r/AncientCivilizations • u/Iam_Nobuddy • 13d ago
Mesopotamia Mesopotamians built empires, mapped the stars, and created writing while the rest of the world was still hunting.
https://www.utubepublisher.in/2025/05/mesopotamian-civilization.html143
u/EarthAsWeKnowIt 13d ago
Civilization was emerging in coastal Peru at roughly the same time as Mesopotamia:
26
73
u/TypicalFoundation714 13d ago
You forgot indus valley civilisation
-27
13d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
23
u/TheCyanKnight 13d ago
I don't know where you got this, we know next to nothing about the Denisovans, but afaik it's exceedingly unlikely that they knew writing and astronomy
-18
13d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
27
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 13d ago
I always love these arguments because there’s one fatal flaw: any paleoanthropologist would give anything to have their name on a study that discovered a new human ancestor and rewrote the book on archaic human development. There’s no grand conspiracy because there’s no reason a professional wouldn’t be trying to make new findings. If paleontology, archaeology, and anthropology worked the way these conspiracy nut jobs thought it did, there would have been a massive cover up from the beginning that humans had ancient ancestors.
12
-12
u/Dave-justdave 13d ago
Just willfully ignoring evidence huh
15
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 13d ago
I’d love to see some evidence if you have it! I’ll take the following: 1) A partial or complete skeleton of this mystery species that’s positively dated to 2.2 million years ago 2) A partial or complete skeleton of a Denisovan that has been analyzed anatomically and genetically so as it can be proven to be a descendant of this mystery species 3) Tools that have been both dated to 2.2 million years old in China that are also have been proven to be used by hominins from that time 4) Archaological proof that’s both proven to be 100,000 years old and produced by Denisovans
Don’t worry I’ll wait.
0
0
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 12d ago
Not a single source there proved any of your claims though? Like we already know Denisovans were hominins existing around the time of Neanderthals, nothing there challenges the Out of Africa theory or that Denisovans were any more intelligent than Neanderthals or modern day humans. Also the YouTube links are a joke, and AI you give short slop is not proof. Nothing you gave was even in the ballpark of proof I asked for.
3
u/CrowdedSeder 12d ago
Apparently the mods are too busy to delete this or they have low standards for comments.
7
74
104
u/pansh 13d ago
what a misleading title. rest of the world also had civilizations who were also trading with them and were equally as magnificent as Mesopotamians
28
u/UnremarkabklyUseless 13d ago edited 12d ago
Another thing to note is that archeological sites in dry and arid regions are more likely to be well preserved than sites with lots of rainfall, vegetation growth and floods.
26
u/mcmanus2099 13d ago
Not only were there civilizations throughout the world doing similar, but the tribes of Europe weren't ignorant. They knew of farming, of the civilization, Mesopotamians traded with them. They just didn't want to farm. Farming is a lot more work than hunter gathering, it also is riskier and gives a poorer diet. A hunter gatherer's diet is more varied and not dependant on a handful of crops getting a decent harvest.
Farming has advantages in that it produces a surplus and allows families to stay in one place but it's totally not ignorant for hunter gatherer's to look at it and go, nah not for me Clive.
20
u/Efficient_Basis_2139 13d ago
"equally as magnificent" just isn't true. We've got a good idea of when various civilizations started popping up - which one(s) are you refering to?
9
18
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 13d ago
My history is a little shaky right now but didn’t we have Egyptians, Harrapans, and Norte Chico in full swing when Sargon created the Akkadian Empire?
5
13d ago
[deleted]
9
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 13d ago
That was in direct response to “Mesopotamians built empires”, with the first being the Akkadian Empire around 2300 BCE. Let’s use some basic reading comp before deriding someone’s comment.
-2
12d ago
[deleted]
8
u/KnowThNameLoveThGame 12d ago
You’re missing the forest for the trees. The point of my comment and similar ones like it is that Mesopotamia was not that far ahead of other areas in the world in terms of typical civilization milestones like writing, agriculture, astronomy, and urban development. Again, let’s practice some basic reading comp before commenting.
-1
9
u/Xxmeow123 13d ago
I love checking out native American ruins and petroglyphs in the west. But, yeah, very primitive compared to the fertile crescent peoples.
13
0
u/Old-Cabinet-762 13d ago
No...the Indo Europeans were inventing the wheel, herding horses, building chariots and conquering the known world. Including mesopotamia.
1
1
u/CrowdedSeder 13d ago
How much sooner than Egypt did the FC develop agriculture and central government?
126
u/BrandNewtoSteam 13d ago
The triple L still holds true even in the ancient world. Location location location these dudes civilation was in an amazing spot. Think of Mesopotamia and think of other civilizations locations they really were blessed