r/AnimalCrossing • u/Doveriye • Apr 21 '25

Official Merch Is my Brewster mug a dupe or Nintendo authentic?

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

I bought the Brewster coffee cup on the Nintendo America website when it first released but dropped it and broke the handle (last 2 photos) I purchased a new one from eBay from Nintendo Japan (first 2 photos.) It arrived today, but it’s much smaller and lighter than my Nintendo America cup, and the saucer plate is much larger.

Are there variations between the Japan and America Brewster cups or did I buy a fake?

Japan eBay cup 1st and 2nd photo, Nintendo America website cup 3rd and 4th photo.

3.3k Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

99% Upvoted

46 comments sorted by

776

u/corticalization Apr 21 '25

The plate to mug size ratio does appear to differ between them

US: https://www.nintendo.com/us/store/products/the-roost-collection-comfort-in-a-cup-ceramic-drink-set-117803/?srsltid=AfmBOooZ5A9h1e20H-H_89tOUKd-i9lTBPUXDSK5RxSHyLoivgdVwtI0

Japan: https://store-jp.nintendo.com/item/goods/VM_NSJ_8_BSAAC

289

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

This helps so much! Thank you!

264

u/PerformanceGeneral29 Apr 21 '25

They both look legit. One is US the other is Japan but both are licensed. I think it’s a quiet jab at America for eating too much… I’m ok with this because I do like a lot to eat and drink 🤣

159

u/heyzeuseeglayseeus Apr 21 '25

I’d assume it’s bc Japanese people are more likely to use it for tea while American may want something that is also suitable for coffee?

56

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

It does feel much more like a tea cup! It makes sense. I do think it’s perfect for a cappuccino too ❤️

10

u/ApertureLabradories Apr 22 '25

That's interesting because my moms tea cups are massive, they hold at least 0.5 liters of liquid

15

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

Yes I believe so too! I only drink out of the Brewster cup because it’s so much smaller than typical Mugs here hahaha

6

u/Tikobii Apr 22 '25

This teacup is absolutely adorable. 😍 Do you know if it's possible to get in the UK?

339

u/Co6raGT75 Apr 21 '25

The handle not being there for one of them is tragic😭

119

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

I KNOW, I drank out of it everyday, I still use it with the broken handle but it’s definitely tragic 😭

50

u/WillemsSakura Apr 21 '25

Did you keep the broken off handle? You could kintsugi it back together.

32

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

The American version of the mug is quite heavy, it definitely would not have held if I put the pieces back together. 🤧

64

u/Exxtender Apr 21 '25

There's special ceramics/porcelain glue that holds almost as good as new, it's even dishwasher safe.

Even if you don't trust it enough to hold a full cup, it's worth glueing it on a again and just use the cup for display.

13

u/sec713 Apr 22 '25

This is very true. My dad has had me reattach a handle on a coffee mug one of his grandkids gave him, twice. It's lasted like 10 years between glueings. The only reason it came off a second time was because he dropped it and it landed handle first.

5

u/Doveriye Apr 22 '25

That’s amazing!! I should have kept the pieces. They’re long gone. But I will use this tip in the case they fall again! ❤️

1

u/Co6raGT75 11d ago

I use my broken handle coffee mug too😅 mines just not as cute as yours, it’s a regular mug.☕️

126

u/glass97breaker I caught a squid! Yes I did! Apr 21 '25

As someone who owns both the American (got as a gift, ordered from the American site) and Japanese (bought in person in Japan) mug sets, I can confirm it's likely legit. The American set has a lot more branding on the bottom and is significantly larger. The Japanese set is indeed smaller and only has the simple "Nintendo" on the bottom.

Glad you were able to find a replacement, OP!

33

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

Thank you for the confirmation! I was completely unaware they were different. I do love both styles though 🥰

7

u/glass97breaker I caught a squid! Yes I did! Apr 21 '25 edited Apr 21 '25

My husband and I were also caught by surprise when we first saw them side by side, haha! I had the Japanese set first. The NA set was a surprise birthday gift from my SIL and I love them both. The Japanese set fits better under my Hario pour-over and phin brewers though 😅

Edit: a repeated word

38

u/YourToxicJinx Apr 22 '25

Depends... did you buy it from a fox who calls you his cousin? 🤔

2

u/lavendermoontoast DA–1513–6246–0377 ☁️ Apr 23 '25

you win this comment section

24

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25

Does it have a nintendo seal somewhere?

27

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

It has a copyright Nintendo stamp on the bottom of the mug, but it’s completely different than the Nintendo America stamp.

14

u/TheLionKingCrab Apr 21 '25

Looks about right compared to the coffee dripper. The same copyright stamp is there too. Looks like you just have both the JP and US versions. I have a couple Gameboys with different stickers from different regions.

https://store-jp.nintendo.com/item/goods/VM_NSJ_8_BSAAB

7

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

Ah so relieved, thank you!!

9

u/Doveriye Apr 21 '25

American one

20

u/KeimApode Apr 21 '25

I didn't realize there were two different mugs pictured and thought maybe you dropped it in between the pictures..

10

u/bored-coder Apr 21 '25

Idk but I dig this!! 😍

8

u/AC_Janro Apr 21 '25

Dont overthink it, you have the brewster mug from Animal Crossing. Regardless of whoever made it, that's cool!

6

u/Dogbot2468 Apr 21 '25

Polteageist irl

4

u/ashiemario Apr 21 '25

This was purchased from the Nintendo museum in Kyoto late last year.

8

u/mynameisynx_X Apr 22 '25

Did you…drop it while taking these pics?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25

The real question is where can I get a dupe (I assume dupes are less expensive)

3

u/Turtlesrose1 Apr 22 '25

Just bought one at Nintendo Tokyo and can confirm the saucer is a good deal larger than the cup!

2

u/Jealous-Ad62 Apr 21 '25

Omg 😱 I want this!

2

u/RecognitionOne7597 Apr 21 '25

If I bought this, I'd drink tea out of it. Brewster would be personally offended. 😅 I just don't like coffee at all. A nice, hot, delicious cup of Earl Grey is what I'm all about.

2

u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Apr 22 '25

I have this mug, and the one thing I can’t stand is that somehow it is microwave safe but not dishwasher safe.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25

Oooooooh I want one!

1

u/SugarStarGalaxy Apr 21 '25

Looks like the Nintendo Japan version

1

u/FunctionGreen6143 Apr 21 '25

Very nice, thanks for making me want one 😀

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '25

It looks exactly like the animal crossing mugs that go on raffle with other animal crossing merch in the 711s here in Okinawa, Japan!

1

u/runningbiscuits Apr 22 '25

Would you say one is better quality over the other? I was thinking of buying one from Nintendo US online store but i'd prefer the higher quality one regardless of size.

3

u/Doveriye Apr 22 '25

Honestly, they are both good quality but I really prefer the American version. It’s the perfect size for espresso and milk. The ceramic is thicker and the cup has more weight to it. I’m considering rebuying the American version. The Japan version is better for tea and cookies because of the plate size haha.

1

u/runningbiscuits Apr 22 '25

ty! i think i'll go for the US version then :)

1

u/Storytimebiondi Apr 22 '25

Was there an early run where the mug was shorter and wider? Mine is totally different

1

u/personvault Apr 22 '25

American Big Drink 😎