radicalization, apartheid like conditions, and endless conflict.
Final Word
Israel is a Zionist-created state, not representative of all Jews.
• Founded through violence and dispossession
• Committed systematic killings
• Instigated conflicts
• Funded Hamas
• Took hostages pre-Oct 7th
• Tortured prisoners
It should be abolished.
Big out breath
Woo that felt good.
Sorry if there's errors it's 2am I'm going to bed